20 Sep 2000, 20:18 UTC
RAP Alternate Decision
- From
- Mona L Petrochko mona.petrochko@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 20 Sep 2000 13:18:00 -0700 (PDT)
Some thoughts for folks to think about in advance of Friday: 1. Decision is great on defining LRMC-adopt ARM/ORA vs. UDCs 2. Decision identifies specific adjustments to ORA from Utilities, but doesn't identify specific adjustments to ORA from ARM (which Dan has done) and which we can point to in comments. The table that compares all proposals is excellent! (It's in Dan's memo) That is a great cross-reference. 3. Need to determine whether we support an average for the state, or utility-specific. Which will be more defensible? I think utility specific. 4. I have some challenges to the adjustments that Neeper ultimately adopted. 5. The decision requires that the utility procurement function interact with the other utility functions on a comparable basis as ESPs, including access to information. (Good decision language. Don't know how to enforce.) Here is a table summarizing the thought process of the revised alternate decision. ORA-ADJ UDC, is the adjustments to ORA's proposal incorporating criticisms of the UDCs. The next line (ORA-ADJ ACCPT) are those UDC criticisms accepted by Neeper. The last is the machinations to average and incorporate a bump for ARM's participation. Cents per MWh PG&E SCE SDG&E UDC 0 .02 3 ORA 48 40 15 ARM 59 67 65 ORA-ADJ UDC 18 .8 6 ORA-ADJ ACCPT 48 28 13 DECISION-AVG+ 32 32 32 I think the items that Dan has identified will provide more than a 2 cent/MWh adjustment, so worth quantifying for the record. These include adjustment for common costs and overheads (FF#27), which ORA said we did a better job than they had. Also, ARM's itemization of procurement related costs, which ORA seemed to agree with, is more extensive. Challenges to Adjustments Adopted by Neeper (ORA-ADJ ACCPT) SDG&E-(pg. 37) 1. Would have disallowed $1.2 million. Neeper disallowed $.2 million (pg. 38) because those costs are being recovered in 376. I will research SDG&E's 376 Settlement Decision, which I believe allows for consideration of those costs in future unbundling proceedings. (Not sure about SDG&E, sure about SCE) PG&E-(pg. 38) Criticizes ORA for not doing a PG&E-specific study. PG&E's criticism ORA for including customer service costs related to its distribution function. Neeper (pg. 40) Says ORA's proxy analysis to SCE is ok. Discounts PG&E's criticism on customer service costs citing to the RAP decision that those costs should be included in the PX credit. This seems to be the best place to advocate use of our numbers over ORA's. We did a PG&E specific study, which I think would be a valid criticism to ORA's numbers. SCE-(pg.39) Would reduce ORA's Energy Service and Marketing costs from $12.3 to $4 million, because it includes costs related to supply from generation sources. Would reduce Customer Service and Information from $21.1 milion to $7.7 million saying that is the amount of CS&I the Commission had allocated to generation. Neeper (pg. 40) accepts reduction of ES&M to $4 million. Neeper does not discuss CS&I. Need MRW input on whether SCE's criticisms are valid. Seems like we have many areas to supplement ORA's numbers, based on the table in Dan's note.