15 Jun 2001, 11:34 UTC
Kyoto Protocol Becomes New Albatross for Bush Administration
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Fri, 15 Jun 2001 04:34:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] Utilities are experiencing tough franchise negotiations as cities link undergrounding agreements to renewals of franchises. Communities apply tremendous political pressure on utilities to underground systems in their commercial as well as residential neighborhoods. SCIENTECH's "Electric Utility Undergrounding" report analyzes existing undergrounding programs, and provides an understanding of how regulatory bodies and utilities around the country resolve this challenging problem. If your company is involved in the undergrounding of power lines, you need to read this report. View the table of contents at: www.SCIENTECH.com/rci [IMAGE] Rapidpartsmart is the newest, most powerful online parts search engine in the power industry. Rapidpartsmart is the complete source to locate, buy and sell engineered parts worldwide. Rapidpartsmart integrates over 5 million supply items into asset management and work management systems to ensure that you know all supply sources, all the time. Rapidpartsmart increases supply options, reduces outage risks and cuts inventory investment. Contact John Kelly at (727) 669-3006 for more information or go to www.rapidpartsmart.com [IMAGE] The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power Systemby RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. The Wall Map measures 42" x 72"; the Executive Map Set consists of 18 11" x 17" maps. Visit our website at www.scientech.comfor a detailed description of these valuable maps and complete ordering instructions. [IMAGE] [IMAGE] June 15, 2001 Kyoto Protocol Becomes New Albatross for Bush Administration By Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [IMAGE]President Bush and European leaders "agreed to disagree" over a global warming treaty, as the president sought to reassure allies that sharp policy differences would not hamper relations between Europe and the United States. During several closed-door sessions, Bush and his European counterparts confronted one of their most contentious areas of disagreement: the president's rejection of the Kyoto Protocol on global warming. "We agreed to disagree," Swedish Prime Minister Goran Persson told reporters. "The European Union is sticking to the Kyoto Protocol. The United States has chosen another policy." Analysis: It is rather amazing how prominently energy issues have factored into the first six months of the Bush administration. In contrast to the eight years of the Clinton administration, when energy policy often took a backseat to other concerns, President Bush-a result of California blackouts, a national shortage of natural gas, sky-high electricity prices, and a controversial energy task plan-been comparatively consumed by energy issues. Now, in a political legacy from the previous administration, President Bush finds himself grappling with another contentious energy problem that has global ramifications. Departing from what appears to be an international consensus, President Bush has declared the Kyoto Protocol an ineffective treaty and has instead decided to further examine the greenhouse gas problem, which has raised further questions about the president's commitment to environmental issues. First, let me provide some background. The Kyoto Protocol developed out of meetings held in December 1997 in Kyoto, Japan, during which time the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change agreed in principle to a series of strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. About 170 governments of various countries, including the United States, participated in the Protocol and agreed to reduce their aggregate carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent emissions by at least 5 percent below 1990 levels by 2012. Noticeably exempt from the Protocol were developing countries such as China and India-of the largest greenhouse gas emitters in the world—which resisted taking on any sort of formal reduction plan until industrialized countries proceeded with their own. This marked the central flaw in the Protocol in that participants such as Europe, Japan and the United States argued that it would be impossible to reach the Protocol's goals without the active and controlled participation of developing countries. Consequently, the United States could not garner two-thirds support from the Senate, which would be required to ratify the Protocol, despite endorsement from the Clinton administration. The United States is the largest emitter of CO2, accounting for one-quarter of the world total per year, and thus its participation in the Protocol has been considered essential. The Protocol's emissions targets include all major greenhouse gases: carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide (NOx), and greenhouse gases created by industrial processes, which are artificial chemicals called halocarbons (CFCs, HFCs and PFCs) and long-lived gases such as sulphur hexafluoride (SF6). The Protocol requires the main developed countries to reduce their emissions of the greenhouse gases by varying amounts: 8 percent for European Union countries, 7 percent for the United States and 6 percent for Japan. With the onset of his new administration, President Bush announced last March that the United States would not support the Kyoto Protocol, again arguing that developing nations were not included and the goals were not realistic. Further, Bush has voiced the concern that ratifying the Protocol would severely damage the U.S. economy as it would restrict industrial production. The president has also pointed out that, although European nations espouse support for the Protocol, none of the EU members has yet to ratify the treaty. Instead, President Bush has adopted a "go-slow" approach toward global warming and has vowed to spend more money to investigate the problem and work with other nations to produce a better plan. A new report from the National Academy of Sciences, requested by the Bush administration, found that global warming is indeed occurring as the result of human activity. Specifically, the report found that the Earth's temperatures could rise between 2.5 and 10.4 degrees Fahrenheit by the end of this century. On the other hand, the report could not reliably establish how much of the warming trends result from natural variations, how fast future warming will occur or how corrective actions might correct it. Thus, the president asserted that these unanswered questions warranted further investigation into the greenhouse gas problem. The president has come under fire both domestically and abroad for what is perceived as a policy that gives preference to business over the environment. In addition to his opposition to the Kyoto Protocol, President Bush also announced in March that he opposes