22 Nov 2000, 11:19 UTC
Re: Enron's Response Today - Key Point to Focus On
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- To
- Susan J Mara
- Cc
- Alan Comnes, James D Steffes, Joe Hartsoe, Mary Hain, Mona L Petrochko, Paul Kaufman, Ronald Carroll, Richard Shapiro, Sarah Novosel, skean@enron.com, Karen Denne, mpalmer@enron.com
- Bcc
- Alan Comnes, James D Steffes, Joe Hartsoe, Mary Hain, Mona L Petrochko, Paul Kaufman, Ronald Carroll, Richard Shapiro, Sarah Novosel, skean@enron.com, Karen Denne, mpalmer@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 22 Nov 2000 03:19:00 -0800 (PST)
Here are IEP's comments on caps. It's from a draft circulated last Friday, but just spoke with Smutney, and he said that the comments did not change substantively . Very briefly, "IEP is generally opposed to caps, but if FERC's going to go with a soft cap, 1) there's a lot of clarification needed, 2) it needs to include "upward ratchet," a la Heber and 3) it must be linked with other reforms (i.e., forward contracting, siting, retail markets, etc.)." The comments do not explicitly address the level of the cap. They also call for a technical conference. Anything to add, Sue? ****************************************************************************** *************************************** B. Issues Concerning Implementation of the &Soft Cap.8 IEP has concerns about the implementation of the &soft cap8 proposal. IEP has not and does not support price caps because it impedes the operation of the market and distorts price signals. Such mechanisms should have no place in competitive markets in the long-run. The Staff Report notes that caps do not work. Citation; Also MSC, IEP is concerned, as are others, that the soft cap proposal will fail to attract new investments in supply or foster meaningful demand response. It is particularly problematic in terms of attracting new capacity that will operate as peaker units for a limited number of hours when weather-induced demand cannot be met from less expensive units or imports. Notwithstanding the apparent opinion of SMUD otherwise, there are demands which materialize only for a fraction of a percentage of the total hours of a year, and therefore some resources will only be dispatched a short number of hours to meet that need. These resources tend to be fast ramping, less efficient units that are not designed or intended to operate as &baseload8 facilities. Hence the suggestion that they &just operate more8 to recover their costs is misplaced. The soft cap also appears to be especially problematic to power marketers who make wholesale purchases for subsequent resale but who may not own the underlying physical generation assets. These entities have a major role in the marketplace in terms of bringing demand and supply together and they seek return on the risks they undertake. These entities will perceive the &soft cap8 as a &hard cap8 which will chill their participation in California, particularly when regional supplies become tight and expensive. This unintended consequence must be avoided or the markets will be hobbled. IEP echoes the concern articulated by the CAISO that the soft cap proposal may divert or require additional ISO resources. It will clearly compound the settlement processes at the CAISO as transactions above the soft cap will require additional tracking and segregation to allow for potential &unwinding8 should the bids be disallowed. It will also require some form of new software to provide for potential calculation of the weighted averaged prices suggested in the November Order, presumably in 10-minute increments, to blend with the market clearing prices established in the various markets. Moreover, if that averaged price associated with bids above the cap is modified often, then CAISO will be required to &re-run8 settlements or undertake subsequent settlement adjustments. It is possible that these efforts*which are suggested as temporary measures in the November Order*would take away from CAISO,s efforts at developing solutions to longer-run problems in terms of software modifications/development. At first blush the details regarding implementation of the soft cap proposal are not straightforward as currently described, and any further exploration this approach will at least require a &technical conference8 to clarify the mechanics and to ensure that it can be done in a reasonable manner. IEP could only support the soft cap proposal if it is part of a negotiated package of inter-jurisdictional programs, and provided that it is subject to an pre-established unidirectional escalation mechanism, or a similar one-way mechanism that is tied to the development of new capacity within the WSCC. The inter-jurisdictional elements must include: ? establishment of standards applicable to potential refunds based on allegations of