Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

19 Jun 2001, 14:35 UTC

Pending FERC Order, West-wide Mitigation

From
Ray Alvarez ray.alvarez@enron.com
To
Tim Belden, Mike Swerzbin, michael.driscoll@enron.com, Matt Motley, Robert Badeer, Diana Scholtes, Sean Crandall, Chris Mallory, Jeff Richter, Tom Alonso, Mark Fischer, Phillip Platter
and 37 more Carla Hoffman, Christopher F Calger, Michael Etringer, Steve C Hall, Christian Yoder, Tim Heizenrader, Stephen Swain, Jeff Dasovich, Susan J Mara, Joe Hartsoe, Ray Alvarez, Elliot Mainzer, Bill Williams III, Paul Kaufman, James D Steffes, Phillip K Allen, Mike Grigsby, Don Black, Neil Bresnan, Jubran Whalan, Dennis Benevides, Jess Hewitt, Louise Kitchen, John J Lavorato, Greg Whalley, Richard Shapiro, Steven J Kean, Linda Robertson, Rebecca W Cantrell, Leslie Lawner, Ronald Carroll, Sarah Novosel, Mark Palmer, Tom Briggs, Mark E Haedicke, Alan Comnes, John Shelk
Date
Tue, 19 Jun 2001 07:35:00 -0700 (PDT)
The following report is comprised of what was discussed at the Commission 
meeting held yesterday and additional intelligence gathered from FERC 
staffers after the meeting.  We are awaiting the final order and will update 
this report as soon as it issues. Generally, the order is expected to expand 
the scope of the Commission's April 26 Order, and this report will highlight 
the differences.

Geographical Scope-  Mitigation is extended to cover all 11 western states.

Term- The term of the order will be extended to cover 2 summers.  We expect 
the order to issue today.  If so, the order will take effect at midnight 
tonight and continue in effect until 9/30/02.

Spot Market- Defined as sales of 24 hours or less, transacted on the day of 
delivery or the day prior to delivery.

Must Sell- To prevent physical withholding, the plan will require all sellers 
to offer all their available power in real time.  All California generators, 
even those not subject to FERC price regulation, will be required to sell 
into the ISO's real time market.   Sellers in the rest of the WSCC are 
similarly required to sell, except that they are not required to sell into 
California and can choose their spot market.  They will be required to post 
available power on the Western Systems Power Pool board.  Hydroelectric 
facilities will continue to be exempted.  

Price Mitigation-  Expanded to be in place 24 hours per day, 7 days per week. 
Applies to all sellers, including marketers and non-public utilities.  The 
plan retains a single market clearing price auction for the spot market, 
based on marginal cost bids. The proxy price formula is changed in several 
respects:

 1. Gas price will be the average of the mid-point of the monthly bid week 
prices as reported in Gas Daily   for Malin, SoCal Gas Large Packages and 
PG&E City Gate.
 2. O&M increases from $2 to $6.
 3. Fuel start-up and emissions costs are eliminated from the formula and 
uplifted from the ISO (i.e. these   costs will be recovered from the ISO, but 
will not go into setting the proxy price).
 4. Similarly, a credit adder of 10% will apply, only in CA. 

A reserve deficiency in CA (7% or less) also triggers mitigation for the rest 
of the WSCC.  The applicable price during reserve deficiency periods is the 
proxy price outlined above.  During times when no reserve deficiency exists, 
the mitigated price will be 85% of the highest price calculated in the last 
Stage 1 emergency.  This price will be in effect until the next Stage 1 
emergency.  Sellers can bid higher than the proxy, with justification, during 
periods of reserve deficiency or when no reserve deficiency exists; PROVIDED 
THAT MARKETERS MAY NOT BID ABOVE THE PROXY PRICE.  FERC will consider the 
entire portfolio of a seller who seeks to justify a higher price than the 
proxy.  Generators may seek cost based rates for their entire portfolio in CA 
if they so choose (i.e. no cherry picking).

Demand Side Management- The plan originally set forth in the April 26 order 
is expected be removed in this order. 

ISO Reporting- ISO will need to report on a quarterly basis as to the status 
of building supply in CA. 

Comments- Comments will be sought on the issue of whether the price 
mitigation formula should be adjusted in response to expected varying load 
conditions due to seasonal changes.

Settlement Conference-  The settlement judge will convene a settlement 
conference on the refund issue no later than June 25 (next Monday) and the 
parties will have 15 days to settle.  A report from the judge to the 
Commission is due 7 days thereafter (for a total of 22 days).

Issues that are NOT expected to be addressed in the order include 
confidentiality, ISO board issues, ISO scheduling penalty application, and 
market based rate authorization.  The Order is not finally issued as of yet, 
and the status of the foregoing items could change upon issuance of a Final 
Order.  We will keep you posted.

Ray Alvarez