20 Feb 2001, 17:38 UTC
(no subject)
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 20 Feb 2001 09:38:00 -0800 (PST)
Hi Rosalee:
Steve Kean asked that I send you this note for transmittal to Ken Lay. Mr.
Lay may receive a call from David Freeman regarding on-going power
negotiations between the California Department of Water and Enron, but it is
not certain that he will call. In the event that he does phone, we would
like to make sure that Mr. Lay gets this information prior returning the
call. Thanks very much for your help.
All the best,
Jeff
Mr. Lay:
As you know we've been working very hard with David Freeman trying to hammer
out a power deal with CDWR. The big issue getting in the way of the deal
continues to be credit. I've attached the summary of the credit issues and
possible solutions to the problem that was included in the email to Senator
Brulte last week. As part of the ongoing efforts to resolve the credit
issues, Chris Calger of the Portland office sent a letter to David Freeman
yesterday. That letter is also attached. In sum, the letter:
expresses our commitment to continue working together to resolve the credit
issues,and,
requests payment for power previously delivered to CDWR and pre-payment for
any new deliveries.
In response, David Freeman phoned Chris Calger expressing dissappointment
that 1) we had yet to sign a power deal with DWR, despite your meeting with
Dave Freeman and Mike Peevey a couple of weeks ago, and 2) we would make a
power deal contingent upon a) payment for power previously delivered to DWR
and b) pre-payment for any future deliveries. Freeman suggested that we
could sign the deal for 200 MWs of power now, but then back out of the deal
if CDWR fails to get adequate credit provisions in place within the next few
weeks. Given the political climate in California, we are of course not
anxious to sign a deal today that carries significant credit risk and
announce later that we are backing out of the deal, since doing so would
place the Company in a very uncomfortable political position. Instead, we
continue to suggest that it's best for all parties to have the credit issues
resolved up front.
You may receive a call from David Freeman seeking to discuss these issues
further. As you know, the credit issues are significant and we are working
hard to overcome those issues. But in the current climate, where the
Governor and the Legislature are actively discussing a complete takeover of
the electric industry in California, getting the contract issues right is
critical.
Regards,
Jeff Dasovich
SUMMARY OF CREDIT ISSUES FROM BRULTE EMAIL
Credit Concerns Regarding Authority Granted to DWR in AB1X to Purchase
Electricity on Behalf of the Utilities
Enron responded to the RFP issued by DWR to enter into power contracts with
suppliers.
Enron is in active discussions with DWR to establish contract terms with the
goal of entering into a power purchase agreement as soon as possible.
However, ambiguities contained in AB1X have created significant credit risk
concerns that need to be resolved in order to finalize contract terms.
We understand that the lion,s share of counterparties share Enron,s credit
risk concerns.
Enron has proposed several options for resolving the credit risk issues and
is working with DWR to arrive at a solution that is mutually agreeable to
both sides and that might serve as a template for power purchase agreements
going forward.
Summary of the Source of the Credit Risk Issue
Ambiguous Ratemaking Authority
The language in AB1X is ambiguous as to whether DWR has any authority to
charge California ratepayers for the costs of purchasing power. From our
analysis of the bill, the language in AB1X appears to leave intact the
California PUC,s exclusive jurisdiction over ratemaking in California. As
such, suppliers have no assurance that the PUC will agree to include in rates
adequate charges to cover DWR,s costs of power purchases.
Ambiguous Regulatory Authority Regarding Contract &Prudence8
The language in AB1X leaves open the possibility that the California Public
Utilities Commission could determine that power purchases made by DWR are
&imprudent.8 On the basis of such a finding, the CPUC could then refuse to
allow DWR to collect from ratepayers the costs associated with its power
purchases. Consequently, suppliers have no assurance that the PUC will agree
to include in rates the charges to cover the costs of power contracts that
DWR has entered into with suppliers.
Ambiguous Language Regarding the Ratemaking Mechanism that Will Be Used to
Recover DWR,s Costs of Power Purchases
In addition to the ambiguity regarding ratemaking and regulatory authority
noted above, the language in the bill is equally ambiguous with respect to
the specific ratemaking &mechanics8 that AB1X directs the PUC to employ to
permit DWR to recover its power purchase costs. Based on our analysis, it is
extremely difficult to determine how the PUC would design the rates to ensure
DWR recovers its power purchase costs. Moreover, as currently drafted, it is
difficult to determine whether AB1X would even permit the PUC to include in
rates all of the charges necessary to fully recover DWR,s power purchase
costs. Again, this ambiguity raises significant credit risk concerns since
suppliers have little assurance that DWR will have the ability to recover
from ratepayers the costs of purchasing power.
