12 Jan 2001, 09:58 UTC
Re: FERC Conference on Market Monitoring- REVISED DRAFT
- From
- Mary Hain mary.hain@enron.com
- Cc
- bhawkin@enron.com, bmerola@enron.com, christi.l.nicolay@enron.com, Donna Fulton, Janelle Scheuer, jeff_brown@enron.com, jhartso@enron.com, Mary Hain, Sarah Novosel, Tom Hoatson
- Bcc
- bhawkin@enron.com, bmerola@enron.com, christi.l.nicolay@enron.com, Donna Fulton, Janelle Scheuer, jeff_brown@enron.com, jhartso@enron.com, Mary Hain, Sarah Novosel, Tom Hoatson
- Date
- Fri, 12 Jan 2001 01:58:00 -0800 (PST)
I'd like to expand on the last point. The Market Monitoring Committee (MMC)
should not make findings, it should simply refer the information it gets to
FERC about abuse of market power and violations of antitrust and if should
report that information subject to confidentiality. Also, if contrary to our
wishes, the FERC allows market monitoring committees to further investigate,
make findings, and impose penalties, FERC must require the tariffs to contain
detailed due process requirements that: (1) specifically name the behavior
that is illegal and relate any penalties to specific violations, (2) require
the MMC to notify the party being invested of the tariff or law that may have
been violated, (3) allow the party being investigated to perform discovery on
any other party (including the ISO or the PX) that may instead be at fault or
may be a contributing party, (4) to facilitate this discovery, allow a party
to know the identity of the party (if any) that alerted the MMC to the
alleged violation, and (5) detail the process for any discovery, hearing, or
ADR process to ensure the party being investigated has adequate notice and
opportunity to be heard and to impute others who may instead be at fault.
Enron Capital & Trade Resources Corp.
From: "Jackie Gallagher" <JGallagher@epsa.org>
01/12/2001 09:14 AM
To: <bhawkin@enron.com>, <bmerola@enron.com>, <christi.l.nicolay@enron.com>,
<donna.fulton@enron.com>, <janelle.scheuer@enron.com>,
<jeff_brown@enron.com>, <jhartso@enron.com>, <Mary.Hain@enron.com>,
<sarah.novosel@enron.com>, <tom.hoatson@enron.com>
cc:
Subject: FERC Conference on Market Monitoring- REVISED DRAFT
MEMORANDUM
TO: Regulatory Affairs Committee
Power Marketers Working Group
FROM: Joe Hartsoe, Regulatory Affairs Committee Chair
Bob Reilley, Power Marketing Working Group Chair
Julie Simon, Vice President of Policy
DATE: January 12, 2001
RE: FERC Conference on Market Monitoring in California
? Revised Draft
? Conference Call on Tuesday, January 16th, 2:00 p.m.
(EST), 1-800-937-6563
Based on discussion at our last conference call and follow-up conversations
with some EPSA members, attached is a significantly revised list of Guiding
Principles on Market Monitoring for FERC's staff technical conference on
January 23rd to develop market monitoring procedures for the Cal ISO
markets. The most significant change from the prior draft is that we now
delete any reference to specific price levels that would screen prices in
California and focuses instead why a price-based analysis for market
monitoring is inappropriate, since it fails to account for capacity costs,
opportunity costs and scarcity values.
FERC Staff has asked that EPSA be prepared to make a presentation at the
January 23rd conference, so it is important that we see if there is consensus
on this approach. We will discuss this draft on a conference call on
Tuesday, January 16th at 2:00 p.m. (EST). To access the call, please dial
1-800-937-6563. Ask for the Julie Simon/EPSA Call. In the meantime, if you
have any questions, concerns or ideas about this effort, please contact Julie
at 202-789-7200 or jsimon@epsa.org before the call.
Attachment
- MARKET MONITORING2.doc