20 Oct 2000, 14:26 UTC
Market Manipulation or Fair Earnings in California? Enron, Dynegy Report Huge Profits
- From
- Peggy Mahoney peggy.mahoney@enron.com
- To
- Vicki Sharp, Harold Buchanan, Elizabeth Tilney, Mark Palmer, Karen Denne, Richard Shapiro, Steven J Kean, Scott Gahn, Greg Cordell, Dennis Benevides, Jeff Dasovich
- Date
- Fri, 20 Oct 2000 07:26:00 -0700 (PDT)
FYI
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Peggy Mahoney/HOU/EES on 10/20/2000 02:23 PM --------------------------- "IssueAlert" <IssueAlert@scientech.com> on 10/19/2000 06:24:37 AM To: cc: Subject: Market Manipulation or Fair Earnings in California? Enron, Dynegy Report Huge Profits http://www.consultrci.com ************************************************************************ TrueQuote completes connection to EnronOnline and receives equity investment from PG&E. Find out more about SCIENTECH'S E-Commerce InfoGrid at: http://www.consultrci.com ************************************************************************ =============================================================== SCIENTECH IssueAlert, October 19, 2000 Market Manipulation or Fair Earnings in California? Enron, Dynegy Report Huge Profits By: Will McNamara, Director, Electric Industry Analysis =============================================================== As energy companies report third quarter earnings, many active as wholesale providers are announcing huge profits. For instance, Enron Corp. and Dynegy have both reported over-the-top earnings for the third quarter, reaping the benefits of skyrocketing energy prices and a continued focus on asset expansion. Both companies benefited from high energy prices this summer, especially in California where electricity prices soared to record levels, resulting in a doubling and tripling of the generation part of power bills for San Diego Gas & Electric Co. (SDG&E) customers. At the same time that these companies are reporting huge earnings, accusations have been leveled that generators and trading companies "manipulated the production of power from June through August to create a false shortage and push up prices." ANALYSIS: First, let me say that I am not picking on Enron and Dynegy. They just happened to release their Q3 earnings comparatively early, opening themselves up for evaluation. According to the California Energy Commission, other non-utility owners or traders of power in California include Calpine, Destec, Duke, Reliant, Southern, and Williams, who altogether own about 40 percent of the generation in the state (compared to the 15 percent owned by California's three investor-owned utility companies). As additional 3Q financial statements are released, I would expect any company that is active on the wholesale market to report a significant increase in earnings, reflective of the summer price volatility. Even a mid-size utility like the Public Service Company of New Mexico (PNM) has posted whopping profits for Q3, which it attributed directly to the "scalding wholesale electric market in the Western United States." With that said, let's take a look at the numbers that we have for the big players, which are startling. Enron's recurring net income, up 31 percent, rose to $292 million, or 34 cents a share, compared with 1999 third quarter earnings of $223 million, or 27 cents a share. By its own admission, sales in Enron's four business units*wholesale energy operations and services, retail energy services, transportation and distribution, and broadband services*grew nearly $30 billion in the third quarter alone. The income before interest, minority interests and taxes (IBIT) reported by Enron's wholesale group increased 66 percent in 3Q to $627 million from $378 million a year ago. The commodity sales and services business increased IBIT to $404 million in 3Q compared to $172 million last year. CEO Kenneth Lay says he is "very optimistic about the continued strong growth" of the company. Over at Dynegy, they are singing the same happy tune. Dynegy reported recurring net income of $176.5 million, or 55 cents a share, compared with Dynegy / Illinova pro forma recurring net income of $96.5 million, or 32 cents per share, for the same period last year. Much of this growth is coming from Dynegy Marketing and Trade, whose reported net income increased to $141.9 million*80 percent of the company's consolidated net income. While neither Enron nor Dynegy has mentioned California in their explanations of the strong Q3 earnings, clearly the high prices in the state must have played a large role in the companies' profits. I think most everyone was expecting any company active in wholesale trading to show strong numbers in the third quarter, based on the high prices in California alone, but the extent of the increase is really stunning. The short answer for the price spikes has been that demand in the state increased to unanticipated highs, while supply became stretched to meet the power needs. Going a step further, limited transmission lines, the fact that no new (significant) power plants have been built in almost two decades, and a 3-percent increase in demand drove costs up in California instead of down. Exacerbating the already tight supplies was the fact that some 2,220 MW of generation, mostly in Southern California, was unavailable during the summer months due to power plant mechanical failures. Plus, growing demand in Arizona and lower hydroelectric production in the Pacific Northwest also contributed to the squeeze in supplies on which California could rely. Customers of SDG&E were hit hardest of all as the utility had paid off its