22 May 2000, 17:36 UTC
FW: NY Times Article
- From
- Rhonda Russell rrussell@fontheiminternational.com
- To
- Amy Fabian, Chris Long, cfontheim@fontheiminternational.com, dmilenthal@hms-partners.com, lndnetwork@aol.com, euramgoode@aol.com, mreid@deweysquare.com, nkramer@resource.com, bob@healthycompanies.com, rferguson@lipmanhearne.com, spainter@fontheiminternational.com, sally.susman@aexp.com
- Date
- Mon, 22 May 2000 10:36:00 -0700 (PDT)
In case you missed this.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> May 22, 2000 > New York Times > AL GORE'S JOURNEY A Boyhood Divided > A Boy's Life In and Out of the Family Script > By MELINDA HENNEBERGER > The last thing Al Gore's father told him, a few days before he > died, and just before he lost the ability to speak, was: "Son, always > do right. Always do right." His father, the senator, felt he had > himself done right a lot of the time, and reliably kept after his son > to follow suit. > After the vice president talked about that last conversation, > though, in a eulogy he had worked on without sleeping for two nights > straight, even some friends wondered whether his father had tacked on > a Hollywood ending, scripting his goodbyes at least in part for the > benefit of the papers, and maybe the history books. This time, nobody > came right out and accused Mr. Gore himself of tweaking the dialogue. > Even the rawest and most intimate moments in his life are now > widely seen as mere theatrics, all part of a presidential campaign > strategy designed by his ambitious, up-from-nothing parents, Albert > and Pauline LaFon Gore, before he was born, and even unto death. > That perception has clearly become a political problem for the > vice president. > Gov. George W. Bush of Texas regularly suggests that Mr. Gore is > a natural-born phony, and the vice president's every remark is now > fact-checked so scrupulously that when he recently said he had once > dreamed of becoming a teacher, reporters wondered if he could prove > it. Had anyone ever heard that story before? > The questions are about more than Mr. Gore's assertions about > the Internet and "Love Story." What in his life was scripted and what > was real? Could even he know the difference? Where did his parents' > hopes end and his own begin? And do you only get credit for hosing out > hog parlors if you did it without an agenda? > But in separating the facts from the fanciful in Mr. Gore's > life, perhaps the most striking discovery is the extent to which the > material that is the most widely doubted is also the most demonstrably > true: Al Gore did do a lot of his growing up in Tennessee. He did work > hard on the farm there -- so hard, in fact, that the hired help felt > sorry for him, and thought his father should ease up. > In the same way, some of what is generally assumed about Mr. > Gore's life is not true: he did not, for example, live in luxury back > in Washington during the school year. > Mr. Gore's parents were both famously frugal and were not well > off until after their son had grown and after the senator's political > career had ended. Though they sent their children to exclusive schools > and provided such social necessities as ballroom dancing lessons for > their son, they also dressed him in a cousin's hand-me-downs and lived > in a hotel because it was owned by a relative who gave them a break on > the rent. > Some summers, the Gores had to pack up their four-room suite and > put their belongings in storage so the place could be sublet while > they were in Tennessee. And Al shared a bedroom with his sister, > Nancy, who was 10 years older, both before and after her college > years. > Part of the reason that the contours of Mr. Gore's unusual > upbringing are not better known, however, is that he himself has > worked so hard to discredit a lot of authentic stories about his > childhood -- the very stories, in fact, that would probably do him the > most good politically. The problem, for him, is the scenes from the > past that portray Mr. Gore sympathetically at the expense of his > hard-driving parents. > They suggest an emotionally neglected boy forced to bear the > weight of enormous adult expectations, and Mr. Gore, who is fiercely > protective of his 87-year-old mother and the memory of his father, > categorically balks at that. > For a time, a decade ago, after his unsuccessful 1988 > presidential campaign and his son's near-fatal car accident the next > year, Mr. Gore himself seemed determined to explore the meaning of his > own life story. > He made a serious study of family dysfunction -- the subtext of > his 1992 environmental manifesto, "Earth in the Balance" -- and passed > out copies of Alice Miller's "Drama of the Gifted Child," a book about > how narcissistic parents can leave their high-achieving children cut > off from their own feelings and hazy on just what they want, other > than to make Mom and Dad proud. Back then, friends said, he was > absorbed by the need to figure things out, to emerge from his father's > shadow. To