9 Oct 2000, 10:51 UTC
Fwd: A. 99-01-034 SCE's Ex Parte Request for the ImmediateSuspension, etc, 10-5-00
- From
- Roger Yang roger.yang@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 9 Oct 2000 03:51:00 -0700 (PDT)
It looks like SCE's request is similar to PG&E's request. If recovery of undercollected procurement costs through a post-freeze surcharge means that the rate freeze is guaranteed to December 31, 2001 or March 31, 2002, SCE's proposal is not necessarily bad. If we can get the CPUC to throw SCE and PG&E a bone, while keeping the percentage of ultimate recovery uncertain, this may solve a lot of concerns. We would also like to see any recovery managed over multiple years in order to keep the surcharge to a minimum. The surcharge will have a negative impact on our current book; however, this impact may net out against any positive impacts for such a plan for both PG&E and SCE. Additionally, deferring and/or extending the recovery period for the surcharge will mitigate negative impacts to our book. Even though a surcharge will cause higher delivery curves which may result in less attractive bundled energy deals (depending on the customer's benchmark), we will still be able to sell unbundled commodity only deals which will largely depend on the post-freeze deregulated market structure. We have implemented the strategy to sell unbundled commodity only, when the regulatory risks become too volatile and when the market structure supports demand for such a product (e.g. SDG&E's service territory). I don't necessarily think it is prudent to publicly oppose the utilities on this issue. I am not even sure we should tip our hand by saying anything publicly on this issue. We might want to maintain a poker face in public. If we come out to strongly, then we might foreclose an opportunity to work with the utilities. If we come out in support, people might figure us out. Whatever the outcome, it is important to preserve the rate freeze as it exists today, which means a PX credit for DA customers. Roger
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Roger Yang/SFO/EES on 10/09/2000 10:32 AM --------------------------- Mona L Petrochko 10/06/2000 09:28 AM To: West GA, Harry Kingerski@EES, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Laird Dyer/SF/ECT@ECT, Michael McDonald@ECT, David Parquet@ECT, Roger Yang, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, Mary Hain@Enron cc: Subject: Fwd: A. 99-01-034 SCE's Ex Parte Request for the ImmediateSuspension, etc, 10-5-00 FYI. ---------------------- Forwarded by Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES on 10/06/2000 07:26 AM --------------------------- "Daniel Douglass" <douglass@ArterHadden.com> on 10/05/2000 06:39:04 PM To: <JBarthrop@electric.com>, <mnelson@electric.com>, <RSchlanert@electric.com>, <mpetroch@enron.com>, <susan_j_mara@enron.com>, <counihan@greenmountain.com>, <athomas@newenergy.com>, <bchen@newenergy.com>, <kmagruder@newpower.com>, <Jeff.Hanson@phaser.com>, <anchau@shellus.com>, <andrew.madden@utility.com>, <ben.reyes@utility.com>, <chris.king@utility.com>, <david.bayless@utility.com> cc: Subject: Fwd: A. 99-01-034 SCE's Ex Parte Request for the ImmediateSuspension, etc, 10-5-00 Today, Edison filed?an ex parte request that the Commission declare that an unforeseen emergency situation has arisen which merits the immediate suspension as to SCE of the ffective date of those portions of Decisions 99-10-057 and 00-03-058 (the End of Rate Freeze Decisions) which do not permit the recovery of a TRA balance after the end of SCE,s rate freeze.? The following is a direct quote from the filing: ? "Specifically, SCE asks for suspension of the effective date of application to SCE of Conclusions of Law 3 and 4 in D. 99-10-057, which read: 3. Carrying over balances related to the &PX lag8 or other unrecovered costs in the TRA or the TCBA violates the rate freeze provisions of AB 1890. Delaying the end of the rate freeze in order to resolve pending Commission proceedings addressing costs incurred during the rate freeze contravenes AB 1890. 