7 Dec 2000, 10:48 UTC
We should lobby for relaxation of emmission limits
- From
- Roger Yang roger.yang@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 7 Dec 2000 02:48:00 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Roger Yang/SFO/EES on 12/07/2000 08:35 AM --------------------------- Scott Stoness 12/06/2000 06:29 PM To: Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES@EES cc: Roger Yang/SFO/EES@EES, Gordon Savage/HOU/EES@EES, Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron Subject: We should lobby for relaxation of emmission limits Getting the government to declare stage 2 continuously (or temporarly relaxing the emmission during periods of cold) for the remaining month could significantly reduce the problems in CA. We should see what press we can make over this. See bolded below: 11,000 MW of generation off line due to unplanned outage and emmission limits. Scott Calif Price Cap Driving In-State Power To Oregon, Wash By Mark Golden and Jason Leopold 12/06/2000 Dow Jones Energy Service (Copyright (c) 2000, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.) NEW YORK -(Dow Jones)- California's wholesale electricity price cap is so far below free-market prices in the Northwest that large amounts of the state's electricity will be exported Wednesday to the Northwest, raising the risk of blackouts in California. On Tuesday, electricity in the Northwest for delivery Wednesday traded at $370-$390 a megawatt-hour, well above the California Independent System Operator's price cap of $250/MWh. California utilities, which buy most of their power in the California Power Exchange's day-ahead market, refuse to pay more there than the ISO's $250/MWh limit. Nor do sellers bother to offer power at more than $250 in the CalPX market. Seeing an opportunity for arbitrage profits, Northwest utilities and electricity trading companies appeared in CalPX's market Tuesday as buyers, even though California utilities are usually the only buyers there, a CalPX market source said. They bought power through the exchange at $400/MWh at the California-Oregon border hub - $250/MWh for the power and $150 per megawatt to import the power - leaving the state with less electricity for Wednesday and leaving California's independent power producers wondering who gets the difference between the $250/MWh maximum price they get from the CalPX and the $400/MWh CalPX charges buyers in the Northwest. Transmission lines that carry power into and out of California were congested Tuesday because of the imports and exports of power. Due to the congestion, the charge to use the lines was $150/MWh, CalPX market sources said. California looks to be priced out of the market for the next couple of months. Forward contracts for electricity in Washington state peaked Tuesday at $750/MWh for deliveries in January, before falling to $650/MWh. For the balance of December in Washington state, power traded at $1,200/MWh. Of course, California could get back into the market by abandoning its price cap, which has been breaking down for the week due to skyrocketing wholesale prices for natural gas. Quietly, the ISO has been purchasing power at prices above its cap outside of its computer-based market in deals struck orally with out-of-state utilities. The resolution setting up the price cap allows for such out-of-market purchases if needed in a supply emergency - but only from out-of-state sources. The ISO declared a Stage 2 electrical emergency Wednesday as reserves dipped below 5%. It was the third consecutive Stage 2 emergency this week, which has seen the state teeter on the brink of rolling blackouts due to less than adequate supply. On Monday, the ISO said the state would face an 11,000 MW deficit every day for the remainder of the year because several power plants are off line for planned or unplanned maintenance, or because they have exhausted their pollution credits. In the CalPX's hourly market Tuesday, prices peaked above the cap for only the second time in the CalPX's three years of operations, CalPX spokesman Jesus Arredondo said. Some traders said that California utilities are effectively conceding that the ISO price cap, which the utilities and state politicians pushed through the ISO governing board this summer, is no longer enforceable because natural gas prices have pushed generating costs above $250/MWh. Cash prices for natural gas in California hit $40 per million British thermal units Wednesday. At $22/MMBtu, once the costs for maintenance and emitting nitrous oxide are added in, generating costs rise to near $300/MWh. -By Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604; mark.golden@dowjones.com