10 Oct 2001, 22:01 UTC
The Other Weapon In Our War Against Terror
- From
- Jonathan Lash, President" @ENRON jlash@wri.org
- To
- Kenneth Lay
- Date
- Wed, 10 Oct 2001 15:01:18 -0700 (PDT)
Dear WRI Friends and Family, A few weeks ago the WRI Board had a powerful and wide ranging discussion of the events of September 11 and their aftermath. We talked about the concept of human security, and the connections among security, environment and development. The following are some observations flowing from that discussion that the Board suggested I circulate to WRI's friends and family. With violent conflict underway, this is a difficult and uncertain time to try to draw conclusions, but it is a critical time to think about the future. Terrorism is hideous theater. Victims and audience are one. Information and images flow around the world without regard to borders as barriers or the intentions of those who create them. We are compelled to respond, locked in the scenes of a tragic drama, a violent twenty first century morality play, running round the clock on CNN. In our minds it began on September 11th, but in other minds it began perhaps a decade before with the Gulf War, but now the awful question is when will it end? How do we create a more secure world? We do not know what the men who hijacked the four planes on September 11 and killed thousands of innocent people hoped to accomplish. It does not appear that they were poor men, but there is reason to believe that Osama bin Laden is bent on provoking a war in which the poor would be his soldiers. Neither violence nor hatred is a pathology only of the poor, but the compound of misery, powerlessness and injustice is volatile - exactly the mix that the terrorists who attacked us hope to ignite. We cannot create security only by striking at the flint; we must deal with the tinder. What if we capture the leaders of terrorist groups, seize their resources, disrupt their networks, and deter their state sponsors, but act with narrow focus, treating terror as a crime without a cause that we can address, will our world be secure? A safe and stable world requires more fundamental changes. The squalid slums in the sprawling cities in the poorest parts of the world are growing explosively, expanding by a million people a week. Three-fourths of the world's agricultural lands are degraded, and the cities are filling with people driven from rural areas by expanding population and failing lands. There are about a billion teenagers in the world, most of them poor, jobless and struggling for shreds of hope. Within a decade or so, if trends continue, there will be 27 cities in the developing world that are bigger than New York. If they are full of jobless young men with nowhere to turn, they will be tinderboxes of anger and despair. One-third of the world's people face water scarcity, and water use is rising twice as fast as population. Three great rivers, the Amu Darya, the Colorado, and the Yellow no longer reach the sea in dry seasons. The number facing scarcity is likely to double in the next several decades creating a band of scarcity around the middle of the globe. 70% of the water people use is for agriculture, and it is used to produce half the world's food. Water scarcity is already raising tensions in many places including the Middle East, the Mekong Delta, and between the United States and Mexico. A billion people depend for food on wild caught fish, but two-thirds of the world's fisheries are being harvested beyond sustainability, and many have collapsed, taking with them people's livelihoods. Half of all jobs worldwide depend on fisheries, forests, and agriculture. In one-fourth of the world's nations natural resources directly produce more income than industry. Global warming caused by the industrial world's ever-increasing burning of coal and oil is underway, and scientists predict that it will cause not just hotter weather, but more severe storms and droughts. It will intensify the agony of dry regions, worsen the misery of the poor, and drive still more refugees from the land. Meanwhile, two billion people still have no access to electricity. Terrorism and war are, in part, the more immediate consequences of ever increasing oil consumption, particularly for transportation. Osama bin Laden has explained his terrorist acts against the US as a response to the presence of US military bases in the Islamic holy land of Saudi Arabia. The US military is there to ensure access to Saudi Arabian oil, which represents the largest oil reserves in the world, about 25%. Many of the most insecure regions of the world are also the least democratic. People there are not only poor, they are voiceless. Dependent directly on natural resources they have no say in how those resources are used, but suffer the consequences when the decisions are corrupt and the use is destructive. The notion that security, stability, and sustainability are linked is by no means novel. Refugees have been driven from the land by the collapse of natural systems for millennia. Nations have fought for access to scarce natural resources. The CIA recognized the connection in an unclassified report last year. Human ability to improve lives while we protect the future has grown rapidly, however, and we must use these capabilities as an alternative weapon in our war on terror. Imagine if we determined not only to root out terrorism, but also to deprive it of soil in which to grow. We in the United States might triple our aid to the poorest nations from $17 to $50 per American per year, supporting a vast improvement in education, health, and micro credit to launch small businesses. We would support improved agriculture, community based fishery management, and the dispersion of practical technologies to use water many times more efficiently. We would work for greater access for more people to sustainable energy resources. We would work to ensure that people have the chance to participate in decisions about natural resources and environment. We would honor our commitments to ensure that poor women can plan their families. We would seek to broaden our