decide. > But today, Mr. Gore seems nothing if not decided. He does want > to be president, and if he can never really know exactly how much of > that want began with his parents, his current attitude seems to be: So > what? "One of the oldest plots in the human story is child follows > parent," he said recently, with what sure seemed like authentic > boredom. And looking back on his early years did not seem so very > difficult. > In a series of interviews about his life, he was relaxed and > appeared at peace with the past. He frankly described a childhood in > which even the usual juvenile scrapes might become part of continuing > political calculations -- maybe the same way writers often end up > milking their families for material. When he got in trouble for > throwing whitewash on trucks as they passed the Gore farm when he was > 12, for example, his father made him send letters of apology to a > number of trucking companies. "That was also an election year, I > believe," he remarked wryly. But, he made clear, it was also just a > kid's life. > From the Farm and the City > "I was conceived in Tennessee," Mr. Gore began, drawling for > effect, in a radio announcer voice that poked fun at the whole > biographical exercise. > Though his political opponents have successfully portrayed him > as a pure-bred Washington creature, with only photo-op moments in the > heartland, he did have a life there, on the family farm, and by all > accounts a more intense emotional connection to that place than to the > nation's capital. > His real childhood was in Tennessee; in Washington, he spent his > time with adults -- important adults, in whose presence he was > expected to behave beautifully, and did. Tennessee was, at the very > least, where Al Gore wished he had grown up. > His buddies in Tennessee certainly considered Carthage, the > small community on the Cumberland and the Caney Fork Rivers, where the > Gores spent summers and holidays, as his true home. "There were not a > lot of kids around the Fairfax," the Embassy Row hotel where the Gores > lived while in Washington, "so he could not wait to get back home," > said Steve Armistead, Al Gore's closest childhood friend, and a good > pal still. > "I went up there" when Mr. Gore was in high school "and the > friend he had in the Fairfax was a bellhop," Mr. Armistead said. > "There were all these dignitaries, but not much for a kid. There was a > dullness, a loneliness about it. He didn't lay around Washington much > when he could have been in Carthage, and that's where he got his > values, working on the farm and growing up around Smith County > people." > Of course, Mr. Gore is the product of both Washington and > Tennessee -- and of the very fact of having grown up in two places, > with two groups of friends and two ways of looking at the world. He > was born in Washington, lived in Tennessee from the time he was 1 > until he was 4, while his father ran for the Senate, and then moved > between the two places until college. > This back and forth set him slightly apart from those around > him, in season and out, and made him tough to figure. > Even his sense of humor is a hybrid, a little bit corny with > flashes of sarcasm. > Mr. Gore himself seems to feel that his split-screen view of the > world was a gift, at least in the end. > "Even though I spent more time each year in Washington, > Tennessee was home," he said. "Now I'm sure that part of that was me, > as a kid, absorbing my parents' insistence on the political reality of > their lives, that they were representing Tennessee in Washington. I'm > sure I picked up a lot of that as a child. But it was more than that." > > He described Tennessee as a place where "the human relationships > were much warmer," and where he had his dearest friends. > "I think I learned a great deal from the, forgive the word, the > parallactic view provided by growing up in two places," he says now, > "because just as having two eyes gives you depth perception, having > two homes allows you to see some things that stand out in relief when > viewed from two different perspectives." > A Tennessee Work Ethic > Mr. Gore's father -- who also favored fancy words -- moved > between two worlds, too, and for all his striving in Washington did > not believe in leaving either Tennessee or his farm roots behind, > ever, even after his career in politics ended. > And he and his wife thought that working on the farm would be > good for their son, whom they told friends they hoped would be > president one day. "It was expected from the time he was little," said > James Fleming, a Nashville doctor and friend of Nancy Gore's, who for > a time served as the Gore family physician. It was not so much that > the Gores thought cleaning out barns would add just the right touch of > "log cabin" to his r,sum,, family friends said, as that they simply > felt it would toughen him up and give him a proper work ethic. > "His daddy used to get him up about 6 o'clock in the morning," > said Mattie Lucie Payne, who