stranded costs, removing a rate freeze and exposing customers to market-based prices. Customers of the other two California IOUs*SCE and PG&E*were protected because they were still under a rate freeze. However, the utilities themselves claim to have also suffered from the price spikes as they buy a great deal of their power on the wholesale market. Due to limited supplies, PG&E and SCE were forced to pay market prices for power but yet were unable to increase their customers' rates. For instance, PG&E claims it was paying $0.18/KWh for energy when by law it could only charge customers $0.055/KWh, leaving it with an estimated $2.7 billion debt that it is petitioning the CPUC to bill back to customers. All of this has been characterized as the "fiasco in California," leaving many to conclude that the market in the state is not workably competitive. The only clear winners in the situation were the wholesale providers, who appeared to simply benefit from the low supply and high demand cycles that drove California this summer. The California Power Exchange, the state's power auction through which all power is traded, issued a recent report acknowledging that, while the state's electricity market is severely flawed, it could find "no pattern of abuse by any group, individual or company participating in the state's main electricity auction." Rather, the California PX maintains that the price spikes were caused by the high demand for electricity, a lack of new generation, higher natural-gas prices, and a drop in out-of-state electricity imports. Yet, a new report initiated by a group of utilities in the Pacific Northwest, casts doubt on this and suggests that wholesale providers actually caused the high energy prices. A Portland-based firm that conducted a private investigation of the California market asserts that the state had plenty of electricity generation this summer, and that wholesale providers withheld power to create artificially high prices. Specifically, the report*written by economist and utility industry consultant Robert McCollough*says California in fact had a 32-percent reserve margin, despite the high prices and the fact that the California ISO issued repeated power emergencies all summer claiming that the state was in a critical power shortage. In addition, McCollough claims that demand in California was actually lower than what was forecast by the Western Systems Coordinating Council. Using EPA data to suggest that power plants ran below full capacity during peak times last summer, McCollough accuses generators of voluntarily lowering their production to drive up prices*essentially creating a market power situation in which energy buyers are left with little choice but to pay exorbitant prices. The report cites Dynegy as an example. Dynegy and NRG Energy Inc. are involved in a joint venture called Cabrillo Power, which oversees the operation of the Encina power plant in Carlsbad, Calif. McCollough reports that the Encina plant operated at well below its full capacity for much of June, even though wholesale prices were well above the generating plant's cost of production. A representative from Cabrillo Power denied that the Encina plant had been used to game the system in this way, and stated that, in fact, the plant was often in danger of being shut down last summer due to heavy output. The response to both McCollough's and the PX's report has been very mixed. One camp remains steadfast in claiming that western states did indeed have a supply shortage this summer, which was the primary reason for the high prices. People in this camp also claim that data from the EPA about power plant emissions are questionable. On the other hand, other investigations continue, following the same claim that generators have gamed the system. The central question to be answered is whether or not companies that generate and/or trade power held back power from the California PX in order to force heavier use of real-time markets at higher prices. Certainly, wholesale providers knew that their power had to be dispatched and understandably they were pleased by the high price of power this summer. Yet this is not the same thing as purposeful manipulation, which has not been officially determined. FERC and the CPUC have been examining these claims since July, and the California attorney general also has initiated an investigation. At this point, there is no clear answer*only a lot of questions and one independent report that has made questionable assertions. =============================================================== Discover a world of utilities information in our new e-zine, SourceBook Online. Get a free SourceBook Weekly article at: http://www.consultrci.com/web/rciweb.nsf/Web+Pages/SBEntrance.html =============================================================== SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly at: http://www.consultrci.com/web/infostore.nsf/Products/IssueAlert Sincerely, Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis wmcnamara@scientech.com =============================================================== Feedback regarding SCIENTECH's IssueAlert should be sent to wmcnamara@scientech.com =============================================================== SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are compiled based on independent analysis by SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy and telecommunications issues. Copyright 2000. SCIENTECH, Inc. If you do not wish to receive any further IssueAlerts from SCIENTECH, please reply to this message and in the body of the email type "remove."