Options to Resolve Concerns Regarding Credit Risk
We have been working diligently with DWR officials to resolve the credit risk
issues. We have identified three options:
Amend AB1X
The amendments, which are attached to this email, would clarify that a) the
PUC would accept as &prudent and reasonable8 all purchase costs incurred by
DWR, and b) the PUC is obligated to include in rates the charges necessary to
ensure that DWR fully recovers its costs of power purchases. This is the
preferred option, though we understand that the there may be some political
challenges standing in the way of amending AB1X. (See attached file
entitled, &AmendAB1X.doc8.)
Clarify the Ambiguities in AB1X through an Order Issued by the PUC, and
through Contract Language
This is the option that we are currently working with DWR officials to
implement. However, it is more complicated and could take significantly more
time to implement than the "legislative" fix. We have attached electronic
copies of the talking points related to the order that the California PUC
would need to issue under this option. (See attached file entitled,
&cpuctalkingpoints.doc.8)
Make Use of Other Instruments Designed to Address Credit Risk
As indicated in our letter responding to DWR,s RFP, we are willing to accept
other forms of credit from DWR. Those options include a letter of credit,
cash prepayment, or an acceptable form of collateral. DWR officials have
indicated to us that DWR prefers to pursue the second options. That is, DWR
prefers to clarify the ambiguities in AB1X through a PUC order and through
contract amendments.
LETTER FROM CHRIS CALGER TO DAVID FREEMAN
February 19, 2001
S. David Freeman, Advisor to the Governor
California Department of Water Resources
1416 ) 9th Street
Sacramento, California 95814
FAX# (213) 897-9560
Re: Proposed Short-Term CAISO Firm Energy Sale
Dear Mr. Freeman,
As we described in our Response to Notice and Invitation to Bid dated
February 6, 2001, Enron Power Marketing Inc. (&EPMI8) and its affiliates are
prepared to provide California Department of Water Resources (&CDWR8) various
power and power-related products. At this time, however, EPMI and CDWR are
not in agreement with respect to the form of contract and the credit support
required to enter into long-term transactions. In response to your request
of February 14, 2001, EPMI proposes that CDWR consider a short-term firm
energy transaction.
EPMI is prepared to offer to CDWR CAISO Firm Energy under the attached EEI
Agreement and Confirmation Letter subject to (i) the payment in full by CDWR
to EPMI on or before February 21, 2001 for deliveries of power already made
by EPMI to CDWR; (ii) confirmation that CDWR will pay EPMI in full for the
new power deliveries according to the schedule described in the attached
Confirmation Letter; and (iii) CDWR will in good faith consider the following
proposals described in our Response To Notice and Invitation to Bid dated
February 6, 2001:
a) Unit Contingent Power supply from Pastoria Energy Facility
b) Firm Power Supply from Market Sources
c) Hourly Demand Response Program
The amounts due from CDWR to EPMI are described below:
DATE DESCRIPTION NET SALES
JAN CDWR $578,870.00
JAN CDWR $4,913,100.00
FEB CERS $6,014,000.00
FEB1-17 Block Forward $2,502,000.00
Total: $14,007,970.00
The above amount can be wire transferred to:
BNK: Bank of America
For: Enron Power Marketing, Inc.
ABA: Routing # 111000012
ACCT: #375 046 9312
Confirmation: Enron Power Marketing, Inc.
Credit and Collections
(713) 853-5667
If we find that payment has been made, we will be able to offer a firm price,
and if we are in agreement at that time, we will sign and forward the
attached documents. On Friday, February 16, 2001, the price for the power
described in the attached Confirmation Letter was $270 per MWh. The price is
subject to change based on market conditions and will need to be revised and
confirmed prior to execution of the attached Confirmation Letter.
EPMI is available to discuss this proposal at your convenience and we will be
available on Tuesday, February 20, 2001 to discuss the amounts payable
described above. We are prepared to continue working with you and your team
to establish a Master Agreement with sufficient credit support to enable us
to enter into other agreements that best meet your power purchase needs. I
can be reached at (503) 464-3735.
Yours Truly,
ENRON POWER MARKETING, INC.
Christopher F. Calger
Managing Director