worked for the Gores as a housekeeper for > more than 40 years. "And Al would say, 'Daddy, we have men working,' > and his daddy would say, 'I know, and you go on down and help them.' " > > He baled hay, cut tobacco and cleaned out hog parlors along with > the hired help. > But the senator also seemed to revel in assigning his son some > of the most backbreaking tasks, like clearing 20 hilly acres with a > hand ax. > "He'd drive him pretty hard," said Gordon Thompson, a friend > whose family used to live on the Gore farm, back when his own father > worked for the senator. > But then, he drove himself hard, too. Even at 4-H camp, as a > 9-year-old, he asked to be given the heavy-lifting kitchen duty > usually reserved for 13- and 14-year-olds. "He was the only camper I > ever had volunteer for K-P," said Jerry Cole, the local 4-H agent. > For several weeks every summer after school let out, but before > his parents could get away from Washington, Mr. Thompson said, Al > would stay with them in a house with no indoor plumbing. "He never > complained," Mr. Thompson said. "I think he was always happiest on the > farm." > Always, he was serious. "He pretty much acted the same way when > he was 13 as he does now," said Donna Armistead, Steve Armistead's > sister and Mr. Gore's first real girlfriend, for several years, > beginning when he was an extremely confident 13-year-old and she was > 16. > "He was a terrific listener," recalled Ms. Armistead, now a > nurse and divorced mother of two. And not just to her, she said. He > would pay attention to the old folks at her grandparents' grocery > store, and hold his grandmother's hand in the nursing home for long > stretches several times a week. > Mr. Gore's own mother "was not very touchy," Ms. Armistead said, > adding, "When he came in she just wouldn't come running to hug him." > She said his father used an entirely different voice when he > talked with Al. > "He'd talk with authority," she said. > And nobody, the way Ms. Armistead remembers it, gave him any > breaks for being a senator's son. > Once, after Mr. Gore and Ms. Armistead had done a particularly > hard job on the farm, the senator told him to take her out for a meal > at a certain cafe. "We were so thrilled," she remembered. "But after > dinner Al gets up to the cash register and said, 'My dad said to > charge it to him,' and the guy wouldn't do it." > The senator's tab was too long already. > "So I had to tell him I'd be right back, and go get the money > from my mom," Ms. Armistead said. > A Touch of Mischief > Still, his time in Tennessee was not all boot camp and character > building, and Mr. Gore did manage to have some unscripted fun. Mr. > Thompson remembers his friend as "pranky," with a love of practical > jokes that endures today. > One New Year's Eve, several of his friends said, their whole > group was snowed in at the Gore farm, so Pauline Gore corralled all > the girls in an upstairs bedroom and the boys in Al's room on the > lower level. The senator, dressed in his bathrobe, sat sentry duty at > the top of the stairs all night long, and every so often yelled > downstairs to his son and the other boys, who were busy sharing one > bottle of beer. > At first light, Ms. Armistead heard a knock on the window, > looked out and saw Al and his buddies, who had slipped out a window > and climbed up onto the deck outside her room, where they were making > snowmen in their underwear for the girls' benefit. > "Mr. Albert still thought he had everything under control," she > said. > Her brother, Steve, describes a pretty mild teenage rebellion: > "We did all the experimental things kids do. We'd sneak out at night > and pick up Coke bottles off a front porch that probably were not > ours, or go to the lake and maybe do a little water skiing at night > that was not too smart, and occasionally have a party. We probably did > a little bit of alcohol abuse." > But there were also times, even as a kid, when Mr. Gore flouted > authority more directly. Once, while staying with the Thompsons, he > heard that his father, who was away, was going to be giving a speech > in Nashville, 55 miles east. > His parents, though, had decided that their son should not come > to the event. > "He was little," 12 at most, Mr. Thompson said, "but Al went > over to Carthage and caught the bus and went down there, still dressed > for the farm. That didn't go over too well. His mom called and wanted > to know where he was -- that was a biggie. My mom had to tell her he > wasn't here. Today, you'd be worried about all kinds of things > happening. But they were more concerned about him not being all > cleaned up." > Like a lot of mothers, Pauline Gore always insisted publicly > that her son was at all times the perfect boy. > But was she embellishing a little? At least at times, she > apparently thought she had reason to worry. > Dr. Fleming said, "I remember Donna, this good-looking girl, > running around the house, and Pauline saying, 'Ohmigod, she's going to > get pregnant, I know