22 Feb 2001, 08:17 UTC
California
- From
- Ginger Dernehl ginger.dernehl@enron.com
- To
-
assad@elektro.com.br, Alan Comnes, Alberto Levy, Aleck Dadson, Allison Navin, Amy Fabian, Barbara A Hueter, Bernadette Hawkins, Bill Moore, cristinah@elektro.com.br, Carlos Gustavo Azevedo, Carmen Perez
and 95 more
Carolyn Cooney, Charles Yeung, Chauncey Hood, Chris Long, Christi L Nicolay, Dan Staines, Daniel Allegretti, Dave Mangskau, Donald Lassere, Donna Fulton, eidy.catala@enron.com, Elizabeth Linnell, Eric Benson, Frank Rishe, Geriann Warner, germain.palmer@enron.com, Ginger Dernehl, gisele.braz@enron.com, Gloria Ogenyi, Guillermo Canovas, Harry Kingerski, Howard Fromer, jpr@ceibo.entelnet.bo, James D Steffes, Janel Guerrero, Janine Migden, javier.pantoja@enron.com, Jean Dressler, Jean Ryall, Jeff Brown, Jeff Dasovich, Jeffrey Keeler, joao.paixao@enron.com, joe.allen@enron.com, Joe Connor, Joe Hartsoe, Joe Hillings, Jose Bestard, Joseph Alamo, Kathleen Sullivan, Kerry Stroup, Kikumi Kishigami, Kirsten Bellas, Lara Leibman, Laurie Knight, Leslie Lawner, Linda J Noske, Linda Robertson, lindsay.meade@enron.com, Lisa Yoho, Lora Sullivan, Luiz Maurer, Lysa Akin, Marchris Robinson, Marcia A Linton, Mary Hain, Maureen McVicker, Melinda Pharms, mike.roan@enron.com, Mona L Petrochko, Nancy Hetrick, Patrick Keene, Paul Kaufman, Ray Alvarez, Rebecca W Cantrell, Ricardo Charvel, Richard Ingersoll, Richard Shapiro, Robert Frank, Robert Hemstock, Robert Neustaedter, Robin Kittel, Ron McNamara, Roy Boston, Rubena Buerger, Sandra McCubbin, Sarah Novosel, Scott Bolton, Sergio Assad, Stella Chan, Stephen D Burns, Steve Montovano, Steve Walton, Steven J Kean, Sue Nord, Susan J Mara, Susan M Landwehr, Terri Miller, Thane Twiggs, Tom Briggs, Tom Chapman, Tom Hoatson, valeria.lima@enron.com, Vinio Floris, Xi Xi - Date
- Thu, 22 Feb 2001 00:17:00 -0800 (PST)
Richard Shapiro 02/21/2001 04:51 PM To: Ginger Dernehl/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Subject: California Please forward to entire group- these are recent talking points re: California.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron on 02/21/2001 04:50 PM --------------------------- From: Jeff Dasovich on 02/21/2001 01:31 AM Sent by: Jeff Dasovich To: Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, skean@enron.com, Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@ENRON, Sandra McCubbin/NA/Enron@Enron, Harry Kingerski/NA/Enron@Enron, Leslie Lawner/NA/Enron@Enron, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, mpalmer@enron.com, Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Linda Robertson/NA/Enron@ENRON, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@ENRON cc: Subject: DRAFT Message Points for Hertzberg Conversationq Here are some draft message points. Please review. Apologies in advance is they're a little rough, but these guys are getting bothersome at this point. Best, Jeff Recent legislative proposals designed to 1) give the State the role of developing, owning and operating power plants in California (SB6X--Burton) and 2) buy PG&E and Edison's electric transmission assets (SB33X--Burton) are taking California in the wrong direction and won't solve the State's electricity crisis. Two other recently introduced new bills are equally disturbing and counter-productive: AB60X (Hertzerg) would make plant certification contingent upon the developer agreeing to sell the power to the state at "just and reasonable, cost based rates." SB39X (Spier) would classify power plant as public utilities and would dictate plant operations to a very significant degree. The proposals are significantly outside the mainstream and offer a political, as opposed to an economic, commercial, financial, or technical solution. Around the rest of the world, governments are privatizing these industries, relying on efficient capital markets to provide both the infrastructure and the products and services that derive from that infrastructure. Astonishingly, California is moving in the opposite direction, toward a state-owned and operated, centrally-planned industry. The notion that a state takeover of the industry is the only choice that California has left is false, will lead to a seriously flawed economic policy, and will result in consumers paying higher prices for lower quality services for years to come. As a political solution, these bills will not increase supply, decrease demand, or get the utilities back on their financial feet. In fact, they are likely to do just the opposite: They will result in a significant expansion of the state bureaucracy and create