11 Apr 2001, 13:18 UTC
SCE Agrees to Sell Transmission Assets to California
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Wed, 11 Apr 2001 06:18:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] The CIS Conferencec provides utility management personnel unequaled insight and current information on Customer Relationship Management (CRM), E-Commerce, Technologies and Marketing. Fifty-four sessions conducted by utility industry representatives will focus on issues facing the industry. Over 100 companies will exhibit the latest technologies and services. Former President George Bush is our Honored Keynote Speaker www.cisconference.org Which e-commerce energy provider had over 600,000 customers in nine states at the end of 2000 and expects to become the largest unregulated electricity and gas marketer in the U.S. in the first half of 2001? SCIENTECH'S E-Commerce InfoGrid provides the answer and gives you much more to stay informed. Purchase your InfoGrid today at www.scientech.com or contact Chris Vigil, toll-free at (888) 972-8676 for more information. [IMAGE] In an exclusive SCIENTECH PowerHitters Interview, Cody Graves, CEO of Automated Energy, Inc. and former Chairman of the Oklahoma Corporation Commission, discusses the status of restructuring in Oklahoma and nationwide. Graves also discusses the role Automated Energy is playing in providing an essential piece of the restructuring pie. Read more at: www.scientech.com [IMAGE] [IMAGE] April 11, 2001 SCE Agrees to Sell Transmission Assets to California by Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis At a joint press conference with Governor Gray Davis, Edison International Chairman, President and CEO John Bryson announced agreement on a plan to restore Southern California Edison (SCE) to financial health. "The negotiated resolution with the Governor is far preferable for our company, our employees and for our customers than is going into bankruptcy," Bryson said. The key part of the agreement is that the state will receive a primary utility asset* SCE's 12,000 mile transmission system. SCE employees will operate and maintain the system through a contractual arrangement with the state. Analysis: Only days after Pacific Gas & Electric Co., its California utility counterpart, declared bankruptcy, SCE announced what is being billed as a pact with the State of California that should keep it out of bankruptcy court. From all appearances, this seems to be a strong deal for SCE, as it not only keeps the utility financially solvent but also removes it from a line of business that remains rather uncertain and financially unrewarding. First, let's establish the key aspects of the agreement. Keep in mind that the California Legislature, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and federal regulators must approve this deal. Edison International (NYSE: EIX), the parent of SCE, has agreed to sell the utility's transmission assets to the State of California for $2.76 billion. The confirmed price tag that the state is paying for SCE's lines seems like a generous offer because it is about 2.3 times the system's current book value of $1.2 billion (the original cost, less any accumulated depreciation (OCLD) recorded in SCE's books). Since transmission rates are based on an allowed rate of return on OCLD, it is uncertain that SCE's current transmission rates will provide sufficient revenues for the state to cover its purchase cost. The sale includes only SCE's transmission assets. It appears that SCE will remain in the distribution business and continue delivering power to customers and running generation. Both the state and SCE have agreed to commit to no less than $3 billion of capital investment in utility infrastructure over the next five years, which presumably includes upgrades to the transmission system and new generation capacity. It is not entirely clear at this time how the $3 billion in capital investment will be shared between the State of California and SCE. Edison officials also have agreed to sell cost-based (not market-based) electricity to the state from power generated at SCE plants. Edison Mission Energy, the unregulated subsidiary of Edison International, is also obligated to sell output from its Sunrise power plant exclusively to California under cost-based pricing. Although SCE divested much of its power assets under agreements with the CPUC, it still shares ownership of the San Onofre Nuclear Plant Units 1, 2 and 3 with San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E), and shares in the Palo Verde, Mohave and Four Corners generating stations. SCE also owns hydroelectric facilities and the Pebbly Beach generating facility. The Sunrise Mission power project is a gas-fired power plant that is currently under construction. Reportedly, the Sunrise plant is expected to provide about 320 MW of electricity during peak periods of demand this summer. According to the Memorandum of Understanding between SCE and the California Department of Water Resources, "SCE's generation assets*including all energy, capacity, ancillary services, and any combination thereof*will be committed to cost-based ratemaking for SCE's bundled service customers." In addition, SCE is prohibited from selling any of these generation assets until Dec. 31, 2010. Also included within the agreement is SCE's commitment to dismiss all pending lawsuits against the CPUC related to market prices in California. Edison International also has agreed to refund $400 million to the utility unit that reportedly had been paid in dividends to the parent company. The $2.76 billion that the state is paying SCE for its transmission assets can be used to pay pre-existing debt to creditors, including power generators that have previously sold power to SCE. This is the essential benefit that the utility receives in the deal and it is a considerable achievement given that the liquid capital theoretically