7 Nov 2001, 16:04 UTC
FW: Generator based sourcing standards
- From
- Stacey Bolton stacey.bolton@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 7 Nov 2001 08:04:36 -0800 (PST)
We're coming down to the final wire on the Green-eT-RECs standard. Below is a synopsis of the outstanding issues. I wanted to get your thought about the following the options. I agree with staff that choice #1 is ideal. My second choice is #3. The issue is this: Each of the regions has slightly different to dramatically different definitions for eligible resources for a Green-e certified electricity product. In order to have a national standard whereby a marketer can market the same product across the states, staff has proposed certifying generators per region. These generators would be certified according to that region's standard. The T-RECS could then be marketed anywhere. Some folks want to control not only the generators that are certified, but the products that are sold in their region. Thus the option for the highest common denominator (choice #2). I think we need to go with the most administratively simple method that will promote the most liquidity. Certifying generator or creating a separate T-RECs standard seem to be the easiest. Let me know your thoughts. I'd like to get back with Meredith today. Also, these issues are pretty nebulous -- so call if you have ?s. Stacey Bolton Environmental Strategies Enron Corp 713-853-9916 direct 713-303-2632 cell stacey.bolton@enron.com <mailto:stacey.bolton@enron.com>
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: "Meredith Wingate" <mwingate@resource-solutions.org>@ENRON Sent: Tuesday, November 06, 2001 4:34 PM To: Anne Marie McShea; Barbara Atkinson \(LBNL\); Brenna Herpmann; Brent Beerley; Jeff Schmidt; Kevin Porter; Liz Robinson; Maureen Mulligan; Mark Crowdis; Matt Deluca; Peter Adels; Rich Travaglini; Roger Clark; Sam Swanson; Serpil Guran; Stacey Bolton; Maryanne Daniel Cc: Dan Lieberman; Andrew Altman; Kirk Brown Subject: Generator based sourcing standards Folks, As you know, at our last meeting, I promised to circulate the different options we discussed on generator -based sourcing standards. The problem we are trying to solve is this: We'd like to develop a national definition for "eligible" renewables for certification of T-RECs products under Green-e. The problem is that if we did a highest common denominator standard, some renewables, namely biomass would be excluded. We feel that this would be a somewhat arbitrary exclusion because biomass has been excluded from some regional standards because of specific regional circumstances and that it would not be fair to penalize the entire biomass industry by eliminating it from the T-RECs - Green-e market. So staff have proposed a generator based sourcing standard. Eligibility would thus apply to renewable generators, not marketers. So if a generator qualified, they would-be able to market their T-RECs anywhere in the US. The general feedback I got from you was that people didn't like this idea because (1) it wasn't clear for the consumer what types of eligible are allowed under Green-e cert. (e.g. Georgia biomass excluded, but PA biomass allowed) and (2) effectively gave marketers the ability to sell a type of power into a market that might not meet the regional definition of eligible, (e.g. you could sell forestry-derived biomass generated in New England into the PA market - the generator would meet the new England definition for eligible and therefore would be able to sell that power anywhere.) We discussed a couple of different options for handling this dilemma. Here are a few of the major pros an cons. 1. Adopt a single generator-based sourcing standard for electricity and T-RECs (this was the proposal by staff) pros: it is consistent b/t electricity and T-RECs products, and it allows for regional definitions of eligibility; cons: not clear for the consumer what types of eligible are allowed under Green-e cert.; effectively gives marketers the ability to sell a type of power into a market that might not meet the regional definition of eligible 2. Don't change electricity standards (keep definition of "eligible" renewable as regional product standard) but have a T-RECs standard that is based on the highest common denominator of all regional Green-e/Green pricing standards. A highest common denominator standard would include solar, wind, digester gas, and possibly LIHI hydro, geothermal landfill methane with some NOx limits. I say "possibly" because these things aren't included in green pricing eligibility criteria but we think we might be able to convince stakeholders there to accept them. Pros: Meets both regional definitions for what is generated in a state and what is marketed in a state Cons: inconsistent standard b/t electricity products and T-RECs products; eliminates biomass and possibly other renewables from eligibility for T-RECs 3. Don't change electricity standard but develop a new national definition for what T-RECs are "eligible" (this would not necessarily be a highest common denominator standard, but more of a "generally accepted renewable" standard) Pros: Doesn't change electricity standard; makes it clear for consumers what's in a Green-e certified product Cons: potentially inconsistent standard b/t electricity products and T-RECs products; could undermine regional standards if something is approved as eligible for T-RECs but it is not eligible for electricity. 4. keep product standard for both electricity and for T-RECs; require both electricity providers and T-RECs providers to meet the regional definitions. Pros: Meets both regional definitions for what is generated in a state and what is marketed in a state Cons: requires T-RECs marketers to market different products for different regions- could prevent them from seeking certification; inconsistent standard b/t electricity products and T-RECs products Please send me your feedback on these different options. We did have an option 5, but upon reflection, it appeared to me to be the same as one of the other options. if this isn't enough selection for you, feel free to add you own option too! Thanks, Meredith Meredith Wingate Center for Resource Solutions Presidio Building 49 PO Box 29512 San Francisco, CA 94134 415-561-2100 _________________________ Information about CRS programs is available at www.resource-solutions.org Curious about Green-e and green power? Check out www.green-e.org