4 Apr 2001, 12:06 UTC
Nevada Blocks Sale of Generation Plants; Re-Regulation Now Likely for State
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Wed, 4 Apr 2001 05:06:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] Southeastern Electric Exchange 2001 Utility Odyssey: Engineering & Operation/Accounting, Customer Billing and Finance Conference and Trade Show The Doral Resort Miami, FL Featured speakers include Wall Street Analysts Ed Tirello and Dan Ford and SEE Company Utility Executives Donald Hintz, Entergy Corp., Dennis Wraase, Pepco, and Bill Coley, Duke Power For full details: www.theexchange.org Learn more about SCIENTECH'S newest InfoGrid: Venture Capital Firms, Emerging Technology Companies and Services in the Electric Industry. Get the latest news and information available today regarding technologies in distributed generation, fuel cell, solar, wind and energy information services. Over 110 companies and over 42 investors are featured in this intelligence product. Download a sample at www.ConsultRCI.com or contact Chris Vigil, toll free at (888) 972-8676 for more information. [IMAGE] The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power System by RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. The Wall Map measures 42" x 72"; the Executive Map Set consists of 18 11" x 17" maps. Visit our website at www.ConsultRCI.com for a detailed description of these valuable maps and complete ordering instructions. [IMAGE] IssueAlert for April 4, 2001 Nevada Blocks Sale of Generation Plants; Re-Regulation Now Likely for State by Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [News item from California Energy Markets] Nevada officials rushed through measures designed to stop the sale of power plants by Sierra Pacific Power and Nevada Power with a total value estimated at $1.7 billion. The Nevada Assembly voted to pass Assembly Bill 369, which halts the plant sales and stops restructuring in the state. Analysis: For the last several weeks, Nevada officials monitoring the energy industry in the state have oscillated between assisting the financially strapped utilities under parent company Sierra Pacific Resources, or preventing what they fear will be a repeat of the California energy crisis. The measure taken late last week by the Nevada Assembly is essentially an attempt to ensure cost-based rates in the state, reduce the potential risk of summer blackouts and wait out the uncertainty surrounding power supply and electricity prices in the West. However, the measure does little to alleviate the financial burden weighing on Nevada's major utility companies, and in fact raises the possibility for further debts that Sierra Pacific and Nevada Power may have to carry to comply with several of the measure's related requirements. The key provision of Assembly Bill 369 blocks the sale of power plants before July 1, 2007, although Nevada utilities will be allowed to apply to the Public Utilities Commission of Nevada (PUCN) for plant sales that include a state of "substantial financial emergency" after July 1, 2003. The measure directly impacts a pending sale to AES Corp. of a 14-percent interest (220 MW) in the Mohave Generating Station, located in Laughlin, Nev., that is presently owned by Nevada Power. AES had agreed to pay $133.5 million for the 14-percent interest in the plant. Under terms of the state's restructuring legislation, Nevada Power and Sierra Pacific Power were ordered to sell their power plants to alleviate concerns about market power. Toward that end, the holding company and its wholly owned utility subsidiaries commenced a public auction of approximately 2,900 MW of power generation facilities. Of Sierra Pacific Resources' nine power plants, which are mostly fired by natural gas and coal, seven had been entered into sales agreements and were awaiting final approval when this Assembly measure was passed. The PUCN had actually approved the sale of the Mohave plant last year, representing the first sales transactions of one of the utilities' plants. However, since the PUCN granted its approval of the Mohave plant, Nevada officials have grown increasingly concerned about instability in the Western power markets and the power supply problems in California. Tom Hay, chief of the Nevada Attorney General's Bureau of Consumer Protection, initiated the block against the sale out of concern about power supply in the state. Specifically, Hay proposed that the Mohave plant should remain under the control of Nevada Power for the time being because it burns coal, a low-cost fuel that can be relied upon to stave off blackouts in the state. In addition, Hay raised the concern that, should the sale of the plant be approved, the new owner AES could decide to sell the power produced by the plant outside of the state after a two-year buy back agreement expires in 2003. By keeping the Mohave and other generating plants under the ownership of Nevada utilities, state officials believe that they can retain regulatory control over the price of power. Nevada Governor Kenny Guinn agreed that the plants should not be sold at this time and said that keeping the plants would protect Nevadans against high prices on the wholesale power markets. Guinn also expressed his intention to block restructuring in the state throughout his term as governor, which ends in 2003. If he is elected for a second term and can see that the markets have stabilized in the West, Guinn said he would consider allowing competition in the state sometime after 2003. For its part, AES says that it will seek legal action to force the sale of the plant to proceed. AES argues that the Nevada Assembly's measure is not