9 Jul 2001, 15:42 UTC
POWER POINTS:Nevada Suffers FERC Unintended Consequences
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 9 Jul 2001 08:42:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron on 07/09/2001 03:42 PM ----- Jennifer Rudolph@EES 07/09/2001 03:28 PM To: CA Team cc: Subject: POWER POINTS:Nevada Suffers FERC Unintended Consequences ---------------------- Forwarded by Jennifer Rudolph/HOU/EES on 07/09/2001 03:27 PM --------------------------- From: Alan Comnes/ENRON@enronXgate on 07/06/2001 06:33 PM To: Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Angela Schwarz/HOU/EES@EES, Beverly Aden/HOU/EES@EES, Bill Votaw/HOU/EES@EES, Brenda Barreda/HOU/EES@EES, Carol Moffett/HOU/EES@EES, Cathy Corbin/HOU/EES@EES, Chris H Foster/ENRON@enronXgate, Christina Liscano/HOU/EES@EES, Craig H Sutter/HOU/EES@EES, Dan Leff/HOU/EES@EES, Debora Whitehead/HOU/EES@EES, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, Don Black/HOU/EES@EES, Dorothy Youngblood/HOU/ECT@ECT, Douglas Huth/HOU/EES@EES, Edward Sacks/ENRON@enronXgate, Eric Melvin/HOU/EES@EES, Erika Dupre/HOU/EES@EES, Evan Hughes/HOU/EES@EES, Fran Deltoro/HOU/EES@EES, Gayle W Muench/HOU/EES@EES, Ginger Dernehl/NA/Enron@Enron, Gordon Savage/HOU/EES@EES, Harold G Buchanan/HOU/EES@EES, Harry Kingerski/NA/Enron@Enron, Iris Waser/HOU/EES@EES, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, James W Lewis/HOU/EES@EES, James Wright/Western Region/The Bentley Company@Exchange, Jeff Messina/HOU/EES@EES, Jeremy Blachman/HOU/EES@EES, Jess Hewitt/HOU/EES@EES, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Kathy Bass/HOU/EES@EES, Kathy Dodgen/HOU/EES@EES, Ken Gustafson/HOU/EES@EES, Kevin Hughes/HOU/EES@EES, Leasa Lopez/HOU/EES@EES, Leticia Botello/HOU/EES@EES, Mark S Muller/HOU/EES@EES, Marsha Suggs/HOU/EES@EES, Marty Sunde/HOU/EES@EES, Meredith M Eggleston/HOU/EES@EES, Michael Etringer/ENRON@enronXgate, Michael Mann/HOU/EES@EES, Michelle D Cisneros/ENRON@enronXgate, mpalmer@enron.com@SMTP@enronXgate, Neil Bresnan/HOU/EES@EES, Neil Hong/HOU/EES@EES, Paul Kaufman/ENRON@enronXgate, Paula Warren/HOU/EES@EES, Richard L Zdunkewicz/HOU/EES@EES, Richard Leibert/HOU/EES@EES, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, Rita Hennessy/ENRON@enronXgate, Roger Yang/SFO/EES@EES, Rosalinda Tijerina/HOU/EES@EES, Sandra McCubbin/NA/Enron@ENRON, Sarah Novosel/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Scott Gahn/HOU/EES@EES, Scott Stoness/HOU/EES@EES, Sharon Dick/HOU/EES@EES, skean@enron.com@SMTP@enronXgate, Tanya Leslie/HOU/EES@EES, Tasha Lair/HOU/EES@EES, Ted Murphy/HOU/ECT@ECT, Terri Greenlee/ENRON@enronXgate, Tim Belden/ENRON@enronXgate, Tony Spruiell/HOU/EES@EES, Vicki Sharp/HOU/EES@EES, Vladimir Gorny/ENRON@enronXgate, Wanda Curry/ENRON@enronXgate, William S Bradford/ENRON@enronXgate, Kathryn Corbally/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Jubran Whalan/HOU/EES@EES, Tony Riley/Enron@EUEnronXgate, Richard B Sanders/Enron@enronXgate, Robert C Williams/ENRON@enronXgate, Greg Wolfe/ENRON@enronXgate, James Wright/Western Region/The Bentley Company@Exchange, Dirk vanUlden/Western Region/The Bentley Company@Exchange, Steve Walker/SFO/EES@EES, Jennifer Rudolph/HOU/EES@EES, Martin Wenzel/SFO/HOU/EES@EES, Douglas Condon/SFO/EES@EES, wgang@enron.com@SMTP@enronXgate, Scott Govenar <sgovenar@govadv.com>@SMTP@enronXgate, Hedy Govenar <hgovenar@govadv.com>@SMTP@enronXgate, jklauber@llgm.com@SMTP@enronXgate, Mike D Smith/HOU/EES@EES, John Neslage/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Janel Guerrero/Corp/Enron@Enron, Eric Letke/DUB/EES@EES, Richard B Sanders/Enron@enronXgate, gfergus@brobeck.com@SMTP@enronXgate, Michael Tribolet/ENRON@enronXgate, Robert Frank/NA/Enron@Enron, Richard B Sanders/Enron@enronXgate, gfergus@brobeck.com@SMTP@enronXgate, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@ENRON, Chris Holmes/HOU/EES@EES, David Leboe/ENRON@enronXgate cc: Subject: POWER POINTS:Nevada Suffers FERC Unintended Consequences Great dialog on everything that's wrong with price controls. -----Original Message----- From: "Onukogu, Ernest" <Ernest.Onukogu@dowjones.com>@ENRON [mailto:IMCEANOTES-+22Onukogu+2C+20Ernest+22+20+3CErnest+2EOnukogu+40dowjones+ 2Ecom+3E+40ENRON@ENRON.com] Sent: Friday, July 06, 2001 1:11 PM To: undisclosed-recipients:;@ENRON Subject: POWER POINTS:Nevada Suffers FERC Unintended Consequences -- > POWER POINTS:Nevada Suffers FERC Unintended Consequences > > By Mark Golden > A Dow Jones Newswires Column > > NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--Those who have opposed wholesale electricity price > controls have been labeled as extreme free-market ideologues who are > insensitive > to the practical impacts on peoples' lives of high electricity prices. > But the most common argument against price caps has been logical, not > ideological: Price controls have never worked. Market participants always > find a > way around the rules. > This week the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission decided that it will > have > to consider at its meeting next week revisions to its June 19 price > control > ruling. The initial price cap rule, set by the California Independent > System > Operator last spring, was only a few paragraphs long. Each successive > price cap > order has gotten longer, though effectiveness still appears out of reach. > The > FERC's April order was 28 pages long; the June order was 48 pages. And now > additional rules are on call to plug the new loopholes. > The revisions will also try to repair damage done to the market by the > June > order. During a spell of very hot weather Monday, Sierra Pacific Resources > (SRP) > subsidiary Nevada Power had to initiate limited rolling blackouts to a > small > number of customers for 45 minutes. The company attributed the blackouts, > in > part, to the new price controls. > Sierra Pacific's chief spokesman, Paul Heagen, provided a bird's eye > view of > the practical realities of the FERC's new price cap regime. > Power Points: After having a few days to look into it, can you say that > price > caps definitely contributed to blackouts in Nevada on Monday? > Paul Heagen: Yes, but first let me say that all of it was unintentional. > FERC > was trying to do the right thing. Price caps were a noble effort to solve > a real > problem in California. > But on Monday the market needed speed and clarity to function. It had > neither, > and that can be attributed to the price caps. Normally, in one or two > phone > calls we could have got what we needed. On Monday, we were five to six > calls > into it and still on the phone. > Price caps are having the unintended consequence of dragging other > states into > the California morass. We have this artificial environment which we are > all > trying to sort through. > PP: How, specifically, are the caps having this effect? > PH: There are a couple of elements. The 10% premium for power sold to > California is supposed to reflect concerns about credit. That 10% in an > open > market is no big deal, but in a constrained situation the seller will grab > it, > because now it's his only chance to make money. > Also, the way this is set up, they look backwards. They determine the > price > after the fact. I can't think of any business in the world where you sell > a > product and find out later what price you sold at. > This had a very chilling effect on people's willingness to sell. > Normally, a > cloud cover comes in and a utility has a little extra power to sell in the > real-time market. Normally, those little 50-megawatt packets move pretty > easily, > and that's really important for maintaining reliability. > With the price cap, utilities hunkered down. Selling at $92 wasn't worth > the > risk. They figured they might as well hang on in case they needed it. > Also, we have a voluntary curtailment program that allows us to share > savings > with customers who agree to curtail use. If the market is, say, $500, we > might > pay them $250/MWh to curtail demand. But in a $92/mkt, we can offer them > such a > small amount of money that they stay on. > PP: Have you talked to FERC about these problems with the price > controls? > PH: We've had a senior team in Washington, D.C., at the FERC since last > week. > Right away we saw another effect of the FERC order: It penalizes companies > like > ours that signed long-term supply contracts before the order because many > of > those deals were done at prices above the price cap. > The biggest issue for us, is, did FERC really mean to penalize companies > like > us that planned ahead? It's long-term contracts that provide price > stability. > It's unfair to our customers to expect them to pay for long-term > contracts > that have been undercut by price caps. If we get into a situation where we > have > a little extra to sell, now we can't recover our costs. > PP: With such high prices the past year, a lot of small, oil-fired > turbines > have been dusted off and put into service on time for this summer. Traders > for > other southwest utilities have said that all these little turbines have > been > very helpful when supplies got tight earlier in the year, but they weren't > available this week because they cost more to run than the price cap. Did > you > see the same thing? > PH: We have some small turbines that we put in Reno and the Lake Tahoe > area in > the last few months. They were supposed to provide peak power, but they > get > uneconomic in a hurry under the price cap scheme. > You know, we've tried to isolate ourselves as best we could from the > California situation and behave very independent of how California > behaves. So > Nevada is a great test case to see if price caps have an unintended effect > outside of California. We were able to minimize the impact on our > customers > Monday, but the situation has maximized the attention of the country on > the > impact of price caps. > -By Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604; > mark.golden@dowjones.com > > (END) DOW JONES NEWS 07-06-01 > 03:14 PM- - 03 14 PM EDT 07-06-01 >