2 Nov 2000, 18:16 UTC
Strategy for California
- From
- Mona.L.Petrochko@enron.com mona.l.petrochko@enron.com
- To
- Roger Yang, dbenevid@enron.com, Tim Belden, Robert Badeer, Michael McDonald, Laird Dyer, David Parquet, dcondon@enron.com, martin.wenzel@enron.com, christopher.f.calger@enron.com, Greg Cordell, sgahn@enron.com
- Cc
- Mara, Susan" @ENRON, enron.com@enron.com, Sandra McCubbin, Joseph Alamo, Marcie Milner, Paul Kaufman, Lysa Akin, Mary Hain, Alan Comnes, james.d.steffes@enron.com, Harry Kingerski, Richard Shapiro
- Bcc
- Mara, Susan" @ENRON, enron.com@enron.com, Sandra McCubbin, Joseph Alamo, Marcie Milner, Paul Kaufman, Lysa Akin, Mary Hain, Alan Comnes, james.d.steffes@enron.com, Harry Kingerski, Richard Shapiro
- Date
- Thu, 2 Nov 2000 10:16:00 -0800 (PST)
Based on the recent activities both at FERC (draft order) and at the CPUC (undercollections/investigations), attached is a draft strategy to develop a concensus position with as many parties as possible going into the next legislative session, which begins in January 2001. There are rumors that the Governor may call for a special session, which would expedite the treatment of energy issues. Please provide any comments/concerns on this approach asap. Because of the undercollections the utilities that accumulated by virtue of the rate cap for SCE and PG&E and the high summer prices, there is a strong move by the utilities to end the rate freeze as expeditiously as possible. However, ending the rate freeze early has serious implications for EES's book of business in addition to the potential to expose consumers to rate shock, a la San Diego, if the rate cap is removed prior to next summer. In conversations with various organizations (WPTF, ARM, IEP, TURN), and internally (Roger Yang), there may be fertile ground for negotiating a settlement that could be supported by the aforementioned organizations, provide utility some hope of recovery of their undercollected costs, continue stabilized rates for small consumers through forward contracting, providing opportunities for ENA, and defining the utilities role as serving only residential and small commercial customers, creating marketing opportunities for larger customers and marketers. The components of a settlement would need to address: 1. Rate Freeze Duration/Value of Hydro 2. Undercollection Treatment 3. Utility Procurement and Pricing/Default Provider The proposal would be as follows: 1. Maintain existing rate freeze through transition period (either 12/31/01 or 3/31/02). a. This gives the utilities a reasonable opportunity to mitigate undercollection in TRA through valuation of hydro, and generation revenues from the hydro and nuclear facilities. It also gives the utility time to structure its portfolio for serving its default customers-forward contract. b. Maintains rate stability for consumers through tight summer supply periods. c. Continues CPUC deliberative valuation of remaining generation assets, including hydro. CPUC recently ordered that supplemental testimony could be filed on December 5 to adjust values to reflect recent market events. We think that the rate freeze cannot end without a valuation of the assets, which is required by December 31, 2001. This could be a very significant mitigation piece. 2. Provide an Equitable Outcome of the Undercollected Balance a. While the UDCs believe they can retro-actively effect an end to the rate freeze, and receive full recovery of any uncollected power purchase costs, TURN has filed saying that these power purchase costs should be treated as a transition cost and the utilities should be given the opportunity to recover those costs during the transition period with the same risk exposure they have always had. Anything still in the account as of 12/31/01 is shareholder risk. b. There may be a nice middle ground here. I think there are some legal issues with TURN's proposal about treating current unrecovered electricity costs as "stranded" costs. However, there is merit to say, let's get to the end of the transition period and net the overcollections in the transition cost balancing account (TCBA) against the undercollected transition revenue account (TRA). Both SCE and PG&E have been recording revenues from hydo, nukes, PPAs and QFs. These revenues, in addition to the remaining asset valuations, will provide a substantial offset to the undercollected revenue balance. c. In addition, there may be additional merit to some sharing of any remaining undercollected balance, after netting the two accounts, between ratepayers and shareholders. An argument can be made that the utilities were over-exposed to the market volatility due to the lack of forward contracting. (Others may say that the utilities should be responsible for the run-up in gas prices and ERCs and that ratepayers be responsible for the balance. Another way, may be to look at allowing recovery of "above-cost" prices for period from June 14-Oct 2. This presumes that the Commission will not try to pursue disgorging profits from marketers/generators.) This amount could be amortized over a several year period (3-5 years) beginning 2002. While the sharing may not be critical to Enron, it will be a big negotiating point between ratepayer advocates and the utilities. 3. Clearer definition of utilities' procurement role a. Define utility's roles as procurer for residential and small commercial customers at a levelized price for fixed period of time (3-5 years). This provides clarity to the utility on for whom they should contract. It will also alleviate claims about future stranded costs when/if default role changes. b. Allow procurement flexibility on meeting that responsibility. Reasonableness will be an issue. Need to determine if we want to propose anything or nothing. c. Provide only POLR service to industrial customers (flow through of a spot market price plus retail adders). d. At the end of the default transition period, begin the process of alternative default providers. 4. Regulatory Process |----------+------------+-----------+-----------+-------------| | Hydro | OII Markets| PG&E/SCE | OII | QF | | | Whole/Retai| Emergency | Broader | Restructurin| | | l | Motions | | g | |----------+------------+-----------+-----------+-------------| | Test. | Subpoenas | Comments | Open 12/21| Ongoing | | 12/5 | | 11/9;Reply| | | | | | 11/17 | | | |----------+------------+-----------+-----------+-------------| | | | Likely to | Deal with | Deal w/ | | | | adopt TURN| ending | clipping | | | | accounting| rate | capacity | | | | proposal | freeze; | payments in | | | | | increasing| SRAC to PX | | | | | frozen | price | | | | | rates, | | | | | | etc. | | |----------+------------+-----------+-----------+-------------| | Final | ? | Decision | Unknown, | | | Dec. 3Q01| | by 12/21 | possibly | | | | | | 2-3Q01 | | |----------+------------+-----------+-----------+-------------|