constitutional and violates the sales contract already approved by the PUCN. AES also pointed out that the Mohave plant is 30 years old and will require significant repairs and improvement, an investment that it was willing to make but one that would cause an unnecessary financial burden on Nevada Power. Moreover, the negative financial impact that the Nevada Assembly's measure might cause is a major point of contention for Nevada Power and Sierra Pacific (along with the two Assembly members who voted against the measure). A spokesperson for the utilities said pending sales of power plants would provide the two companies with about $1 billion in cash, which "would go a long way to help us buy fuel and purchase power." As I discussed in my 3/8/01 IssueAlert the utilities' parent company Sierra Pacific Resources continues to struggle financially, so much so that a pending acquisition of Portland General has now been scrapped. Sierra Pacific Resources reported a significant fourth-quarter loss ($18.2 million) as a result of soaring costs of power in the western United States. The company incurred losses as a direct result of "the growing and unrecovered cost of purchased power in the volatile wholesale market." The company attributed the latest quarter's loss to nearly $258 million of unanticipated fuel and purchased power costs. Although the Nevada Assembly's measure passed with a 9-2 vote, one assembly member recognized the fact that if "we weaken [the utilities] to the point where they can't borrow to purchase fuel, we won't have power." Consequently, the state could still find itself with a compromised power supply, despite its efforts to retain state control over existing power plants. Additional financial burden could be placed on Nevada Power and Sierra Pacific as a result of other requirements that are included in related Assembly measures. For instance, AB 418 calls for gradually increasing the amount of green power used by the utilities to 15 percent (from its current 0.2 percent). The bill allows for the PUCN to fine the utilities $10,000 a day or a total of $3 million for failing to buy the required amount of renewable energy. Although a representative of Sierra Pacific Resources said that the company supports the use of renewable power, the Assembly measure's requirement was considered "so much, so quick, so fast." The block on the power sales and indefinite delay in the start of competition essentially returns Nevada to a re-regulated state. This is another example of the continuing fallout that has resulted from the California energy crisis, especially among neighboring states in the West. As another example, New Mexico recently decided to also delay the start of competition until 2007. Western states, which in one way or another have felt the direct impact of the power crunch in California, have become more cautious about deregulation and seemingly are in no hurry to open their markets to competition (despite the fact that deregulation proceeds in other areas of the country). However, unlike California, where the state government now has an active role in purchasing power and may take over the utilities' transmission assets, Nevada Gov. Guinn has expressed no interest in having the state or local governments take over the jobs of electric utility companies. Rather, Guinn merely wants to retain the control that the state traditionally has had over setting utility cost-based rates, an authority that would become diluted if out-of-state power companies own generation assets located in Nevada. Further, Guinn wants to return to deferred energy rates (also known as fuel-adjustment clauses), in which a utility is allowed to seek dollar-for-dollar adjustments in rates to recover costs associated with purchasing power on the wholesale market. As opposed to monthly rate increases, Guinn believes that an annual rate increase*which Nevada Power and Sierra Pacific would have to request and justify*would "smooth out the ups and downs of power and fuel costs over the year." In addition, Guinn believes that the combination of state regulation and cost-based rates offers a better strategy for the state than attempting retail competition at this time. To supplement power supply, Guinn believes that Nevada should promote the use of merchant plants rather than relying on the incumbent utilities to build additional generation. Moreover, the Nevada Assembly measure brings competition in the state to a screeching halt (at least for the next few years). However, the larger issue at hand presently is the precarious financial state of Sierra Pacific Resources and its utilities. Without the cash that would have been gained from the sales of its power plants, it is unclear how Sierra Pacific Resources will be able to pull itself out of debt. The utility already received an emergency rate increase last month, so any attempt to secure additional increases would surely be politically unpopular. Gov. Guinn's proposal regarding deferred energy rates may provide a mechanism to bring Sierra Pacific's rates more in line with its costs, but most likely such a rate increase would take effect only once a year. Meanwhile, Sierra Pacific must still procure some power on the wholesale market, where prices remain high (a situation that could get ever worse this summer if warm temperatures drive up demand). Thus, ironically, as much as state officials have tried to avoid the energy crisis found in its western neighbor, Nevada is increasingly exhibiting some of the same fundamental problems found in California. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.ConsultRCI.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.