4. Sections 368(a) and 367(a) do not permit the utilities to carry over after the rate freeze those costs incurred during the rate greeze. Exceptions to the rate freeze that are not specifically ennumerated in AB 1890 are not lawful. SCE also asks for suspension, as to SCE, of effective date of the second bullet-pointed subparagraph of Ordering Paragraph 2 in D. 99-10-057, which reads: 2. The tariffs proposed by the advice letters shall not be modified except as required by this order, as follows: * * * * No utility may carry over costs incurred during the rate freeze period to the post )rate freeze period, notwithstanding the status of the Transition Revenue Account (TRA), relevant Commission proceedings, or Power Exchange (PX) billings, as set forth herein. SCE also asks for suspension, as to SCE, of the effective date of any provisions of D. 00-03-058 which are consistent with the above Conclusions of Law and Ordering Subpararagraph. This request is based upon and hereby incorporates the Emergency Petition Of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) For Expedited Modification Of Decisions 99-10-057 And 00-03-058 and the supporting declarations of Chris Dominski and W. James Scilacci (collectively, the &Emergency Petition8) filed on October 4, 2000." ? Attached is a copy of the filing. ? Dan Date: Thu, 05 Oct 2000 19:15:13 -0400 From: "Archer, Anthony V" <ARCHERAV@sce.com> To: "'kpoole@adamsbroadwell.com'" <kpoole@adamsbroadwell.com>, "'mdjoseph@adamsbroadwell.com'" <mdjoseph@adamsbroadwell.com>, "'epoole@adplaw.com'" <epoole@adplaw.com>, "'mpa@aelaw.com'" <mpa@aelaw.com>, "'jweil@aglet.org'" <jweil@aglet.org>, "'ronknecht@aol.com'" <ronknecht@aol.com>, "'berry@apx.com'" <berry@apx.com>,"'ed@apx.com'" <ed@apx.com>, "Daniel Douglass" <Douglass@ArterHadden.com>, "Freya Christian" <FChristi@ArterHadden.com>, "'mgomez1@bart.gov'" <mgomez1@bart.gov>, "'rschmidt@bartlewells.com'" <rschmidt@bartlewells.com>, "'wbooth@booth-law.com'" <wbooth@booth-law.com>, "'blaising@braunlegal.com'" <blaising@braunlegal.com>, "'rmccann@cal.net'" <rmccann@cal.net>, "'glwaas@calpx.com'" <glwaas@calpx.com>, "'lgurick@calpx.com'" <lgurick@calpx.com>, "'kmills@cfbf.com'" <kmills@cfbf.com>, "'rliebert@cfbf.com'" <rliebert@cfbf.com>, "'theresa_mueller@ci.sf.ca.us'" <theresa_mueller@ci.sf.ca.us>, "'honest@compuserve.com'" <honest@compuserve.com>, "'mbrubaker@consultbai.com'" <mbrubaker@consultbai.com>, "'ang@cpuc.ca.gov'" <ang@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'fua@cpuc.ca.gov'" <fua@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'jjz@cpuc.ca.gov'" <jjz@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'kim@cpuc.ca.gov'" <kim@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'kth@cpuc.ca.gov'" <kth@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'mer@cpuc.ca.gov'" <mer@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'raw@cpuc.ca.gov'" <raw@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'rtf@cpuc.ca.gov'" <rtf@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'ztc@cpuc.ca.gov'" <ztc@cpuc.ca.gov>, "'patrickm@crossborderenergy.com'" <patrickm@crossborderenergy.com>, "'pstohr@dbsr.com'" <pstohr@dbsr.com>, "'ad046@detroit.freenet.org'" <ad046@detroit.freenet.org>, "'pat.williams@dhcmail.com'" <pat.williams@dhcmail.com>, "'natutt@duanemorris.com'" <natutt@duanemorris.com>, "'gtbl@dynegy