9 Oct 2000, 10:03 UTC
Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: GEORGE W. BUSH CRITICIZES CLINTON-GORE'S ENERGY POLICY ...
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Mon, 9 Oct 2000 03:03:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Miyung Buster/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on 10/09/2000 10:03 AM ----- djcustomclips@djinteractive.com 10/05/2000 03:19 PM Please respond to nobody To: 86464@WCTOPICS.djnr.com cc: Subject: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: GEORGE W. BUSH CRITICIZES CLINTON-GORE'S ENERGY POLICY ... GEORGE W. BUSH CRITICIZES CLINTON-GORE'S ENERGY POLICY IN ANNOUNCING HIS OWN ? 10/04/2000 Foster Electric Report 7 (c) Copyright 2000, Foster Associates, Inc. While attacking the Clinton-Gore Administration's "nonexistent" national energy policy, Republican presidential candidate George W. Bush recently revealed his own policy. "Despite presiding over a period of unprecedented economic growth and increasing energy demand, it is clear that the Clinton-Gore Administration has done little to plan for America's future energy needs," said a Bush position paper on energy issues. "At best, for the last seven-and-a-half years the Administration has had no energy policy. At worst, its policy has been to ignore America's increasing reliance on foreign oil, while discouraging domestic energy exploration and production. Moreover, the Administration's actions have been inherently contradictory: extolling the virtues of information technology, but failing to plan for the increased energy needs of the New Economy; promoting the development of electric vehicles, but discouraging investment in new electrical generating capacity." In particular, Bush criticized the Administration for allowing U.S. dependence on foreign oil to jump to a record 56 percent, compared with only 36 percent during the 1973 oil crisis. As important as oil is, however, "increasingly, the most critical source of energy for the country is electricity, which is principally produced not by oil, but by natural gas, coal, nuclear energy, and hydroelectric power," asserted the Bush energy policy outline. And while the Clinton-Gore Administration has been pushing Americans to increase their use of renewable energy resources, Bush believes that a national energy policy "must also be realistic about our current situation. . . . [and] must reflect the fact that, for the foreseeable future, hydrocarbons -- oil, coal, and especially clean-burning natural gas -- will continue to play a critical role in meeting the growing energy needs of the New Economy. Hydroelectric and nuclear power will also play an important role." Bush also blasted the current Administration for discouraging investment in additional electrical generating capacity and transmission, leaving certain areas of the country vulnerable to regional brownouts and blackouts. In particular, the presidential hopeful noted that Internet-related activities now consume about 13 percent of U.S. electric output. Further, while in 1975 roughly 25 percent of U.S. energy demand was delivered as electricity, Bush's energy outline said this figure has risen to almost 37 percent and will continue to rise "due to the growth of the New Economy." "Intel estimates the number of Internet nodes will reach one billion sometime during the current decade," noted Bush. "New web sites translate into more users, more traffic, more servers, more peripherals, more air conditioning -- in short, more demand for electricity and for the fuels that are used to produce it." And as demand keeps growing, the nation's generating fleet is getting older. By 2015, about 60 percent of the existing coal-fired plants and 40 percent of nuclear plants will be more than 40-years-old. At the same time, the nation's electric transmission grid desperately needs new investment as it bends under the strain of greater power flows created by competition in wholesale electricity markets. "Unfortunately, the Clinton-Gore Administration has failed to establish a framework to encourage this investment," Bush asserted. Bush next noted the nation's dependence on coal to produce 50 percent of the nation's electricity supply. Yet, while the U.S. holds more than 25 percent of the world's coal reserves, which would be enough to produce power at current production rates for the next 250 years, Bush said the current Administration's policies and implementation of the Kyoto global climate treaty would reduce electricity derived from coal to less than 10 percent by 2020. "As a result, electricity prices would increase 50 percent in real terms and a massive investment in natural gas infrastructure would be required to replace the lost coal capacity," Bush continued. Further, substantial emission reductions "could be more readily achieved by scheduling emission reductions to coincide with technological advances, but the Administration is instead insisting upon substantial reductions before these advances can be reasonably deployed." The Clinton-Gore Administration was also blasted by Bush for doing nothing about replacing the 40 percent of the nation's electricity needs currently being met by the nuclear capacity expected to be retired by 2020 and for the costly and time consuming current hydropower relicensing process, as well as for not taking a stand on Secretary of the Interior Bruce Babbitt's open advocacy of destroying dams. Finally, Bush -- who passed an electric industry deregulation bill while governor of Texas -- complained that the Administration has not pushed hard enough for a federal electric industry deregulation bill. "Roughly half of the states, including Texas, have passed some form of electric restructuring legislation to deal with retail markets," Bush stated. "It has become increasingly clear, however, that federal legislation is needed to assure the reliability of the nation's electrical grid, and to promote consumer choice by removing federal barriers to competition. Unfortunately, the Administration has not offered the leadership necessary to pass a comprehensive electric restructuring bill, thus preventing consumers from receiving