28 Aug 2001, 13:44 UTC
FW: Transwestern pipeline Colorado Audit FEIN 74-1294795 (Account L80-30571) Tour, Status and Protest (COMPRESSOR FUEL)
- From
- Bob Chandler bob.chandler@enron.com
- To
- Gary Zahn
- Bcc
- Tracy Geaccone
- Date
- Tue, 28 Aug 2001 06:44:42 -0700 (PDT)
FYF Tax exposure.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Rittgers, Dan Sent: Monday, August 27, 2001 11:15 AM To: 'Petersen, John' Cc: Russo, Gavin; Hrna, Sandra Subject: RE: Transwestern pipeline Colorado Audit FEIN 74-1294795 (Account L80-30571) Tour, Status and Protest (COMPRESSOR FUEL) John, I have prepared a more formal position regarding the exemption of "Compressor Fuel" consumed in a "continuing business activity" (Gas services). Before I submit this position to you, I will circulate my position letter within the company and validate the facts. I will be relying primarily on Colorado Regulations 26-102.21 or 39-26-104.1(d.1). Have these regulations changed recently? My service may be out of date. Attached below are schedules for Compressor and Domestic fuel consumption for the audit period. -----Original Message----- From: Petersen, John [mailto:jpetersen@spike.dor.state.co.us] Sent: Monday, July 30, 2001 2:16 PM To: Rittgers, Dan Subject: RE: Transwestern pipeline Colorado Audit FEIN 74-1294795 (Account L80-30571) Tour, Status and Protest Dan, Here is my initial response. I haven't had time to do too much research on this, but this preliminarily the Department's position. Sorry this took so long but I am working on a bankruptcy case which has my first priority. jp > ---------- > From: Rittgers, Dan[SMTP:Dan.Rittgers@ENRON.com] > Sent: Monday, July 23, 2001 12:20 PM > To: Petersen, John > Cc: Russo, Gavin; Hrna, Sandra > Subject: RE: Transwestern pipeline Colorado Audit FEIN 74-1294795 > (Account L80-30571) Tour, Status and Protest > > <<File: REG.doc>><<File: industrial use.doc>> > The trip was very helpful for me as well. I learned a lot from Terry > the day before. > > The decision to proceed further will not be my decision, but I will > prepare an internal analysis, along three main points. In preparing > this internal analysis, it would be helpful to know your (Colorado's) > position on the following issues: > > ASSETS/PURCHASE AND SALE AGREEMENT (PSA) > > Our original position related to the characterization of our purchase as > the purchase of real property, rather than TPP. Regarding your > acquiescence of the pipeline from the original jeopardy assessment under > this argument, thanks that is a big chunk of the original assessment. > My tentative concern under this argument is that foundation, conduit, > wires, pipe and valves remain on the schedule. The compressor might be > a bit more difficult to argue under this position. > > Further, Friday, I submitted a copy of the "Operating and Sale > Agreement". This agreement will further support my position that the > PSA was not a purchase of TPP, but was the purchase of a 77% equity > interest or right to the pipeline's capacity. Using this agreement, my > position is that the transaction is fully exempt as provided by Reg. > 26-102.15 (SEE Reg.doc ATTACHED). It says,' "Tangible personal > property" does not include intangible personal property constituting > mere rights of action..."' Transwestern is acquiring a "right" to > capacity on the pipeline, as stipulated under the terms of "Exhibit C". > Given the "Operating and Sale Agreement", do you see this as a viable > conclusion? If the operating agreement constituted the entirety of the writing accompanying the transfer of cash from Enron to Northwest Pipeline Corp., I might agree. But, the purchase agreement lists assets acquired for cash. > COMPRESSOR FUEL/DOMESTIC FUEL > > I'll get the Compressor and domestic consumption numbers soon, and the > price will be determined a little later. There are separate meters for > measuring Compressor and Domestic fuel consumption. Friday, I submitted > my tax exempt position for Compressor Fuel consumed for Gas Services > (SEE industrial use.doc BELOW). > I don't believe that the statute and regulation support that position. Transporting gas would have to qualify as providing gas or electric service to qualify for the exemption. I don't believe it does. I definitely need more research on this. > PENALTY & INTEREST > > I will be requesting a waiver of penalty and interest on any assessment. > The disposition of penalty and interest will be resolved at a level above the auditor level. > -----Original Message----- > From: Petersen, John [mailto:jpetersen@spike.dor.state.co.us] > Sent: Monday, July 23, 2001 9:52 AM > To: Rittgers, Dan > Subject: RE: Transwestern pipeline Colorado Audit FEIN 74-1294795 > (Account L80-30571) Tour, Status and Protest > > > Dan > > Good morning. Thanks for the tour of the La Plata Facility. It was > very > helpful. I'll remove the $4,803,629 for the 'pipe 30" x .325' from the > proposed taxable amount. Everything else I'll keep as previously > determined > unless I receive additional information from you. > > Also, I look forward to receiving the gas consumed figures for both > domestic > use, which I understand is taxable, and the compressor use which remains > unagreed. If you have a proposal for the valuation of the gas consumed, > that > would be helpful also. Thanks again for the tour and your assistance in > completing the audit. John Petersen, 303-355-0400 x 622. > > ---------- > > From: Dan.Rittgers@enron.com[SMTP:Dan.Rittgers@enron.com] > > Sent: Monday, July 02, 2001 10:08 AM > > To: jpetersen@spike.dor.state.co.us > > Subject: RE: Transwestern pipeline Colorado Audit FEIN 74-1294795 > > (Account L80-30571) Tour, Status and Protest > > > > > > Return Receipt > > > > > > Your RE: Transwestern pipeline Colorado Audit FEIN 74-1294795 > > > > document (Account L80-30571) Tour, Status and Protest > > > > : > > > > > > > > was Dan Rittgers/ENRON@enronXgate > > > > received > > > > by: > > > > > > > > at: 07/02/2001 11:08:50 AM > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >