14 Nov 2000, 13:42 UTC
CAMBRIDGE ENERGY CONFERENCE CALL ON CALIF./ FERC ISSUES
- From
- Margaret Carson margaret.carson@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 14 Nov 2000 05:42:00 -0800 (PST)
Cambridge Energy Research sees FERC's order as bold but still insufficient to solve Calif's complex problems in electricity. FERC does show an important change in direction to be more active. Calif. clearly has gone wrong. FERC did not confirm that market power exists though. FERC alone cannot fix the fundamental supply/demand imblance problem at the seat of Calif's power price spikes now. FERC is taking a scattershot approach however to remedies. Its creating more problems for Merchant generators however. Cera sees FERC at the start of a series of changes to effect the Calif. market for some time to come. Cambridge sees FERC's 5 main thrusts: 1. FERC sees Calif. oversight of the ISO Board as ineffective. Too many price caps changes inside one month, too many quick switches in policy. This summer the ISO operators were actually doing the CPUCs job when the ISO was operating to protect the core customers. 2. FERC stripped Calif ISO of price cap setting power..but setting it at $150 mwh for a soft cap has problems too because its too low (discourages new plants) and a hassle for those who want to offer above it..not clear price signals. 3. Its good that now IOUs can buy/sell power outside the PX giving more market options. But FERC won't mandate utilities to hedge, but indeed they need to use more of these types of tools beyond the old spot market addiction. CPUC does not yet know what a good portfolio for power should look like. 4. FERC set market penalties for underscheduling and the new ISO board is trying to break up the balkanized way power used to be bought and sold by Calif utilities. 5. Calif. congestion management reform pace is too slow. Calif. needs real nodal pricing. Will the $150 soft cap retard new plants? Has a chilling effect because there is no floor and the ceiling is low. There are 61 GW proposed in the West now and 21 GW are needed. Will CPUC introduce a capacity charge to promote new plants? Now the ISO in its actions can enter into supply contracts for ' new ' capacity for 3 years with a $125 kwh payment plus what it pays in the price to clear the energy market. People will try to reclassifiy 'old' plants as 'new' plants to try to make the cut. Will it make more sense for plants to be outside Calif. to compete ? It makes things less onerous on the regulataory front to site outside Calif. then inside. The areas outside Calif. see Calif. effects changing their own markets. FERC saw links with power price caps and efforts to move power from COB to Palo Verde. If you move volumes away from the day ahead market more into bilaterals this will weaken the price cap effects. We should not forget that it was due to PURPA high priced power under long term contracts that Calif. got themselves into many of these problems in the first place. CPUC wants to create managed competition and tinker between new and old capacity and these intrusions blue the market signals. Why are prices still so high in this shoulder season? Generation shortfall is the real reason. Plus Gas prices are high and its the marginal fuel, nuclear outages still exist and seasonal hydro is low and NOX emissions ($45 pound) costs for clean up add to price pressure. Calif. demand for power grew 3 percent per year and supply grew 1 percent per year so shortage was inevitable. CPUC never saw it. It is still not clear these new FERC remedies will fix this gap. Transmission constraints contribute to the supply crisis but the generation shortfall is bigger problem. Low cap is of concern, even if it is a soft cap. At PJM the cap is $1000 and they can exceed their cap in PJM. In Calif there is a case where the stranded costs worked off fast, and incentives to add new plants were missing as power prices were low until demand exceed supply . Calif is a market in short supply and next summer the problems will still be here. If the older plants now have higher costs due to NOX and heat rates, this should signal new plants to come forward and run more and get better margins, esp in So. Calif. But in the future the new gas on gas competition plants will find it harder t o compete and these plants will need 20 years or so to pay out..so the risk to thin margins is real for merchant plant developers.