27 Nov 2000, 09:20 UTC
Bad Proposed Decision
- From
- Jeffery Fawcett jeffery.fawcett@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 27 Nov 2000 01:20:00 -0800 (PST)
Attached below is the CPUC's proposed decision in the Gas Industry Restructuring proceeding. Essentially, it adopts the Interim Proposal with a few modifications. The CPUC states that they are taking a "cautious" approach to deregulation in light of recent market events in both electricity and gas, and therefore, rejected the more robust reforms outlined in the Comprehensive Settlement. The CS was offered by SoCal Gas and supported by many of the settlement parties, including Enron and Transwestern. The good news is that, with respect to Hector Road, the maximum volume at Hector is limited to 50 MMcf/d, similar to the proposal made by the Comprehensive Settlement. I've included the section from the PD that deals with this issue for your convenience. The full document is also attached. excerpt at at page 50 regarding Hector Road: (1) Receipt Points/ Intrastate Transmission As we have already discussed above, we now judge that intrastate transmission unbundling is not wise at this time for the SoCalGas system. However, SoCalGas, intrastate transmission system can still be made more accessible and understandable to its users. In R. 98-01-011, the record reflects dissatisfaction among customers and shippers with the lack of clarity on how SoCalGas schedules gas shipments through its windowing system, and SoCalGas, sole use of the Hector Road interconnection as a receipt point. (Exh. 8 in R. 98-01-011, pp. 29-31 (Southern California Edison Company Market Conditions Report), (Panel Hearing Testimony of Mr. Paul Carpenter, Southern California Edison, Tr. pp. 931-932, Jan 25, 1999).) Our decision in D. 99-07-015 directed investigation into using the Hector Road interconnection, even on an interim basis, and the publication of SoCalGas, windowing criteria in tariffs. SoCalGas filed Advice Letter 2837, which detailed its process of basing a maximum amount of gas scheduled for shipment through a receipt point on the prior day,s nominations, except at the first of the month. Early in the instant proceeding, the ALJ held in abeyance active consideration of the windowing procedure tariff SoCalGas filed, pending the resolution we reach today. (Prehearing Conference of September 1, 1999, p. 34.) We are approving on an interim basis the replacement of the current windowing process with a system under which SoCalGas will establish receipt point capacities, subject to daily revision, on the basis of the physical maximums for each receipt point under the operating conditions expected for that day. Customers and shippers will know the daily maximums because they will be posted on SoCalGas, GasSelect system daily prior to the nomination deadlines. If, in the aggregate, customers nominate more than the physical capacity at any receipt point, gas will be scheduled based on the upstream pipeline,s capacity rights system. For Wheeler Ridge, at which more than one upstream pipeline delivers gas, the maximum daily physical capacity would be allocated between upstream sources pro rata on the basis of the prior day,s scheduled deliveries from each source. This system eliminates the mystery in how pro-rations are made, provides continuity in capacity rights between the interstate and intrastate systems and provides flexibility for customers in nominating at the most cost-effective receipt point on any given day. We recognize that it does not provide for long-term planning, but the alternative under the CS of paid-for firm receipt point rights for the term of the settlement has the disadvantage of locking customers into a receipt point that may lose value over the term. In this period of gas price volatility, we believe that the more flexible plan is the right one. Thus, we direct SoCalGas to withdraw Advice Letter 2837 and file a new advice letter within 10 business days implementing the proposed receipt point physical capacity system. This may be the same as the exemplary tariff filed with the IS or updated as necessary pursuant to subsequent proceedings. This tariff revision will be effective within 30 days after the filing unless rejected by the Energy Division. In R.98-01-011, PG&E and Edison particularly complained about the restrictions at Wheeler Ridge. (Exh. 15 in R. 98-01-11, pp. 7-9 (PG&E Rebuttal to Market Conditions Report), and Exh.8 in R. 98-01-011, pp. 29-31, (Southern California Edison, Market Conditions Report).) One response in the IS to these complaints is the establishment of a formal receipt point at Hector Road for all customers, subject to Wheeler Ridge access fees and surcharges. Its capacity will be 50 MMcfd or greater as long as there are nominations of that volume and Mojave Pipeline Company delivers that much in