26 Jul 2000, 16:55 UTC
Re: PACIFIC VIRGO
- From
- Matthias Lee matthias.lee@enron.com
- To
- Britt Davis
- Cc
- Alan Aronowitz, Harry M Collins, Deborah Shahmoradi, Brenda McAfee, Richard B Sanders, Angeline Poon
- Bcc
- Alan Aronowitz, Harry M Collins, Deborah Shahmoradi, Brenda McAfee, Richard B Sanders, Angeline Poon
- Date
- Wed, 26 Jul 2000 09:55:00 -0700 (PDT)
Britt
I have planned to meet with WFW (Neale Gregson) and Capt Sawant again
tomorrow. One of the issues I want to revisit with Capt Sawant is the issue
of putting the Owners on notice of the sensitivity of the cargo. I recall
Capt Sawant's opinion not to be as categoric as expressed in the memo, but
want to absolutely sure. Like you, I feel it is a very important point. I
will be discussing the issue of additional experts with Neale as well. Neale
Gregson is an experienced maritime arbitration counsel and has experts he is
able to recommend.
As for privilege and discoverable documents, I discussed the issue with Neale
today and he recommends that communication with experts be routed through WFW
to avoid the issue. Reports to date and internal correspondence from in-house
counsel would be privileged as well. Attached is Neale's fax on this issue
for your reference:
Regards
Matt
From: Britt Davis@ENRON on 07/25/2000 09:07 PM
To: Matthias Lee/SIN/ECT@ECT
cc: Alan Aronowitz/HOU/ECT@ECT, Harry M Collins/HOU/ECT@ECT, Deborah
Shahmoradi/NA/Enron@Enron, Brenda McAfee/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Richard B
Sanders/HOU/ECT@ECT
Subject: Re: PACIFIC VIRGO
Matt,
Good report. I am concerned about this expert's conclusions, the most
troubling of which is that our putting the ship on notice of the end use of
the cargo would have been of so little importance. That is probably our
strongest point. I also share your concern about his lack of experience as a
witness in an arbitration. We need an expert who is well respected by U.K.
arbitrators and their tribunals. I will likewise try to get other names.
Meanwhile, I question whether we should ask Capt Sawant to put anything in
writing concerning how to beef up his second report until we talk further. I
am concerned that anything he puts in writing may be discoverable in a U.K.
arbitration proceeding if we use him as an expert and/or if he has any
otherwise discoverable factual information. Would you mind passing this
concern by WFW for its comment? I am assuming that the WFW counsel with whom
you are speaking are experienced maritime arbitration counsel.
Thank you for keeping us advised. Deborah, please print this out (including
the attachment) for the file.
Britt Davis
Matthias Lee@ECT
07/25/2000 05:37 AM
To: Matthias Lee/SIN/ECT@ECT
cc: Britt Davis/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Alan Aronowitz/HOU/ECT@ECT, Harry M
Collins/HOU/ECT@ECT, Deborah Shahmoradi/NA/Enron@Enron, Brenda
McAfee/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Michael A Robison/HOU/ECT@ECT, Angeline
Poon/SIN/ECT@ECT
Subject: Re: PACIFIC VIRGO
Attached is the Memo of the meeting prepared by WFW. Although Capt Sawant is
very knowledgeable, he has never been an expert witness in an Arbitration. I
will be discussing with WFW about alternative experts.
Regards
Matt
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Matthias Lee 07/25/2000 03:30 PM To: Britt Davis/Corp/Enron@ENRON cc: Alan Aronowitz/HOU/ECT@ECT, Harry M Collins/HOU/ECT@ECT, Deborah Shahmoradi/NA/Enron@Enron, Brenda McAfee/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Michael A Robison/HOU/ECT@ECT, Angeline Poon/SIN/ECT@ECT (bcc: Matthias Lee/SIN/ECT) Subject: Re: PACIFIC VIRGO Team Just a brief update. We are presently trying to consolidate all existing samples in singapore for joint testing and analysis. We are facing some difficulty with the Batangas samples because SGS Philippines has advised that they cannot airfreight the samples without using IATA containers and that would involve breaking the seals. Eric is examining our options to transport the samples to Singapore and will be seeking the input of Cliff Bennett (Minton Treharne). One possibility may be to transport by sea, but I understand that will take 5 days voyage but vessels between Philippines and Singapore are infrequent. Meanwhile, I have been in contact with external counsel Watson Farley & Williams (WFW) to finalise our legal position. WFW attended at our office and interviewed with Capt. Sawant of PacMarine. WFW is preparing the memo of the meeting which I will distribute when received. FYI - the broker confirmed yesterday that Mitsubishi Corporation is the time charterer of the vessel. Regards Matt