it.' " > Mr. Gore was not shy about expressing affection for his > girlfriend in front of his mother. > "I remember Pauline and I drove him to the airport one time," > said Ms. Armistead, "and he kissed her on the cheek and then he kissed > me. I mean, he laid one on me, honey." > Ms. Armistead says the two of them were lectured. "Miss Pauline > said keep busy, don't think about sex, enjoy your time together but > always have something in mind to do," she said. "Cold showers and lots > of exercise." > But she also says Mrs. Gore need not have worried. "Sex was sex > even then," Ms. Armistead said, "but Al and I both had goals." > Finding a Role Model > Today, the vice president seems to enjoy looking back on the > benign pleasures of the summers when he got to be a kid in Tennessee > -- skinny-dipping with Mr. Thompson in a cattle trough or hypnotizing > chickens, which Mr. Gore says is "a little-known farm skill passed > down from adolescent wizard to adolescent wizard." > Mr. Gore also situates himself politically in Tennessee, as heir > not only to his father but to Cordell Hull, whom he describes as "the > model for public service in our part of the country." Mr. Hull floated > logs down the Cumberland River with Mr. Gore's grandfather, settled in > Carthage and became the congressman in the seat the Gore father and > son later held. > An ardent free-trader, Mr. Hull won the Nobel Peace Prize for > his role in founding GATT, now the World Trade Organization, and was > secretary of state in World War II. "But before that he was a judge on > the circuit, and in 10 counties there, the picture above the judge's > chair in the courtroom is neither George Washington, Thomas Jefferson > nor Franklin Roosevelt," Mr. Gore said, with the greatest possible > reverence. "It's Cordell Hull to this day." > Asked to name the most important things he had inherited from > his parents, Mr. Gore talked for a long time about his father and his > father's ideals. But the first thing he said in answer to the question > was this: > "Some of what people perceive as the stiffness and formality I > sometimes lapse into comes in part from my father's habit of trying to > ensure that he always presented a dignified appearance to live up to > the position he felt deserved dignity. > "People who saw him on the stump and playing the fiddle find > that ironic because they don't remember the formal bearing that he had > in most of his appearances. He had a capacity to enjoy humor and music > and friendship, and he also felt the need to present himself as a > senator in a formal and dignified way." > Those who knew the senator say his climb from poverty was still > too fresh and stereotypes of Tennessee hillbillies with dirt under > their fingernails still too prevalent for him to feel he could afford > the luxury of letting his guard down in certain public settings. > His father "always raised cattle, he always farmed, he always > found relaxation, even in Washington, by going to the farm and working > with cattle," the vice president said. > "But he became a statesman," too, Mr. Gore said. "I've often > thought in my father's persona he continued to manifest both." > His friends feel sure Mr. Gore would move back to Carthage if, > as Mr. Thompson delicately put it, "worse comes to worst." The vice > president laughed at that, but agreed. "Well, I'll retire in Carthage > for sure," he said. "You know, I hope that's many years from now." > One thing that still strikes all his Tennessee friends as odd, > though, is that through all the time he spent there growing up he > never spoke a word about Washington. And he absolutely refused to wear > any of the neatly folded T-shirts his mother had packed for him -- > T-shirts emblazoned with the name of his prep school, St. Albans. > "He probably thought we would think he was trying to act like he > was better than the rest of us," guessed his old friend Edward Blair. > But Mr. Gore, who had his boots up on the table in front of him > as he talked, snorted when he heard this. > "I guess maybe they were thinking that Washington is such a neat > place," he said, "that I would naturally want to tell them all about > the great things there." > Few Comforts of Home > If the Fairfax was a cold place to grow up, it was not because > there was no family close by. > The owner, Grady Gore, was a cousin of the senator's. Louise > Gore, one of Grady's daughters, lived in the hotel. Her sister, Mary > Gore Dean, moved in, too, after her husband died in a plane crash. For > a while, their brother Jimmy Gore and his family were on the premises, > as well. When they moved, it was just down the block. > But the vice president is not sentimental about his time there. > "I came to love the farm," he said. "The hotel I never loved." > The senator's correspondence makes clear that he and his family > were there because the price was right. The Gores looked for a house > in Washington for years, but never found anything they felt they could > afford. > And one thing that seems to