6 Apr 2001, 12:15 UTC
Future Looks Dark for New York Market; NYSEG Outlines Energy Policy
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Fri, 6 Apr 2001 05:15:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] Southeastern Electric Exchange 2001 Utility Odyssey: Engineering & Operation/Accounting, Customer Billing and Finance Conference and Trade Show The Doral Resort Miami, FL Featured speakers include Wall Street Analysts Ed Tirello and Dan Ford and SEE Company Utility Executives Donald Hintz, Entergy Corp., Dennis Wraase, Pepco, and Bill Coley, Duke Power For full details: www.theexchange.org In an exclusive SCIENTECH PowerHitters Interview, Cody Graves, CEO of Automated Energy, Inc. and former Chairman of the Oklahoma Corporation Commission, discusses the status of restructuring in Oklahoma and nationwide. Graves also discusses the role Automated Energy is playing in providing an essential piece of the restructuring pie. See the questions Graves was asked at: www.ConsultRCI.com [IMAGE] The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power System by RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. The Wall Map measures 42" x 72"; the Executive Map Set consists of 18 11" x 17" maps. Visit our website at www.ConsultRCI.com for a detailed description of these valuable maps and complete ordering instructions. [IMAGE] IssueAlert for April 6, 2001 Future Looks Dark for New York Market; NYSEG Outlines Energy Policy by Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [News item from Reuters] New York State Electric & Gas Corp. (NYSEG), one of New York's seven utilities, said the state will not have enough megawatts to support a truly competitive wholesale electric market until 2008. NYSEG, in a report issued late Wednesday, warned there are "serious problems with (New York's) generation supply and a lack of transmission and pipeline infrastructure." The report challenges a market appraisal by the New York Independent System Operator (NYISO), which has run the state's wholesale power market since 1999. The NYSEG report, titled ``New York State's Electric Energy Crisis and NYSEG's Comprehensive Solution,'' criticizes the NYISO for not giving power consumers "price certainty" in the transition from local monopolies to an open, competitive market. Analysis: New York can now officially be added to the list of troubled energy markets, as market projections and fundamental structural problems spell out an alarming prognosis for the state as it heads into the summer season. However, unlike California, which basically faces a power supply problem that can be improved over time, New York arguably suffers from a more severe and permanent set of conditions that cannot be easily resolved. Like its West Coast counterpart, New York also suffers from a supply / demand imbalance and local resistance that thwarts new generation development. However, even if or when power supply can be increased in New York, the core load center of New York City still suffers from inherent transmission deficiencies that continue to take their own toll on the stability of the market. Various stakeholders in the New York market have now begun to place blame on each other in advance of what could shape up to be a very problematic summer. As noted, in its new report, NYSEG, a subsidiary of Energy East (NYSE: EAS), is especially critical of NYISO, which it says has contributed to soaring wholesale prices in New York. NYSEG also blames NYISO for outlining unrealistic goals for new power supply, not providing accurate price signals to energy customers, and for not doing enough to solve immediate problems. Yet, beyond the finger pointing, some essential facts can be established, on which both NYSEG and the NYISO apparently agree. According to data included in the NYISO report, between 1995 and 2000, while statewide demand in New York rose by 2,700 MW, generating capacity under contract in the state increased only by 1,060 MW. New York has not brought a new plant online since 1996, when a 200-MW plant opened in Brooklyn. It has been almost seven years since a 1,000 MW unit in Oswego, N.Y. marked the last plant to open upstate. In addition, New York suffers from severe transmission bottlenecks. Deficient transmission systems in central New York, around New York City and at the outlining borders to other states and Canada limit the amount of power than can be imported into the state. New York City is relatively isolated from the transmission grids that serve the rest of the state and must rely heavily on city-based power supply. New York City's load should reach 10,535 MW this summer alone, requiring 8,428 MW of in-city capacity, along with imports, to meet demand and provide a reserve margin. With a current capacity of 8,132 MW, there is a potential 296 MW shortfall. These projections presume normal weather conditions. If New York experiences a warmer-than-normal summer, the outlook gets even worse. Further, according to a report from New York's State Attorney General, between 1988 and 1998 capital improvements to New York's transmission system dropped from $307.7 million per year to $90 million per year. At the present time, only one major addition to the transmission system in the state is scheduled. A proposed underwater line linking Long Island to Connecticut would provide Long Island with about 300 MW of additional power and increase its import capacity by about 4 percent. Unless this transmission expansion is expedited, it is not scheduled for operation until 2002. Consequently, given all of these factors, power supplies in New York most certainly will be strained this summer when warmer temperatures drive up the use of air conditioners, pushing demand to annual highs. While NYSEG and the NYISO may agree on the nature of New York's problems, a contentious debate has emerged with regard