25 Jun 2001, 12:56 UTC
Sunday's SF Chronicle - Direct access falls victim to crisis
- From
- Susan J Mara susan.mara@enron.com
- To
-
Alan Comnes, angela.schwarz@enron.com, beverly.aden@enron.com, bill.votaw@enron.com, brenda.barreda@enron.com, Carol Moffett, cathy.corbin@enron.com, Chris H Foster, christina.liscano@enron.com, Christopher F Calger, craig.sutter@enron.com, Dan Leff
and 109 more
debora.whitehead@enron.com, Dennis Benevides, Don Black, Douglas Huth, Edward Sacks, eric.melvin@enron.com, Erika Dupre, Evan Hughes, fran.deltoro@enron.com, gayle.muench@enron.com, Ginger Dernehl, Gordon Savage, Harold Buchanan, Harry Kingerski, James D Steffes, James W Lewis, james.wright@enron.com, jeff.messina@enron.com, Jeremy Blachman, Jess Hewitt, Joe Hartsoe, Karen Denne, Kathy Bass, Kathy Dodgen, Ken Gustafson, kevin.hughes@enron.com, Leasa Lopez, Leticia Botello, Mark S Muller, marsha.suggs@enron.com, Marty Sunde, Meredith M Eggleston, Michael Etringer, Michael Mann, Michelle D Cisneros, mpalmer@enron.com, Neil Bresnan, Neil Hong, Paul Kaufman, Richard L Zdunkewicz, Richard Leibert, Richard Shapiro, Rita Hennessy, Robert Badeer, Rosalinda Tijerina, Sandra McCubbin, Sarah Novosel, Scott Gahn, Scott Stoness, Sharon Dick, skean@enron.com, Susan J Mara, tanya.leslie@enron.com, Tasha Lair, Ted Murphy, Terri Greenlee, Tim Belden, tony.spruiell@enron.com, Vicki Sharp, Vladimir Gorny, Wanda Curry, William S Bradford, Jubran Whalan, triley@enron.com, Richard B Sanders, Robert C Williams, Jeffrey Watkiss, Ronald Carroll, Donna Fulton, Gary S. Fergus, Bruno Gaillard, Linda Robertson, Lazure Ren, lazure@enron.com, Michael Tribolet, Phillip K Allen, Christian Yoder, JOHN G KLAUBERG, Tamara Johnson, Greg Wolfe, Jeff Dasovich, Dirk vanUlden, steve.walker@enron.com, Mike D Smith, Leslie Lawner, Robert Neustaedter, Steve Walton, psmith3@enron.com, mjackso7@enron.com, Janel Guerrero, Mark Fillinger, Jennifer Rudolph, martin.wenzel@enron.com, wgang@enron.com, Joseph Alamo, Tracy Ngo, Ray Alvarez, Steve C Hall, jay.zoellner@enron.com, Fatimata Liamidi, Sonia Perez, Chris Holmes, venkatesh.mani@enron.com, Richard Crevelt, Dave Perrino, malcolm.adkins@enron.com, Kevin Keeney, Chris Stokley, Minal Dalia - Date
- Mon, 25 Jun 2001 05:56:00 -0700 (PDT)
Sue Mara Enron Corp. Tel: (415) 782-7802 Fax:(415) 782-7854
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Susan J Mara/NA/Enron on 06/25/2001 12:55 PM ----- "Beiser, Megan" <Megan.Beiser@edelman.com> 06/25/2001 12:26 PM To: "Allen, Stevan" <stevan.allen@edelman.com>, arm@phaser.com, Bob_Anderson@apses.com, "brbarkovich@earthlink.net" <bbarkovich@earthlink.net>, cra@calretailers.com, dennis.flatt@kp.org, dhunter@s-k-w.com, djsmith@s-k-w.com, Dominic.DiMare@calchamber.com, drothrock@cmta.net, "Fairchild, Tracy" <tracy.fairchild@edelman.com>, gdoar@newpower.com, gharrison@calstate.edu, hgovenar@govadv.com, jackson_gualco@gualcogroup.com, "jerryl@abag.ca.gov" <jerryl@abag.ca>, .gov@mailman.enron.com, johnlatimer@capitoladvocacy.com, ken_pietrelli@ocli.com, kgough@calpine.com, kmccrea@sablaw.com, kmills@cfbf.com, lhastings@cagrocers.com, "Manuel, Erica" <Erica.Manuel@edelman.com>, mday@gmssr.com, mmoretti@calhealth.org, nplotkin@tfglobby.com, randy_britt@robinsonsmay.com, richard.seguin@kp.org, RochmanM@spurr.org, rrichter@calhealth.org, sgovenar@govadv.com, smccubbi@enron.com, spahnn@hnks.com, sschleimer@calpine.com, theo@ppallc.com, vincent.stewart@ucop.edu, vjw@ceert.org, "Warner, Jami" <jami.warner@edelman.com>, wbooth@booth-law.com, wbrown@lhom.com, wlarson@calstate.edu cc: Subject: Sunday's SF Chronicle - Direct access falls victim to crisis > Greg Lucas' long-awaited Chronicle story about DA ran this weekend ... > > ENERGY CRUNCH > Direct access falls victim to crisis > Power-buying plan's future is in doubt > Bernadette Tansey, Greg Lucas, Chronicle Staff Writers > Sunday, June 24, 2001 > ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle > > URL: > http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/06/24/MNL67535.DTL > > > The option to shop around for the best deal on electricity -- one of the > cornerstones of California's deregulation plan -- could soon be scrapped. > > Businesses may lose the right to cut their own deals with private power > suppliers, and environmentally conscious consumers could be barred from > shifting their business from utilities to renewable energy firms, unless > the Legislature acts quickly to save the program. > > The potential cost savings of so-called direct access to competing > electricity providers was the plum that incited big businesses to fight > hard for deregulation in 1996. But the program -- although it was not > responsible for the soaring rates that piled up state and utility debt -- > may be sacrificed in the state's drive to recoup its costs. > > The fate of the program was thrown into doubt last winter, when > skyrocketing wholesale electricity costs collapsed the nascent direct > access market, weakened the utilities and caused the state to take over > power purchases. > > Industry has been lobbying hard since then to keep the option open for the > future. But the problem for Gov. Gray Davis' administration is that the > state needs big industrial consumers to stay on as utility customers to > help pay off the $8 billion it has already spent