anti-terror alliance into a partnership for human security, abandoning unilateralism for broad collaboration. We would join the same allies whose help we now seek in confronting terrorism, to combat global climate change, using our immense technological capacity to reduce our use of fossil fuels, and diminish our dependence on foreign oil. The partnership for human security would make the world a safer place even if it cannot remove all of the causes of conflict between peoples and among nations. Consider the alternative. If the United States takes direct action but withdraws from collaboration on broader purposes any security we achieve will be ephemeral. If our oil use continues to rise we will have fewer options in the Middle East. If we fail to invest in development we will have fewer friends and fewer customers. If we do not solve tomorrow's problems today, we will still have today's problems tomorrow. What is WRI's role? Do we matter? There are organizations around the world, many of them WRI's partners, who work to improve human security. Human security is at the heart of WRI's work. Our mission is to "move human society to live in ways that protect Earth's environment and its capacity to provide for?future generations". Our work is to create solutions to global problems and vehicles for the collaboration necessary to implement them. After the attacks on September 11th, WRI staff received several thousand messages of concern and outrage from our colleagues in more than 100 countries. These were not the list serve exchanges of rumors and misinformation that surged through the web, but affirmations from our partners in values-based networks that rise above the differences of place. They form the links that are essential to maintain understanding in moments of violence. WRI uses the technologies of the Global Era to create connection among people, and we use connection to provide information and voice. For example: ? Global Forest Watch supplies space based data and Information Age tools to local groups on the ground in the world's last frontier forests. They collect information on who is doing what and whether it is legal which Global Forest Watch uses to create a real time, on-line, map based early warning system of threats to the forest, a system that enables companies to avoid purchasing wood from unsustainable logging, and consumers to hold companies accountable. The groups on the ground are empowered. ? Earth Trends provides people with the world's best source of information about their environment and natural resources, and the tools to use that information to influence decisions. Information is power. Earth Trends enables people to find and use it. ? The Access Initiative has built a global alliance of groups and institutions to hold governments publicly accountable for their compliance with their commitments to open environmental governance articulated in the Rio Declaration and the Aarhus Convention. The initiative will strengthen people's claims to information, voice, and justice. ? New Ventures creates opportunity and hope. It identifies and supports a new generation of entrepreneurs in Latin America who are seeking to create sustainable enterprises in their communities. New Ventures provides business mentoring, visibility, and access to venture capital for ideas that use local resources and capacity sustainably, and has mobilized millions of dollars in investment capital even during a strong economic downturn in Latin America. ? Oil for a Finite Future demonstrates how long term deployment of more efficient, non-fossil fueled vehicles such as hydrogen or electric cars powered by renewable energy resources can alleviate the underlying long-term security issues of oil depletion and global climate change, not to mention terrorism. Since non-Persian Gulf oil production is nearing its peak we show that we cannot drill our way to energy security. ? SafeClimate provides tools for individuals, businesses, and institutions to reduce their impact on climate change by taking low cost steps to reduce the emissions of greenhouse gasses that they cause, making climate protection as easy as putting out the recycling bin. Americans are hungry to do something that helps. When they do, their government will follow them. ? Climate and Developing Countries - WRI has been a leading voice of reason about the role of developing countries in addressing climate change, developing widely used indicators, and policy proposals that have helped create the basis for a dialogue more constructive than the sloganeering of many American political leaders. ? Digital Dividends explores the opportunities for development, empowerment, and improved management of natural resources on the other side of the digital divide, and has linked leaders in the digital industry to hundreds of innovative projects created by local entrepreneurs and activists worldwide. We have done innovative and influential work on energy, agriculture, and water resources. We have sought to engage businesses and investors in creating strategies for sustainability. We believe that work that connects people across the boundaries of region and sector is the most powerful antidote to the toxins of misery, mistrust, and disempowerment. We will continue to be advocates of the proposition that protecting the web of life that connects and supports us all is essential to long term security. Violence is not new. Brutality and hatred have afflicted humanity for as long as the capacity to do good has elevated us. We learned the knowledge of good and evil only when both entered our hearts. Do we have the occasion to do good as well as justice in responding to the terrible evil that was committed on September 11th? The modern violent evil is both terrifying and shocking not only because it occurred on American soil, but also because it was so sudden and powerful. The force of evil has been amplified, its reach extended, its speed accelerated like so many things in the global era, by technology and connection. The jetliners that were the instruments of destruction are among the forces shrinking our world. Jonathan