any domestic restrictions in CO2 emissions from the nation's power plants, retracting on a pledge that he had made during his campaign. Carbon dioxide is not classified as a pollutant by the Clean Air Act, and thus the White House said that Bush's original promise was a "mistake" inconsistent with the president's broader goal of increasing domestic energy production. Toward that end, the Bush administration has focused on the construction of some 1,900 new power plants across the country to resolve a growing supply / demand imbalance. On the other hand, business groups have applauded the president's approach, echoing his belief that the Protocol would harm the nation's economy and that domestic, technology-based solutions represent a better solution. This is obviously a political story packed with passion on both sides of the debate. I won't use this space to criticize or defend President Bush's environmental stand. Instead, I think it will be useful to clearly identify the two polarized approaches that world leaders are taking toward the Kyoto Protocol. European leaders have vowed to enact the Protocol without the United States, which may not be possible. The Protocol can only be enacted if nations that produced 55 percent of the industrialized world's carbon dioxide in 1990 decide to ratify it. Japan could be the wild card in the debate, as it is leaning toward the Protocol but has not yet officially ratified it. If Japan does participate, proponents of the Protocol would have 57.5 percent of 1990 emissions (enough for ratification). Nevertheless, here is how the two approaches shake out: The Bush Approach We were given the best indication of the approach President Bush plans to take in his own environmental proposal (expected some time this summer), in a recent radio address. "With new technology, sound regulation and plain good sense, we can expand our energy production while protecting the environment," the president said. The Bush administration's previously released energy plan is primarily focused on building the nation's energy supply through the expedited construction of new generation (including nuclear power plants). Further, the president has said that "energy production and environmental protection are not competing priorities" and can both be achieved with new technology. While the president has not made any specific references to new provisions for limiting CO2 emissions from existing or new plants, the new technology to which he has referred most likely includes clean-coal technologies that can be implemented to reduce emissions from coal-fired plants. As noted in the 3/27/01 IssueAlert, new, clean-coal technologies are being tested and developed by various companies throughout the United States. One example is the integrated gasification-combined cycle (IGCC) technology that first converts coal into a combustible gas, cleans the gas of virtually all pollutants, then burns the gas in a turbine much like natural gas. More than 99 percent of sulfur, nitrogen and particulate pollutants can be removed in the process. Three gasification power plants have been built in Florida, Indiana and Nevada. As coal remains the United States' most abundant fuel source, constituting 95 percent of our nation's fossil energy reserves, much of the nation's plan for reducing emissions will focus on coal-fired generation. It is important to note, however, that most of the clean-coal technologies currently being developed eliminate SO2 pollutants and NOx, but may do little to address CO2 emissions, which is the primary focus of the Kyoto Protocol. President Bush has also stated that his administration will fully fund high priority areas for scientific research into climate change over the next five years, and help developing nations such as China and India to match the U.S. commitment. The Kyoto Protocol Approach European Commission President Romano Prodi has said that the 15 European Union countries will proceed with ratifying the Kyoto Protocol. As noted, the participation of another large industrialized country such as Japan is needed to officially enact the Protocol. If the Protocol is enacted, an international conference will be held in Bonn, Germany, this July to spell out how the specific goals of the treaty will be reached. Toward this end, French President Jacques Chirac recently commented that, "Now is not the time to conduct new studies. These studies have already been done. We have to set objectives." Specifically, European countries will proceed with setting specific and targeted cuts in their emission gases such as CO2 produced by power plants powered by fossil fuels. The EU has said that, if ratified, it will comply with the Protocol's standards for emissions reduction by 2012 and go "significantly further" to reduce emissions beyond that date. Yet, interestingly, across the Continent, nuclear power, which produces no CO2 emissions, has undergone a resurgence and presently generates an increasing percentage of the power in countries such as France and Germany. However, we have a good indication of the specific measures from negotiations that took place during the Clinton administration. Most of the emissions targets of the participating countries will be reached through emission-trading mechanisms. Trading emission of greenhouse gases allows industrialized countries to buy emissions rights from each other at a price commonly agreed. In other words, industrialized countries that do not meet emissions targets can strike deals with other industrialized nations that do better than required. This may encourage reductions to be made where they are most needed. However, critics have suggested that the mechanisms amount to loopholes that would allow large polluting countries to continue polluting, while smaller countries trade credits that do not amount to significant reductions. Moreover, the two approaches being pursued by President Bush and the European Union represent inherently different philosophies regarding the urgency of emissions control and methods that should be employed to reduce greenhouse gases. There is little possibility that President Bush will change his stand and include the United States in the Kyoto Protocol. Without U.S. participation, the Protocol may once again be stalled unless another large industrialized country such as Japan decides to join. On his own, President Bush now moves forward with constructing a plan for the United States that attempts to balance the reduction of emissions while aggressively expanding the country's generation supply. This will be a difficult balance to achieve, but the president remains confident that environmental protection and industrial expansion do not need to be mutually exclusive. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.scientech.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily e-mail, send a message to Issue Alert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.