16 Apr 2001, 12:54 UTC
PUCT Protocols Order
- From
- Thane Twiggs thane.twiggs@enron.com
- To
- Mike Curry, jducote@enron.com, Drew Tingleaf, cahn@enron.com, Jason R Wiesepape, berney.aucoin@enron.com, Michelle Parks, Doug Gilbert-smith, Larry Jester, joe.allen@enron.com, Patrick Keene, Stacey Bolton
- Date
- Mon, 16 Apr 2001 05:54:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please find attached the PUCT order approving, with modifications, the ERCOT Protocols. What follows is a brief summary of many of the points that directly affect the ERCOT market. I will provide a complete summary and timeline for response or request for rehearing on any of the issues later this week. Two of the most noticeable departures from the Protocols was for the Commission to ask for a review of the balanced schedule requirement and a departure from the current bilateral market to an LMP type market. The Commission directed ERCOT to respond with the technical feasibility of relaxing or eliminating the balanced schedule requirement. The other departure from the ERCOT protocols by the Commission is in reference to local or intrazonal congestion. The Commission states that if direct assignment of the local congestion to the generating resources is not possible, they will consider other market options such as an LMP model. The Commission will review both of these market concepts in September 2001. The ERCOT Protocol Review Subcommittee will take the ordered protocols and start the process of Protocol Revision. Each of the revisions have been assigned a completion date by the PUCT and can be found in schedule 4 attached. The PUCT approved the ERCOT petition and Ordered the that the Protocols should take effect June 1, 2001. The Commission state that the Protocols are fundamentally sound, however there are certain provisions that are boxed (cannot take effect until the ERCOT system can accommodate them) as provided for in the Protocol Implementation Plan. ERCOT was directed to initiate a process to implement the boxed provisions as soon as possible. As for the rest of the changed required by the PUCT, a timeline was attached for the implementation of the protocol revisions. Under the Protocols as filed, ERCOT had &sole discretion8 for its conduct, however, the PUCT will require ERCOT to exercise its discretion in a &reasonable, nondiscriminatory manner.8 Ancillary Services. The Protocols require ERCOT to procure the following Ancillary Services sequentially through an Auction: regulation down, regulation up, responsive reserves and non-spinning reserves. The PUCT is concerned that the process results in the possibility of price reversals where the clearing price for some A/S may be higher than other higher grade A/S services which may create incentives to game the system. The PUCT directed ERCOT to amend the Protocols such that it will procure A/S through use of simultaneous optimization for assignment of resources to A/S products, and will set prices for each A/S to the corresponding shadow price. The PUCT also ordered to ERCOT to amend the protocols such that it will use a two settlement system for the procurement of A/S. The day ahead period procurement will settle and announce at 13:30 with the second to take place during the adjustment period for each hour. Until the system is capable of the two-settlement system, ERCOT must amend the system to only allow downward adjustment of prices for unselected A/S bids and allow unselected bids by a QSE to be withdrawn only in descending order of bid prices. The wrinkle here is that the ERCOT system purges unselected bids and will require a manual tracking of the bids. A &spot check8 for the activity has been discussed. Finally, ERCOT is to consider and report whether or not ERCOT should make conditional selections of A/S bids (from a QSE portfolio) and then possible deselect based on location and not price after the QSE resource plans are published. Market Solution. Under the ERCOT protocols, a Market Solution for reducing congestion exists when at least three unaffiliated resources have available capacity and the ability to submit a bid to ERCOT to solve a circumstance of local congestion and no one bidder is essential to solve the congestion. The PUCT would like the protocol amended to require that a &market solution8 exists only when at least three bids are received from unaffiliated resources. Out of Merit Order (OOM) Service. The PUCT directs ERCOT to use the same ratcheting sown mechanism for out of merit order capacity payments to out of merit order energy payments that are based on the 18,000 heat rates. Reliability Must-Run Service. The PUCT would like to have additional incentives for generation entities to enter into RMR service contracts and that once covered, the until will be efficiently utilized. As such, ERCOT is to amen the Protocols to give an RMR unit owner the additional option for retaining 10% of net positive margins for energy generated in excess of the amount that the unit is obligated to produce under its RMR contract. Uninstructed Deviations. In order to encourage &good price chasing8 and discourage &bad price chasing,8 ERCOT was ordered to amend the Protocols to apply the ex ante MCPE for balancing energy set ten minutes for the beginning of a settlement interval to all instructed deployment of balancing energy during the settlement interval and use the second subsequent interval ex poste MCPE, which will be set five minutes after the end of the first settlement interval, for uninstructed deviations during the first load interval. Bid Caps. During the transition period, until July 4, 2004, there shall be a generation resource bid cap of $1,000 per MWh for energy that ERCOT procures. The bid cap does not apply to load resources. ERCOT was also directed to develop and submit for possible approval a bid cap on capacity bids for generation resource offering to provide replacement reserve service. Balance Schedule Requirement. The current Protocols require QSEs submit a balanced schedule, however, the PUCT intends to consider in September, 2001, the policy implications of the balanced schedule requirement, and whether the requirement should be relaxed or eliminated. ERCOT was also directed to report on the technical implications of relaxing or eliminating the balanced schedule requirement. Inter-zonal Congestion. ERCOT shall amend the Protocols to convert to the direct assignment of inter-zonal congestion costs, and base direct assignment of inter-zonal congestion costs on an adjustable commercial model that employs operational shift factors on the CSCs. The Commission will also require ERCOT to publish advisory updates or forecasts of the shift factors corresponding to CSCs to reflect predicted operating conditions and contingencies. ERCOT's obligation to guarantee full zone-to-zone- congestion cost insurance to those who acquire TCRs in proportions based on forecasted shift factors, shall be eliminated. The result of this is that a TCR portfolio that provides a full hedge of inter-zonal congestion cost based on the forecasted shift factors will not guarantee a full hedge against the actual congestion charges. The Commission does not like ERCOT to be in the business of insuring transmission users against changes in shift factors. The Commission also feels that &use-it-or-loose-it8 feature will result in inefficient usage of the transmission system. As such the Commission directs ERCOT to amends the protocols to define TCRs as pure financial instruments and eliminate &use it or loose it8. As for the TCR Auction, a single round combinatorial auction is more appropriate. Bids can take the form of price-quantity pairs for TCR portfolios or single TCRs. Preassigned TCRs. MOUs and Coops that own or have a long-term annual capacity and energy commitment from a specific &remote8 generation resource shall be preassigned TCRs. Other Stakeholders argued that the preassigning of TCRs reduces the amount available to the market and increases congest costs borne by other market participants. The Protocols, however, will be changed to state that the preassigned TCRs are subject to change or elimination at any time upon ERCOT Board of Directors approvals or Commission Order. Intrazonal Congestion. ERCOT shall amend the Protocols to require direct assignment in intrazonal congestion management costs through a usage fee based on the flow over the congested intrazonal interfaces. The usage fee shall apply to the generation resources that cause the congestion fee. The net revenues from the usage fee shall be distributed, or credited against uplift charges. However, the Commission advises that to the extent feasible under the zonal, portfolio-based model embodied in the Protocols, ERCOT shall promptly notify the commission, so that the Commission can promptly consider ordering the implementation of other alternative congestion management methods, particularly locational marginal pricing. Thane Thomas Twiggs Enron Corp 1400 Smith Street Houston, Texas 77002 713-853-3199 Voice 713-408-4463 Mobile 713-646-8272 Fax 877-968-8967 Digital Pager or 8779688967@skytel.com <<Timeline-Final Order1.ppt>> - 23220fo.doc - 23220fo, Attachment 5.xls - 23220fo, Attachment 6.xls - 23220fo, Attachment 7.doc - 23220fo, Attachment 8.doc