additional burdens on the state budget. The transmission buyout contemplated in SB33X is extremely complex, requiring buy-in from state and federal authorities, bondholders, creditors and others. California will be forced to spend an enormous amount of time and resources trying to achieve the deal, with no certainty of success, particularly in view of PG&E's public opposition. There is no evidence that the State has any expertise in overseeing a TX system as large and complex as the ones possessed by PG&E and Edison, even if it did manage to complete the transaction. Nor have any estimates been made regarding how much additional capital California will be required to invest in what is generally viewed as a transmission network in desperate need of repair and upgrading. In the meantime, summer approaches, and the gap between supply and demand remains staggering. This complex, costly and litigious alternative will in no way reduce the serious threat of blackouts that California faces this summer. When those blackouts arrive*and they will unless bold action is taken swiftly* consumer will wonder why policy makers spent their time negotiating the price of utility transmission assets. As important, it is extremely difficult to see how the transmission buy-out offers creditors a better alternative to bankruptcy court. Indeed, when viewed against the uncertainty of achieving the transmission buy-out, particularly in light of the politically charged atmosphere in which the debate is taking place, creditors seem increasingly inclined to opt for the relative certainty that comes with a bankruptcy court. If that happens, the State loses a significant amount of influence over the situation. Moreover, SB6X squarely inserts the State into the power plant business, despite the face that there is abundant private capital ready and willing to invest in California*IF California provides the investment environment to attract that capital. Unfortunately, these bills create an environment that is hostile toward investment capital. Distressingly, the state could finance, develop, own and/or operate power plants, at the same time that it controls the monopoly transmission system. In addition, any company that uses the newly-created &Power Authority,s8 financing authority would have the price that it can charge for power set by the &Authority,8 or, if the developer is a utility, by the California PUC. In sum, the biggest player in the power business*the State*will control the network that power suppliers must use to get their power to market. The state will control the price to use the network, and in many cases it will also control the prices power suppliers charge for power services. This scenario makes the old vertically-integrated monopoly structure look inviting. Capital markets will run from this &solution8 and put capital to more productive uses outside of California. Under this proposed &solution8 only IOUs and municipal utilities will build plants, and the state will be forced to finance them. That,s the same recipe for inefficiency and waste that got California to electricity prices that were 50% higher than the national average. We,ve been down that route; it,s been given chance after chance to succeed, and it,s failed. State-ownership and intrusive regulation haven,t worked in the past, and they won,t work today. This package of bills will increase the risk of blackouts this summer; increase the time it takes to close the gap between supply and demand in California; increase the likelihood of bankruptcy; and force businesses to look elsewhere to locate and/or expand operations, all of which put California,s economy at risk. The real solution is to succeed in doing what California failed to do the first time*lay the groundwork for truly competitive retail and wholesale markets and foster an environment designed to foster investment, invest, rather than chase it away. ---------------------- Forwarded by Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron on 02/21/2001 04:50 PM --------------------------- Susan J Mara 02/21/2001 04:22 PM To: Mark Palmer/Corp/Enron@ENRON cc: Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Sandra McCubbin/NA/Enron@Enron, Harry Kingerski/NA/Enron@Enron, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron Subject: Message Points Mark, I have passed the following message points out to some colleagues to help them respond to reporters calls. I put it together by smushing together jeff's and my points. It addresses all four bills of concern. Sue Mara Enron Corp. Tel: (415) 782-7802 Fax:(415) 782-7854