24 Aug 2000, 10:24 UTC
RE: GSPP Electricity Policy Summit meeting minutes
- From
- Lee Friedman lfried@uclink4.berkeley.edu
- To
- whederman@columbiaenergygroup.com, Heather Cameron, lfried@uclink.berkeley.edu, Jeff Dasovich, Annette Doornbos, Allen Mosher, gramlr@pjm.com
- Date
- Thu, 24 Aug 2000 03:24:00 -0700 (PDT)
Hi all. I'm pleased to be part of this group and to work with each of you again. I agree with those who have responded so far that the cons probably outweigh the pros of having joint business school sponsorship. I see some resons to narrow down date choices. Not Nov. 2 or 3 because too much of GSPP will be away at the APPAM conference in Seattle. Nov. 6-10 is election week, and that would detract from the press coverage we ought to get. And Thangsgiving week is probably a poor choice. So I suspect best times after end of Oct. are either Nov. 13-17, maybe Mon. Nov. 20, or the last week of Nov. 27-Dec. 1. Later than this begins to get into end of classes, finals, etc. On format, I'm thinking about how to combine high-visibility players with academics to make for a productive discussion. Possibly we might want 2-3 people on each panel as "speakers" and 1 other person as a "discussant" to respond to speaker ideas. Maybe the discussants should be academics, the speakers high-visibility players (who are known to have opposing views in some interesting way). Perhaps there should be a brief keynote speaker (e.g. Feinstein 10-15 mins), then a single academic to give a brief history of the deregulation movement (20 mins.), then two panels (short-run problems and solutions, long-run problems and solutions). We might want at least one speaker who can bring in some non-US experience, like England's since they are much further down the deregulation road than we are. Except for the "Feinstein" opening role, I'd like the other speakers to be really knowlegable about this area (i.e. more than just highly-visible people). Rich Gilbert from our econ. dept. is another possible academic (he preceded Borenstein as head of the University's Energy Research shop, and then did a Washington tour as chief economist of DOJ; he's also a founder of Law & Economics Consulting), who might be good on the "long-run" panel if we go that way. Richard (Dick) Bilas is a CPUC commissioner and an economist by training, and might be a good backup choice (or even preferable) to Lynch. Lee Friedman
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: gramlr@pjm.com [mailto:gramlr@pjm.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 23, 2000 4:28 AM To: amosher@appanet.org; doornbos@socrates.berkeley.edu; jeff.dasovich@enron.com; lfried@uclink.berkeley.edu; hcameron@uclink.berkeley.edu; whederman@columbiaenergygroup.com Subject: GSPP Electricity Policy Summit meeting minutes Coordinating committee, Here are my notes from the meeting. The address list above is the current group so we can continue by e-mail by replying to this group until people are ready for another call. I don't think the Dean needs to hear all of the back and forth. Lee Friedman has kindly agreed to advise and participate. Open questions: -do we want to join with the business school for this event? -should we push the date back? -what is your top 5 list of speakers? -any comments on what we agreed on or revisions to the minutes? This is really moving! Thanks everyone. Rob <<Electricity policy summit minutes 082200.doc>> Rob Gramlich PJM Market Monitoring Unit (610) 666-4291 gramlr@pjm.com