Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

23 Aug 1999, 21:06 UTC

FAS 133 response

From
Mark - ECT Legal Taylor mark.taylor@enron.com
To
Paige Grumulaitis
Date
Mon, 23 Aug 1999 14:06:00 -0700 (PDT)
Paige - I can be more argumentative here but if it's not going to make any 
difference in the outcome, I don't really see the point.  Let me know if you 
disagree.

While a commodity forward contract which contains an asymmetrical default 
provision clearly does not have the characteristic of net settlement, we do 
not believe that Statement 133 is appropriately applied to any contract which 
requires the making and taking of delivery of a physical commodity absent a 
default, regardless of whether the default results in a termination payment 
which may be payable to the defaulting party.  An event of default and 
resulting termination of a commodity contract can have far reaching negative 
implications for the defaulting party well beyond the terms of the contract 
itself (e.g. damage to reputation and credit, triggering of cross-defaults, 
etc.).