15 Jul 2001, 22:15 UTC
Re: Please read- Argentina economic risk
- From
- Guillermo Canovas guillermo.canovas@enron.com
- Date
- Sun, 15 Jul 2001 15:15:00 -0700 (PDT)
I assume the issue is TGS (instead of CGS) I will call you after sending this mail. Below is a small analysis related to the convertibility Law and TGS. 1. Argentina Convertibility Law No 23,928. The Convertibility Law passed on March 1991 determined the following: ? Established a fixed exchange rate between the dollar and the national currency (1 dollar = 10,000 Australes, latter defined as equal to 1 peso) ? The Central Bank (Argentine Federal Reserve) must permanently have international reserves (dollars, gold, other currencies) available to back 100% of the monetary base. The Central Bank must sell all required dollars at the fixed exchange rate. ? It is forbidden any price adjustment clause by an index. ? For all transactions agreed upon before the Law, prices could not be larger than the contractual price, adjusted by the exchange rate variation plus 12% a year (section 9). This section affected contracts in force. ? The Convertibility Law was just amended on June 22nd 2001 by the Law 25445, to equal 1 peso to the simple average of 1 dollar and 1 euro. Anyway, according to its section 2, the new Convertibility rule will only be in force once the price market of 1 dollar is equal to 1 euro (to avoid a surprise devaluation). 2. Legal requirements for a devaluation To modify the exchange rate before 1 dollar = 1 euro, it would be necessary to abolish or amend again the Convertibility Law. In such regards, the Congress would have to abolish the Convertibility Law or keep the Convertibility at a different exchange rate. Although in principle a devaluation should not affect contracts with prices set in dollars, even the Convertibility Law has affected contracts that were in force. So, there is a certain risk that a new eventual amendment of the Convertibility Law could affect contracts in force. In fact I think there is a higher risk of the government breaching the contracts or defaulting debt payments than devaluating the currency by surprise. 3. Impact on TGS Since the privatization rules establish that TGS, rates are in dollars, a devaluation that respects contracts in force should not have a significant impact on TGS financial results. However, due to the social impact of a devaluation, the Congress could pass a new law establishing a new mechanism to calculate Public Utilities rates. The higher the percentage of devaluation (and the higher the social turmoil), the higher is the probability that this kind of Law would be passed. Richard Shapiro 07/15/2001 06:32 PM To: Guillermo Canovas/SA/Enron@Enron cc: Subject: Please read- Argentina economic risk Let's discuss.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron on 07/15/2001 04:36 PM --------------------------- From: Robert Johnston/ENRON@enronXgate on 07/12/2001 10:54 AM To: Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Kevin Hannon/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Brendan Fitzsimmons/ENRON@enronXgate, Scott Tholan/ENRON@enronXgate Subject: Please read- Argentina economic risk Hi Rick- Kevin Hannon asked that we contact you to coordinate some market intelligence research pertaining to the deepening financial crisis in Argentina. Kevin would like us to investigate how Enron's CGS project will be treated by the Argentinean govt should a default or devaluation take place. We understand that you have the contract providing more information on how the project is protected by international treaty. It would be great if we could get a copy and meet with you briefly to discuss this request. Thanks for any help you can provide during what I know is a very busy time for you! Robert Johnston Manager, Market Analysis Enron Wholesale Services x39934