28 Apr 2001, 20:55 UTC
Re: Time Warner
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- Date
- Sat, 28 Apr 2001 13:55:00 -0700 (PDT)
OK Gang: Well, I,ve been crunching numbers all day, and haven,t yet gotten to the writing. I've attached Dylan's original responses for reference. Figure it'll be a memo from Time's CEO to the Time Board. I,ve leaving now for Mendocino, but will be back early tomorrow to finish this up. Please check out the spreadsheet. The case is sort of confusing*how do Time,s analysts value Time at $189-212, when they,re trading at 109 the day before the announcement of the deal with Warner. That doesn,t jive. Are they saying that, absent synergies, the combined Time/Warner is worth the enterprise value of Time at 189-212 plus the enterprise value of Warner at $63-71 (again, the analysts valuation)? That just seems ridiculous, give where they,re trading. Anyway, here,s where my analysis is heading----tell me if I,m smoking crack. The deal isn,t really $175 per share. It,s $175 LESS the taxes that will have to paid (since it,s a purchase deal) PLUS the value of the tax shield created by the net increase of $8.9B in new debt that Paramount will take on. Does this seem right? Could folks look at my spreadsheet? I,ve got it conceptually set up, but I,m not quite sure how to calculate the taxes paid under the purchase method or the value of the tax shield (assuming that this is correct. If I,m just completely out of it with this angle, just let me know. In any case, seems that there,s some value in the tax-free (Time-Warner) versus the taxable (Time-Paramount) deals. Presumably, we could take the total enterprise value of Time-Warner (nontaxed) and compared it to the total enterprise of Paramount-Time (taxed) and compare the two. I, ve got a hunch that the Time-Warner number may win the day, but I haven,t gotten that far in the crunching yet. In any case, I,ll be back around Noon tomorrow and will crank the puppy out. Best, Jeff