buying power and the > estimated $43 billion worth of power it has contracted to buy over the > next 20 years. > > Otherwise, the utility customers left behind -- householders and small > businesses -- will be stuck with the whole bill. > > Competing proposals to allow companies to bail out by paying an "exit fee" > to cover a share of the cost are working their way through the > Legislature. > > But time is running short, state Treasurer Philip Angelides warned the > Legislature and the state Public Utilities Commission this month. > > The state plans to issue $12.5 billion in bonds in September for power > purchases, and officials say underwriters want to be assured that there is > a large enough revenue stream to repay the bonds. > > Angelides and other state officials urged the Legislature and the PUC to > decide by the end of June either to ban direct access or lock in a > procedure to charge each departing company for its share of the state > power costs. > > "The hypothetical and theoretical desires for a direct access market and > the hypothetical and theoretical desire for a bond sale are now > intersecting in reality," said Assemblyman Fred Keeley, D-Boulder Creek > (Santa Cruz County). > > Industry advocates agree that firms should pay a fair share of the > electricity purchased on their behalf. But how much -- and how to make > that calculation -- is a complex issue they fear will be decided in haste, > said Dorothy Rothrock, a lobbyist for the California Manufacturers and > Technology Association. > > "We are reacting to crises, real or man-made, and making decisions in a > rush without considering the consequences," Rothrock said. > > The PUC is set to vote Thursday on a proposed urgency measure to suspend > direct access as of July 1. The ban recommended by a PUC administrative > law judge would continue as long as the state functions as power buyer for > utility customers -- conceivably through the term of state contracts > ending in 2020. > > Lawmakers had authorized the PUC to suspend direct access last winter when > the state took over electricity purchasing. But a divided PUC delayed > action as legislators worked with industry to salvage the program. > > Although direct access contracts are still legal until the PUC acts, in > effect the program was slammed into suspension by the brutal power price > hikes of the past 18 months. Threatened by exposure to rising wholesale > electricity rates, virtually all direct access customers have returned to > the utilities, where they are protected by the state rate freeze. > > Even though the right to deal directly with generators has been on the > books since 1996, few businesses or householders actually did it. > > Many of the residential customers who signed on with alternative suppliers > did so to support the growth of renewable power like solar and wind > energy. At its peak, the program drew about 224,000 households -- about > 2.5 percent of the customer base of California's major utilities. About 13 > percent of the industrial market contracted for their own power. > > Industry has until tomorrow to file plans with the PUC to preserve direct > access under a proposal by public utilities Commissioner Richard Bilas, a > strong supporter of the program. > > Commissioner Jeff Brown said he favors direct access, but the continuing > uncertainty over the form it would take jeopardizes the state's ability to > float its bonds. > > Commissioner Carl Wood, a direct access opponent, said it should be > abolished, because it creates a danger that residential and small business > customers will be stuck paying for relatively high-cost contracts secured > by the state during the energy crisis, while large industries would be > free to buy cheap power from the newer, more efficient plants that will be > coming online in the next few years. > > But Wood said even if the PUC suspends the option, the state Legislature > could order its reinstatement. > > Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Marina del Rey, is carrying a bill to do that while > requiring the exit fees demanded by Angelides and state finance officials. > > > Without those safeguards, utility revenues would dive into a "death > spiral, " where rates would keep rising as more companies abandoned the > system, Bowen said, giving the remaining customers a deeper incentive to > bail. > > State legislators are set to meet this week to start deciding how > California's electricity market should be structured in the future. But > deadlines to deal with the state's financial hangover are pushing > decisions on direct access. > > Bowen said it's unlikely her bill will be passed within a few weeks, the > time frame Davis administration officials have urged to give certainty to > the terms of the bond deal. > > Angelides said the Legislature could still pass a law reviving direct > access before the bond language is written in July. But after that, the > Legislature cannot pass laws that change the terms of contract commitments > made by the state, he said. > > "There is still a window to act here, but they have to act fast," > Angelides said. > > E-mail Bernadette Tansey at btansey@sfchronicle.com and Greg Lucas at > glucas@sfchronicle.com. > > ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle Page A - 21 >