all of the benefits that deregulation can provide." In contrast to the Administration, the position paper said Bush "recognizes the need for a comprehensive, strategic approach to ensuring U.S. energy security. He understands that the only way to meet America's growing energy needs is to utilize a range of fuels and technologies: oil, natural gas, coal, nuclear, hydroelectric, wind, and biomass, as well as increased conservation. He also understands the critical need to help low-income Americans with their energy bills." Thus, if elected president, Bush pledged to work with Canada and Mexico to develop a North American energy policy. "The U.S. must develop policies and strategies to support the increasing cross-border flows of oil, natural gas and electricity within North America," Bush explained. "Governor Bush and his Secretary of Energy will work with their counterparts in Canada and Mexico to improve oil and gas distribution, enhance the reliability of the North American electrical grid, and promote cross-border energy trade. For example, Canada and the U.S. could work together to streamline permitting so that a natural gas pipeline from Alaska to the Midwest could be built." On whether to use the strategic petroleum reserve (SPR)to mitigate high oil prices, Bush said no. Instead, he would like to create a privately-managed Northeast home heating oil reserve. "However, he does not believe that the government should be actively trading petroleum products into, and out of, storage, as this represents significant government involvement in the oil markets," said the paper. "Rather, the government should contract with private companies to perform storage services. This will minimize government expenditures and interference in the market, while ensuring that heating oil supplies will be available when needed." To help the nation meet "the electricity demands of the new economy," Bush pledged to encourage the development of North American oil and natural gas resources. As part of this strategy, Bush would propose to open 8 percent of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge "to environmentally responsible exploration," which could replace the oil that the U.S. now imports from Iraq, and "examine whether certain promising natural gas reserves in federal lands should be opened to environmentally responsible and regulated exploration." Bush also recognizes the need for environmentally responsible development of existing coal, nuclear, and hydro capacity. Thus, as president, he pledged to fund research into "Clean Coal" technologies and support the permanent extension of the existing Rtax credit. To facilitate the transfer of nuclear assets to U.S. utilities specializing in operating nuclear power facilities, Bush promised to seek legislation clarifying that the transfer of plant decommissioning funds not be taxed as part of the transaction. On hydropower, Bush wants to streamline the relicensing process and oppose efforts to breach hydroelectric dams. Bush also insisted that comprehensive electric industry deregulation legislation is necessary "to encourage the investment necessary to expand electrical generating capacity," maintain reliability, and encourage competition. "Having enacted one of the most successful and comprehensive electricity deregulation bills in the nation, Governor Bush understands the need for complementary federal deregulation legislation," the position paper stated. Thus, as president, Bush would support federal legislation that (1) empowers a single organization to oversee reliability concerns and assess penalties for those that abuse the transmission grid, (2) protects consumers, and (3) repeals the Public Utility Holding Company Act and ends the mandatory purchase requirement of the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978. A President Bush would also promote separate legislation (1) establishing mandatory reduction targets for emissions of four main pollutants: sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxide, mercury and carbon dioxide; (2) phasing in these emissions reductions over a "reasonable" time period; (3) allowing utilities to make modifications to their plants without fear of new litigation under the Environmental Protection Agency's new source review requirements; and (4) providing market-based incentives, such as emissions trading and carbon credits, to help industry achieve the required reductions. To encourage the development of renewable and alternative energy sources and to promote conservation, Bush would propose to create a "Royalties Conservation Fund" that would earmark royalties collected from new oil and gas exploration on federal lands to fund conservation efforts. "It is estimated that royalties collected from opening just 8 percent of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil and gas exploration could produce hundreds of millions of dollars in royalties annually," the paper noted. Bush would also support tax credits for electricity produced from alternative and renewable resources. Finally, among other things, Bush plans to (1) require federal regulators "to develop a comprehensive policy for approving pipelines, (2) invest $1 billion over ten years "to establish clear rules to help efficient utilities purchase nuclear plants, streamline the relicensing process for hydroelectric projects, and oppose the breaching of dams"; (3) and propose legislation requiring electric utilities to reduce harmful emissions, not just asking them to do so voluntarily as advocated by Vice President Gore. Folder Name: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation Relevance Score on Scale of 100: 97 ______________________________________________________________________ To review or revise your folder, visit Dow Jones CustomClips or contact Dow Jones Customer Service by e-mail at custom.news@bis.dowjones.com or by phone at 800-369-7466. (Outside the U.S. and Canada, call 609-452-1511 or contact your local sales representative.) ______________________________________________________________________ Copyright (c) 2000 Dow Jones &Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved