Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

26 Aug 1999, 21:57 UTC

Re: SWAP

From
Julian Poole/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT" AT ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@CCMAIL no.address@enron.com
Date
Thu, 26 Aug 1999 14:57:00 -0700 (PDT)
Sara, pls. read this email and call me.

Julian
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Julian Poole/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on
26/08/99 17:56 ---------------------------


Julian Poole on 27/08/99 00:26:10

To:   Don Black/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Federico
Cerisoli/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc:   Rodolfo Freyre/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Brent
Hendry/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
Subject:  Re: SWAP

Rolo and I just had a meeting with Amy at Duke, regarding the 
misunderstanding of the Floating Price assumed in the swap.
There is a difference between their definition of Index and ours. Duke was 
assuming the "monthly average of the monomic spot price published by Cammesa"
to be the one which includes:
Weighted average of hourly energy prices
"Energia Adicional"
Capacity (including: Base, Confiabilidad, Reserva de Potencia and
Servicios Asociados)
This is published by Cammesa as one monthly price.

I was assuming the "monthly average of the daily monomic prices", which
includes:
Simple average of hourly energy prices
Capacity (including: Base and Confiabilidad)

The difference between Duke's Index and ours is that Duke's usually trades at 
approx. $2.50-$3.00 above ours. Clearly there was a confusion here.

So, there is no deal at this point. But Duke is evaluating taking a position 
by which they claim that the exchanged e-mails are clear enough to enforce 
the swap, and therefore they might not be willing to let it go so easy. They 
are awaiting to check with Erik and legal and will get back to us shortly. I 
believe there is room for misunderstanding in the e-mail were Amy defines the 
Index, in which she agrees with our definition of Floating Price, and adds 
the other wording.

Below is the sequence of e-mails exchanged with Amy during the proposal 
period. The title of the proposal I sent says "Financial Swap Indication" and 
For discussion purposes only.

Any thoughts?

Julian
---------------------- Forwarded by Julian Poole/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on
26/08/99 16:17 ---------------------------


"Amy J Statler" <ajstatler@duke-energy.com> on 26/08/99 19:40:39

To:   Julian Poole/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc:
Subject:  Re: SWAP







Julian,
Yes, I am aware of the situation.  Please accept my invitation to come to our 
office around 3:30 or 4:00.  If this time does not fit in your schedule
please
let me know when you are available.
Thanks
Amy





jpoole2@ei.enron.com on 08/26/99 12:14:00 PM

To:   Amy J Statler/International/GlobalAsset@DukePower
cc:   Erik Ludtke/International/GlobalAsset@DukePower, Alejandro 
Felices/International/GlobalAsset@DukePower, fceriso@ei.enron.com,
dblack@ei.enron.com
Subject:  Re: SWAP







Amy,

It appears there has been a misunderstanding in what each one of us referred
to
as "Average Monomic Price". I suggest we get together and discuss this issue.
Are you in BA? You can come to our offices or we




%ll step over.

Regards, Julian




"Amy J Statler" <ajstatler@duke-energy.com> on 26/08/99 01:04:57

To:   Julian Poole/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc:   "Erik Ludtke" <elludtke@duke-energy.com>, "Alejandro Felices"
<axfelices@duke-energy.com>
Subject:  Re: SWAP









Julian,
Please refer to attached emails where we agree that the floating price will
be
the "monthly average of the monomic spot price published by CAMMESA."  The 
monomic price published by CAMMESA is found in the MEMNET under the icon
Informe
Mensual titled Precios Medios Monomicos Mensuales or in the Boletin Mensual
del
MEM.
Please adjust your confirmation language to reflect this.
Thanks,
Amy




jpoole2@ei.enron.com on 08/04/99 01:09:47 PM

To:   Amy J Statler/International/GlobalAsset@DukePower
cc:
Subject:  Re: SWAP







I agree

Julian




"Amy J Statler" <ajstatler@duke-energy.com> on 04/08/99 19:11:15

To:   Julian Poole/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc:
Subject:  Re: SWAP






Julian,
Yes, I agree with those terms.  I would like to add that it will be the
monthly
average of the monomic spot price published by CAMMESA.  Also, the
transaction
will be settled monthly.
Amy




jpoole2@ei.enron.com on 08/04/99 10:44:15 AM

To:   Amy J Statler/International/GlobalAsset@DukePower
cc:   fceriso@ei.enron.com, dblack@ei.enron.com
Subject:  SWAP






Amy,

While waiting for the Master Swap Agreement to be signed, I want to confirm
the
general terms for the swap.
Attached is a file describing the deal.

Let's make sure our US lawyers are moving forward with the MSA.

(See attached file: Duke.ppt)
Regards,

Julian






 - Duke.ppt