response to those nominations. This provision should allow greater flexibility for shippers and customers as well as leveling the playing field between SoCalGas and others at this interconnection. We will support SoCalGas, application to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for approval of Hector Road as a formal delivery point by Mojave. El Paso Natural Gas Company objected strongly to the provision in the IS for automatically expanding of Wheeler Ridge capacity While this was not an option specifically mentioned in D.99-07-015, we do not choose to stand on that technicality to exclude it from consideration here. Once a proceeding is open to settlement, the dynamics of settlement talks may bring in matters outside the delineated scope, as they have done here with regard to Wheeler Ridge expansion and, for instance, pooling. Both proposals respond to concerns raised in R.98-01-011, (see citations in text above as well as Panel Hearing Testimony of Mr. Benjamin C. Campbell, PG&E, Tr. pp. 267-268, Jan 19, 1999)) and neither was specifically excluded from further consideration in D.99-07-015. We therefore view them as within the scope of this proceeding. To the extent that other receipt points are also viewed as constrained, we welcome evidence to that effect in a future proceeding, as well as proposals for criteria to determine when expansion should be applied for. by 100MMcfd if a certain number of curtailments occurred, and for automatically allowing the expenses of that expansion to be rolled into rates. We do not wish to approve automatic rate increases for all ratepayers for a facility for which only some may have use, but we believe that developing criteria for expansion of receipt points is useful. Hector Road may not entirely alleviate the problem of constraints on northern gas flowing to the south. Therefore, we approve that portion of Section III of the IS that sets forth criteria for expansion, but provide that upon the meeting of that criteria, SoCalGas shall submit an application for an expansion of the receipt point capacity. That application shall be processed in the regular way, with the issues of need in the context of the entire system and foreseeable market conditions considered. Moreover, rolled-in or incremental rates, allocation of cost among classes and consequent rate design will remain open for decision in that proceeding. Thus, the modification to the IS that we make is in the first sentence of the first full paragraph on page 8. The words &apply to8 should be inserted after &SoCalGas will8. We specifically disapprove the IS language in the middle on page 8 beginning with the words &This Settlement8 through the end of the paragraph, and the concomitant language in Appendix A setting the cost at $12 million in 1999 dollars.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Jeffery Fawcett/ET&S/Enron on 11/27/2000 08:45 AM --------------------------- From: Jeff Dasovich on 11/22/2000 06:28 PM Sent by: Jeff Dasovich To: Jeffery Fawcett/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Susan Scott/ET&S/Enron@ENRON cc: Subject: Bad Proposed Decision Well, this shows the direction in which the "new" Commission is heading. The very good news, though, is that TW's proposal was included in both settlements (now that's hedging!). Thus, the benefits to TW were preserved under both proposals. Congratulations. That's fantastic--hard work that paid off. We will of course express out extreme dissappointment with the PD, and point out that this decision condemns California to a 20th century infrastructure, when the state's 21st century economy demands much, much better. We should discuss. Since the PD empowers the likes of Norm and Florio, it will be important to play very close attention to implementation of Hector. Sorry to have to be the one to deliver the news. But we have a knack of making lemonade out of lemons and we'll do out best to do the same here, whatever turns up at the end. Best, Jeff ----- Forwarded by Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron on 11/22/2000 05:53 PM ----- Michael.Alexander@sce.com 11/22/2000 05:27 PM To: Paul_Amirault%SCE@sce.com, tomb@crossborderenergy.com, burkee@cts.com, craigc@calpine.com, rick.counihan@greenmountain.com, jdasovic@enron.com, MDay@GMSSR.com, Douglas.Porter@sce.com cc: Colin.Cushnie@sce.com, INGGM@sce.com Subject: The PD in the Gas Restructuring is out. I have yet to read the whole thing, but the title "Approval With Modifications Of The Interim Settlement..." does not bode well. According to Steve Watson (and I only have Steve's statement second hand), the decision reflects a fear that the timing is wrong in light of the current volatile gas price market. (See attached file: Proposed.doc) -- Michael S. Alexander Southern California Edison 626-302-2029 626-302-3254 (fax) - Proposed.doc