5 Mar 2001, 11:23 UTC
Fwd: FW: Fessler - what went wrong in CA
- From
- Robert Weisenmiller rbw@mrwassoc.com
- Date
- Mon, 5 Mar 2001 03:23:00 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> > > -----Original Message----- > > Electricity Daily > > > > March 2, 2001 > > > > Fessler Fesses Up to What Went Wrong in California > > Breaking a lengthy refusal to comment publicly on the California > > electricity "Perfect Storm," Dan Fessler (chairman and a member of the > > California Public Utilities Commission from 1991 to December 1996) > > described to a recent conference in New York why things have gone so awry > > in the state and what he thinks might now be done. > > His explanation of why the crisis arose is fairly conventional: a shortage > > of generation capacity; grossly erroneous predictions of the timing and > > strength of the economic recovery in the state; and a fatal decision to > > separate the California Power Exchange from the California Independent > > System Operator. That's a policy to which Fessler (now with the meaty > > LeBouef, Lamb law firm) believes that the PUC should never have agreed. > > "Little did I realize," he told the meeting, "that the market design to > > which the commission and legislature had acceded would turn out to bear a > > striking resemblance to the battle cruiser, that ill-fated darling of > > virtually every naval power in the period 1910-1914. At Jutland, it was > > belatedly discovered that these vessels-imbued with attributes of speed > > and weaponry that made them so appealing on paper-could not take a punch. > > Their armor was too thin: a fatal design flaw revealed only when they were > > tested in battle." > > So what do we do now? Fessler suggests "a technique which I advocated in > > 1996 and which remains available for deployment next week. If successfully > > implemented, my suggestion would directly assail the vehicle of high > > prices by enlisting self-interested opportunistic behavior to make the > > demand curve elastic for the first time in the power crisis. > > "I propose that California pay large users to get off the system the > > moment reserves approach Stage One conditions. Demand bidding would > > replace interruptible tariffs for the simple reason that [the latter] have > > not worked." > >