bother Mr. Gore -- far more, in > fact, than the idea that his 52 years add up to something that is not > so much a life as a story line -- is the perception that "I was in > this luxury apartment eating room service, sort of like Eloise." > Asked if his younger days in Washington were lonely, he sighed. > "Oh, no," he said. "I mean I had good friends and I had my > sister. And it's not as if I didn't have my parents. They went out > frequently, and every six years they had a hard campaign, but they > were great and loving parents, and the times when they were pulled > away I had Nancy and my friends. I wasn't left alone with my > thoughts." > He got pretty creative about making his own fun, sometimes > upending all the furniture in the living room to construct an > elaborate fort. But activity was supposed to be purposeful. "His dad > was a very, very proud man and believed that old Cordell Hull thing of > you're put on earth for a purpose and it's to improve the condition of > life," said Mr. Gore's cousin, Mark Gore, who lived down the block. > (His cousin also remembers Senator Gore teaching him to swim by > throwing him into a pool when he was 4, while Al, who was 7, looked > on, laughing.) > From fourth grade on, young Al attended St. Albans, the > Episcopal boys' prep school on the grounds of the National Cathedral, > where he did well but was not, according to friends, especially happy. > > Throughout high school, he wrote his Tennessee girlfriend, Ms. > Armistead, twice a day, and called her on a pay phone every Saturday > night. > Two of Mr. Gore's closest Washington friends recall that while > Al Gore was the focus of his parents' fondest hopes, it was his > free-spirited, rebellious sister, Nancy, who took more of their > energy. "The general topic of conversation over there was what > outrageous thing Nancy did this week," said one of these friends. "She > got a lot of attention and Al was kind of an afterthought, because he > never misbehaved." > For him, the best times were those spent throwing a ball around > with his father at Grady Gore's estate in Potomac, Md. "He had some > cattle from the Tennessee farm brought up there," Mr. Gore said, > smirking like he knows that sounds kind of crazy. "And a lot of times > on weekends we'd go up there and he'd work with the cattle and I'd > help him and then we'd take a break." Sometimes, too, they played > catch in the Russell building, outside the senator's office, though if > someone walked by, "he'd duck back into the office until they passed" > because "it wasn't very dignified," the son recalled. When Al Gore had > real ballgames, though, it was his sister, not his father, who would > come. > More often, his father took him to Senate hearings. He sat > through long stretches of discussion over the bill, co-sponsored by > his father, that created the Interstate System of highways. How wide > would the new roads be? Green or blue for the road signs? As a kid, > Mr. Gore followed these developments avidly, keeping track of the > miles of completed highway the way other kids his age followed the > Yankees' box scores. > "He also took me on the Senate floor, even though he wasn't > supposed to," Mr. Gore remembered. And one day, when Al was 5, he was > invited to come up front to meet the vice president, Richard M. Nixon, > who was presiding that day: "He put me on his knee and was very nice > to me, and the experience forever after deprived me of the more > sublime pleasures of Nixon hatred." > Once, Mr. Gore's father let his son listen in on an extension > while he spoke to President John F. Kennedy, who at the time was > furious at a certain steel executive for raising prices after the > steel workers had agreed not to seek a wage increase. "The family > anecdote that my father always told after that -- like a lot of family > anecdotes I can't really vouch for -- but he said that I said, 'Dad, I > didn't know presidents talked that way.' " > The vice president does have strong memories of Kennedy, though. > > "I was blown away by his inaugural address," he said. I remember > so vividly the thick snow on the seats, and listening to each word > bring out such poetic force. Really, it was a remarkable time. My > sister was one of the first volunteers for the Peace Corps that month, > and the whole family was filled with the excitement of the New > Frontier." > They all wanted, each in their own way, to be part of that > excitement. And the entire family talked a lot about not just the > bills before Congress but the big issues of the day, especially civil > rights. In these discussions, was his mother more liberal than his > father, as some who knew the couple have suggested? "Mmmmm, my dad was > pretty liberal," Mr. Gore answered. "She was, like most moms, the > conscience of the family, but they didn't really disagree. And my > sister was more liberal than both of them put together." > Then Mr. Gore started to laugh, and kept on for a good long > time. "It was a family of many consciences," he said. > > >