.com'" <gtbl@dynegy.com>, "'brbarkovich@earthlink.net'" <brbarkovich@earthlink.net>, "'jsilva@edisonenterprises.com'" <jsilva@edisonenterprises.com>, "'huse@eesconsulting.com'" <huse@eesconsulting.com>, "'sdefrawi@efaches.navfac.navy.mil'" <sdefrawi@efaches.navfac.navy.mil>, "'furutanj@efawest.navfac.navy.mil'" <furutanj@efawest.navfac.navy.mil>, "'cmkehrein@ems-ca.com'" <cmkehrein@ems-ca.com>, "'askaff@energy-law-group.com'" <askaff@energy-law-group.com>, "'difellman@energy-law-group.com'" <difellman@energy-law-group.com>, "'jtachera@energy.state.ca.us'" <jtachera@energy.state.ca.us>, "'LKristov@energy.state.ca.us'" <LKristov@energy.state.ca.us>, "'rtavares@energy.state.ca.us'" <rtavares@energy.state.ca.us>, "'Slayman@energy.state.ca.us'" <Slayman@energy.state.ca.us>, "'abb@eslawfirm.com'" <abb@eslawfirm.com>, "'jdh@eslawfirm.com'" <jdh@eslawfirm.com>, "'jbennett@gmssr.com'" <jbennett@gmssr.com>, "'jlondon@gralegal.com'" <jlondon@gralegal.com>, "'rick.counihan@greenmountain.com'" <rick.counihan@greenmountain.com>, "'ddavie@hesinet.com'" <ddavie@hesinet.com>, "'mhg@hetrading.com'" <mhg@hetrading.com>, "'smoss@hooked.net'" <smoss@hooked.net>, "'jeff@jbsenergy.com'" <jeff@jbsenergy.com>, "'jogg@jhenergy.com'" <jogg@jhenergy.com>, "'ewo@jmbm.com'" <ewo@jmbm.com>, "'napedersen@jonesday.com'" <napedersen@jonesday.com>, "'dws@keywaycorp.com'" <dws@keywaycorp.com>, "'karen@klindh.com'" <karen@klindh.com>, "'bloomje@la.whitecase.com'" <bloomje@la.whitecase.com>, "'btenney@landuselaw.com'" <btenney@landuselaw.com>, "'chilen@llgm.com'" <chilen@llgm.com>, "'jleslie@luce.com'" <jleslie@luce.com>, "'randy_britt@mayco.com'" <randy_britt@mayco.com>, "'chrism@mid.org'" <chrism@mid.org>, "'phanschen@mofo.com'" <phanschen@mofo.com>, "'rbw@mrwassoc.com'" <rbw@mrwassoc.com>, "'athomas@newenergy.com'" <athomas@newenergy.com>, "'derkp@newsdata.com'" <derkp@newsdata.com>, "'ell5@pge.com'" <ell5@pge.com>, "'j3m9@pge.com'" <j3m9@pge.com>, "'jyf1@pge.com'" <jyf1@pge.com>, "'whe1@pge.com'" <whe1@pge.com>, "'jbarthrop@powersavers.com'" <jbarthrop@powersavers.com>, "'keith-sappenfield@reliantenergy.com'" <keith-sappenfield@reliantenergy.com>, "'pjmuller@ricochet.net'" <pjmuller@ricochet.net>, "'melanie_gillette@rmiinc.com'" <melanie_gillette@rmiinc.com>, "'jbushee@sablaw.com'" <jbushee@sablaw.com>, "'kmccrea@sablaw.com'" <kmccrea@sablaw.com>, "'cohnap@sce.com'" <cohnap@sce.com>, "'costac@sce.com'" <costac@sce.com>, "'fosterbc@sce.com'" <fosterbc@sce.com>, "'lehrerjm@sce.com'" <lehrerjm@sce.com>, "'dbb@sdcity.sannet.gov'" <dbb@sdcity.sannet.gov>, "'kmelville@sempra.com'" <kmelville@sempra.com>, "'LVanWagenen@sempra.com'" <LVanWagenen@sempra.com>, "'anchau@shellus.com'" <anchau@shellus.com>, "'dmarcus@slip.net'" <dmarcus@slip.net>, "'aorchard@smud.org'" <aorchard@smud.org>, "'thaines@smud.org'" <thaines@smud.org>, "'bfinkelstein@turn.org'" <bfinkelstein@turn.org> Cc: "Cohn, Ann" <Ann.Cohn@sce.com>,"Fox, Beth" <Beth.Fox@sce.com>, "Lehrer, James" <James.Lehrer@sce.com>, "Chadsey, Linda" <Linda.Chadsey@sce.com>, "Monalisa, Dina" <MONALID@sce.com>, "Simpson, Mary C" <SIMPSOMC@sce.com> Subject: A. 99-01-034 SCE's Ex Parte Request for the ImmediateSuspension, etc, 10-5-00 Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="=_1941F0B8.89E8C083" <<SCE's Ex Parte Request For Suspension, Etc.>> Attached is SCE's Ex Parte Request For The Immediate Suspension Of The Effective Date of Portions of D.99-10-057 and D.00-03-058 Relating To The Post Rate Freeze Recovery Of The TRA Balance. This document was filed and served today on all parties of record in A. 99-01-034, et. al., (PTR) Thank you, Anthony V. Archer So. Cal. Edison's Legal Dept. Tele: 626 302-3104 Pax:: 2-3104 Fax:: 2-2304 Suite 315 - 10-5-0.PDF