to finding a solution. In its own proposal, released in early March, the NYISO focused on building new generation, expediting siting processes, improving transmission lines, and conservation efforts. In one of its key proposals, the NYISO urged the creation of 8,600 MW of new electricity (roughly 30 percent of New York's peak demand) by 2005, with up to 5,000 MW of that generation being made available by the end of 2001. NYSEG immediately denounced the plan for "falling short in its assessment of the magnitude of the crisis" and issued its own proposals in its recent report. For instance, NYSEG officials said that NYISO had "grossly oversimplified the situation" and that, considering the tenuous state of power construction in New York, the objective of establishing 8,600 MW by 2005 was "extremely unrealistic." In turn, NYSEG says that a robust wholesale electric market will not materialize in New York until 2008, assuming that measures to repair the problems in the state are taken immediately. In early March, NYSEG released the "NYSEGPlan," outlining six steps which it believes "contain the real solutions to ensure a successful transition" to a competitive market in New York. In summary, the NYSEGPlan includes: Streamlining the siting and approval process to build new generating plants. Adding to the state's transmission capacity. Adding to the state's natural-gas supply infrastructure. Creating a regional transmission organization to increase supply liquidity. Reinforcing the need for wise energy use by all consumers, by encouraging interruptible load where feasible, and building the technological infrastructure necessary for real-time pricing. Approving the NYSEG Price Protection Plan, in which electric rates would be frozen for seven years, by July 1, 2001. However, while NYSEG criticized NYISO for espousing unrealistic goals, the same obstacles inherent in New York's market might also thwart its own energy plan. For instance, topping the list of NYSEG's six steps is an emphasis on establishing new generation in New York through a streamlined siting and approval process. This may be easier said than done. As I mentioned in my 3/22/01IssueAlert, the opposition to new power plants in New York equals the lobbying force that community groups in California wield. In that column, I discussed the fact that Sithe Energies has downscaled a proposed plant in Ramapo, N.Y. (from an 827-MW combined-cycle facility to a 510-MW peaking unit) due to opposition raised by local residents. In addition, just yesterday, a New York Supreme Court judged blocked efforts by the New York Power Authority (NYPA) to build two 44-MW gas-fired generators in the borough of Queens. The Supreme Court judge order NYPA to "cease all construction on the units" and ruled that the power authority violated state environmental-review laws to its efforts to rush the plant into service by June. In response, NYPA has said that the plants*along with nine others that it is hoping to build throughout New York City*are needed to prevent power outages this summer. NYPA continues to face fierce opposition from community groups (many of them launching lawsuits) who do not want the generation units in their neighborhoods. Consequently, the supply / demand imbalance in New York is a very serious matter, and one that residents in the state may not fully appreciate unless blackouts occur. Until the core problem of insufficient transmission lines surrounding New York State and New York City are solved, adding new power supply (assuming that generation development can move past community opposition) would not be enough to bring more balance to the market. In the interim, conservation efforts may truly be the only tool that New Yorkers can user to abate power outages this summer, but again the general public may not fully understand the need to reduce their power usage. New York basically has three options at this point to prepare for near-term problems. First, expedite the building of new generation sources (including distribution generation alternatives). This assumes that gas lines will be sufficient to import necessary fuel. Second, allow the economy of New York City to stagnate as a result of the supply / demand imbalance, which will drive residents out of the city and in turn reduce demand. And, third, focus on conservation efforts, which again may not work until residents are directly impacted by outages. The city may choose a combination of all three approaches or decide to focus on just one. However, to address the immediate concerns, it does not appear that New York has any options besides this three-tier approach. One point that bears mentioning is the similarity between California and New York regarding the position that both states took on divestiture. Although it is not completely accurate to say that either state officially mandated divestiture, utilities in both California and New York felt intense pressure to divest and submitted restructuring plans that included the sale of most of their power plants. NYSEG, the author of the new report on New York's power problems, is one utility that sold all of its generation assets and will remain only in the transmission business. This most likely creates a heightened sensitivity on NYSEG's part with regard to the power supply shortages presently facing New York. Again, we now have two states that represent the array of problems that can result when the vertical utility model becomes dismantled. Of course, it is not fair to say that divestiture is the sole source of the current problems in California and New York, but taking away a utility's ability to effectively control is own power supply costs certainly contributed to the vulnerability in both states. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.ConsultRCI.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.