should stave off bankruptcy proceedings. It is also important to note that this is the first revenue stream that has been specifically earmarked for SCE's pre-existing debts. Recent rate increases that have been approved by the CPUC can only be applied to subsequent debts incurred by the utility. In addition, SCE will be allowed to issue bonds to recover a "substantial portion" of the approximate $5 billion in debt that the utility has accrued due to uncollected purchases of wholesale power. The agreement should return SCE's debt to investment grade, making it easier for the company to raise money to fund future operations. By reducing its debt load, Edison CEO John Bryson remains confident that SCE "can borrow to pay out [remaining] debts." SCE Chairman and CEO Stephen Frank expressed confidence that a final agreement could be reached "before the end of the year," although the California Legislature reportedly has agreed to expedite its own review of the agreement and provide approval before summer temperatures begin to wreak havoc on the California market. If for any reason the sale of the transmission assets has not been completed within two years, SCE is obligated to sell to the state its hydroelectric generation facilities instead (at a to-be-determined price). Although the deal is expected to proceed, some concerns have been raised about federal issues related to interstate commerce. In addition, the fact that Pacific Gas & Electric Co.*with which SCE has often been intertwined*remains in bankruptcy court could also complicate the agreement between SCE and the state. News of the agreement immediately caused Edison shares to increase by about $2.16, or 24 percent, to $11.08 on April 9. As of the close of trading on April 10, Edison shares were priced at about $11.38. For its part, SCE said that it was "racing toward" an agreement with the governor to avoid being forced into an involuntary bankruptcy. Yet, for some time, SCE has been more willing to sell its transmission assets than PGOever appeared to be. In fact, I wrote in the 2/26/01 IssueAlert that Gov. Davis had reached an "agreement in principle" with SCE regarding the sale of the transmission lines. Most of the key elements of the agreement that has been agreed to by both parties have been in the works for over two months. PGOCorp. issued a statement that it was pleased that SCE had been able to reach an agreement with Gov. Davis, but said that the agreement did not change its own direction toward bankruptcy court. According to a report on CBS.MarketWatch.com, Fitch analysts have suggested that the sale of SCE's transmission assets to the state of California could in fact lend a "framework" that might be used in Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s bankruptcy proceedings. What this might mean is that Federal Judge Dennis Montali, the official overseeing Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s bankruptcy, might rely upon the agreement between SCE and the State of California to mandate a similar deal for PG&E. Gov. Davis commented that the SCE deal could serve as a basis for separate agreements with SDG&E, and eventually PG&E, if they choose to come back to the negotiating table. In fact, the state could submit a plan to Judge Montali outlining a purchase of PG&E's transmission assets, which the judge could ultimately enforce. An argument could be made that the agreement SCE has reached with the State of the California provides benefits to the utility that go beyond protecting it from bankruptcy. One could argue that SCE benefits by being able to exit the transmission business altogether, which in many ways can cause tremendous problems for the companies that choose to remain in this business. Transmission operations also typically offer a low rate of return; in SCE's case, according to its most recent 10K filing, its transmission business resulted in a return on equity of 9.68 percent. SCE had proposed that the return on equity for its transmission assets be set at 11.6 percent, which FERC rejected (FERC has ultimate authority over transmission service pricing). Thus, the question could be raised of why SCE would even want to remain in the transmission business, given this low return on equity. Behind the scenes, SCE could very well have previously made the determination that its transmission business was not a valuable part of its overall operation. This could be representative of an international trend, as regulatory agencies in Australia and Great Britain have also set lower limits on the average transmission network charges that utilities can implement. Moreover, the State of California does not bring extensive operational expertise to its new role as a transmission owner. Thus, the state is wise to keep SCE employees in charge of the operation and maintenance of the transmission system. This substantially reduces the risk for the state, which is a prudent move. From the state's perspective, it gets an asset in exchange for a bailout, which makes its investment in SCE beneficial. However, the transmission business will present unique challenges for the state, such as raising capital for transmission improvements and siting procedures. The state may quickly learn why the transmission business is perceived as being so challenging, and why it is difficult to entice companies to build new transmission lines (especially considering the low rate of return that the transmission business offers). On the other hand, by assuming the role of a transmission system owner, the State of California will be in a position to obtain competitive information about the activities of power generators in the state. This could result in a significant advantage for the State of California if it remains in its current power-buying role. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.scientech.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.