Undated
Re: Re[2]: DPC Naphtha Hedge
- From
- Mark - ECT Legal Taylor mark.taylor@enron.com
- Cc
- Doug Leach
- Bcc
- Doug Leach
- Date
- Mon, 31 Dec 1979 16:00:00 -0800 (PST)
Marc, We have sought, and paid for, advice from Indian counsel concerning commodity derivative transactions with Indian counterparites. We have had that advice updated and confirmed in connection with this proposed transaction. The result of that advice is that we will require an opinion from DPC's outside counsel that the proposed transaction is enforceable against DPC before the transaction can proceed. While I have no legal objection to sending a form of L/C that would be acceptable to us, it doesn't make much sense to go through the exercise if DPC will not be providing the necessary opinions. Mark
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Marc De La Roche 02/24/99 07:42 AM To: Mark - ECT Legal Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Doug Leach/HOU/ECT@ECT, Ram Srivastav@Enron, Vinayak S Bapat@Enron, Pavan Dave@Enron Subject: Re[2]: DPC Naphtha Hedge Mark, Contrary to the response received from DPC's President, Ram Srivastav, the CFO Vinayak S Bapat is not willing to investigate DPC's legal position with respect to the derivatives at DPC's cost. Per your verbal instructions to me, ECT can't proceed with sending DPC a SL/C format until such outside counsel opinion is available. I await further instructions on how to proceed, if at all. Marc ---------------------- Forwarded by Marc De La Roche/HOU/ECT on 02/24/99 07:35 AM --------------------------- From: Vinayak S Bapat@ENRON on 02/24/99 05:43 PM To: Marc De La Roche@ECT cc: Subject: Re[2]: DPC Naphtha Hedge Marc, I am not going to my lawyers and asking an opinion for ECT's benefit at DPC's cost. If ECT wants to find 'legal status' it can hire any counsel it desires at ECT cost. Thanks & Regards, Vinayak ______________________________ Reply Separator _________________________________ Subject: Re: DPC Naphtha Hedge Author: Ram Srivastav at DPC_PO Date: 2/24/99 8:25 AM While the legal openions are coming - please continue working the rest of the issues and Dont forget that MSEB has to understand and agree to any of these arrangements. Ram ______________________________ Reply Separator _________________________________ Subject: DPC Naphtha Hedge Author: Marc De La Roche/HOU/ECT at ECT Date: 2/23/99 2:55 PM Mood Stamp: FYI --------------------------------- Importance: High --------------------------------- Vinayak, We very much look forward to being able to help DPC mitigate it's fuel price risk by implementing a derivative through ECT. ECT's counsel has advised me that the format for the Standby Letter of Credit to cover ECT's exposure on the derivatives will be sent to you/DPC as soon as you provide us with an opinion from outside (non-DPC) Indian counsel on the legality of commodity derivatives in India. Pursuant to the above, please obtain a formal opinion from outside (non-DPC) Indian counsel on the legality of commodity derivatives in India, and send it to myself at your earliest convenience. Thanking you in advance, Marc