market power abuse in FERC jurisdictional markets; ? definition of durable reasonableness review standards applicable to wholesale purchases by the load serving utilities such that they will no longer be discouraged from entering bilateral arrangements on a forward basis; ? establishment of a &road map8 by the California Commission that delineates a firm timeline*with milestones*for the review and resolution of retail market issues including market-based demand responsiveness; ? establishment of a &road map8 by this Commission, in consultation with the CAISO, that delineates a firm timeline*with milestones*for the review and resolution of implementation issues associated with the Commission,s subsequent order in this docket as well as other outstanding proposals such as generation interconnection rules and congestion management; ? establishment of firm sunset date, not to exceed 2003, to bound the duration of soft cap, and implement a unidirectional escalation mechanism, not subject to subsequent lowering, which is based either on a pre-established schedule or tied to increases in installed capacity within the WSCC. Susan J Mara 11/22/2000 10:21 AM To: James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Alan Comnes/PDX/ECT@ECT, bernadette Hawkins/Corp/Enron@Enron, Christopher F Calger/PDX/ECT@ECT, David Parquet/SF/ECT@ECT, Debra Davidson/PDX/ECT@ECT, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, gfergus@brobeck.com, Ginger Dernehl/NA/Enron@Enron, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Jeff Richter/HOU/ECT@ECT, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@Enron, Joseph Alamo/NA/Enron@Enron, Jubran Whalan/HOU/EES@EES, kcurry@bracepatt.com, lanai.wolfe@enron.com, Marcia A Linton/NA/Enron@Enron, Mary Hain/HOU/ECT@ECT, Maureen McVicker/NA/Enron@Enron, Mona L Petrochko/NA/Enron@Enron, Neil Bresnan/HOU/EES@EES, Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, rcarroll@bracepatt.com, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, Robert Badeer/HOU/ECT@ECT, Sarah Novosel/Corp/Enron@Enron, Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron, Tim Belden/HOU/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: Enron's Response Today - Key Point to Focus On I know that WPTF is supporting Hebert's approach and would suggest starting with $250 or higher with big increments every six months. WPTF is also asking for clarification on what the cap applies to. I don't recall what the comments said on refund and I haven't taken a look at the WPTF final yet. I'll let you know. I'll check on the others today. James D Steffes 11/22/2000 07:30 AM To: Alan Comnes/PDX/ECT@ECT, bernadette Hawkins/Corp/Enron@Enron, gfergus@brobeck.com, Christopher F Calger/PDX/ECT@ECT, David Parquet/SF/ECT@ECT, Debra Davidson/PDX/ECT@ECT, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, Ginger Dernehl/NA/Enron@Enron, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Jeff Richter/HOU/ECT@ECT, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@Enron, Joseph Alamo/NA/Enron@Enron, Jubran Whalan/HOU/EES@EES, kcurry@bracepatt.com, lanai.wolfe@enron.com, Marcia A Linton/NA/Enron@Enron, Mary Hain/HOU/ECT@ECT, Maureen McVicker/NA/Enron@Enron, Mona L Petrochko/NA/Enron@Enron, Neil Bresnan/HOU/EES@EES, Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, rcarroll@bracepatt.com, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, Robert Badeer/HOU/ECT@ECT, Sarah Novosel/Corp/Enron@Enron, Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@Enron, Tim Belden/HOU/ECT@ECT, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Subject: Enron's Response Today - Key Point to Focus On As I've been thinking about our response today, I would like Enron to focus on making sure that the California (WSCC) markets are as good a possible for business over the next 15 to 24 months. Following that idea, I think that the key points are (1) clarifying/raising the soft cap and (2) reducing the burden/risk of the prospective refund period. I know that we had discussed leading off with the debate over market power / retroactive refunds, but I think that (a) FERC is not inclined to do much more on this issue, (b) FERC wants to fix the market as much as it can given the current political realities, and (c) if retroactive refunds become an issue, we still have our full compliment of resources to later fight this fight. I would recommend that the pleading and Alan's testimony be modified to bring these issues to the top of the ticket. We should still include all of our other arguments. Finally, I want to make sure that Enron is taking the right position by quietly supporting a $250/Mwh soft cap with safe harbor fixes? Sue Mara, can you please try and find out what EPSA, IEPCA, and WPTF are going to file? I want to make sure that we are in the ball park on this issue but not getting too soft. Jim