17 Mar 2001, 12:31 UTC
SDG&E Bundled Customer deDASR Justification
- From
- Dennis Benevides dennis.benevides@enron.com
- To
- Mike D Smith
- Date
- Sat, 17 Mar 2001 04:31:00 -0800 (PST)
The following justification is intended to support potential deDASR decision for SDG&E service territory accounts. For Bundled Contracts (EES & EEMC), EES is responsible for managing all components of the customers bundled bill except taxes. Such components include energy and all UDC related charge components (CTC, post-transition period CTC, transmission, distribution, nuclear decommissioning costs and public purpose programs, i.e. the CA fully bundled bill). Enron has leveraged its risk management skills to manage the risks associated with the regulatory risk embedded within its retail contracts. The discount off tariff product provides the Enron customer with certainty regarding the magnitude and duration of savings derived from deregulation in California. These contracts span the AB1890 transition period and typically brought expected deregulation savings forward for the customer and levelized the savings over the contract term. EES hedges its risk by buying Energy in the same manner as the Utilities during the transition period and locking in supply at fixed prices when customers are exposed to full spot market prices. During the regulated AB1890 transition period, the utilities pay ESPs a PX credit equal to the fully bundled tariff price minus the avoided cost of energy procurement (the PX-credit). EES hedges the T&D, and CTC regulatory risk though a variety of hedging activities including interest rate swaps, development of bundled service index products, electric commodity and other fuel related hedging activities and intervention in Utility regulatory proceedings on behalf of our bundled service customer base. The ability to source from the UDC is implicit within any contract that transfers the price risk for all commodity and UDC-related (non-commodity) costs to Enron. In February, 2001 Enron chose to resource its supply for its SCE and PG&E locations from the host Utility. This resourcing decision was necessary as a result of : a) PG&E/SCE non-compliance with the AB1890 tariffs (Rule 22), b) the demise of the California PX and lack of a liquid hourly market necessary to follow a retail customer load shape and c) to protect our retail customer base against potential discriminatory treatment upon their return to Utility Service upon expiration of their Enron retail energy service contract. Current legislation is now pending that may again provide regulated bundled service rates for SDG&E customers. This legislation has the potential to provide for the discriminatory treatment of direct access service customers upon their return to Utility default service at the expiration of their DA contract term. Upon passage of such legislation, it is imperative that bundled service and direct access customers continue to be treated in a comparable manner. This was a fundamental principle of California deregulation. The passage of such legislation, would result in the continued need for SDG&E to calculate a PX credit associated with energy deliveries by third party ESPs. Under AB1890, the credit is equal to the fully bundled contract price minus the spot market value of the energy plus associated delivery costs imposed on the Schedule Coordinator. The energy only portion of the SDG&E customer bill has continued to be calculated and posted on the SDG&E ESP website even after the suspension of the SDG&E rate freeze in July, 1999. New legislation with a fixed generation rate applicable to SDG&E bundled service customers which allowed for collection of resulting UDC undercollections in future time periods from all customers (including existing DA customers who later return to UDC bundled service) essentially constitutes a return to the AB1890 transition period mechanism for SDG&E. Such legislation may also prevent the establishment of critical mass necessary to support development of a liquid hourly market within California necessary to follow a retail customers load shape without the existence of the PX. In the event of such a reregulation rate freeze, AB1890 and the existing SDG&E tariffs should also make SDG&E liable for such "PX-Credits" to ESPs who have entering into bilateral Bundled Service contracts under the AB1890. In the event that the rules, tariffs or legislation are modified to no longer provide for such PX-credits, EES could preserve the commercial practicality of its CA Bundled Service Contracts by resourcing its supply for EES/EEMC customers located within SDG&E service territory directly from SDG&E.