9 Oct 2000, 10:20 UTC
NRG AFFILIATES ASK FERC TO RULE ON DISPUTED STATION POWER ISSUES AFFECTING DIVESTED GENERATION ASSETS
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Mon, 9 Oct 2000 03:20:00 -0700 (PDT)
NRG AFFILIATES ASK FERC TO RULE ON DISPUTED STATION POWER ISSUES AFFECTING DIVESTED GENERATION ASSETS 10/04/2000 Foster Electric Report Page 13 (c) Copyright 2000, Foster Associates, Inc. In a renewal of a controversy that has arisen several times in the past with respect to the issue of station power, three NRG affiliates that purchased electric generation facilities from Niagara Mohawk Corp. in 1999 -- Dunkirk Power LLC, Huntley Power LLC and Oswego Harbor LLC (EL00-113) -- petitioned FERC on 9/22/00 to declare that NRG's electric generation facilities have the right (and have had this right since their purchase from Niagara Mohawk) to treat station power as net/negative generation. The petitioners also asked FERC to confirm they have the option of obtaining station power from the grid at wholesale, regardless of whether the generation facility is running at that specific time, together with the ability to net the station power from the facility's sales to the wholesale energy market. Further, the petition wants the Commission to declare that Niagara Mohawk cannot require any of NRG's generation facilities to obtain station power under a retail tariff, or resort to state law self-help procedures to bypass the Commission's jurisdiction, disconnect or terminate station power, thereby shutting down the facilities. Finally, pending resolution of the instant petition, the NRG entities urged FERC to issue an interim order preventing Niagara Mohawk from disconnecting or terminating station power for any NRG generation facility. If station power service were terminated, the petition noted, the three NRG entities would be unable to supply their total capacity of 3,060 MW to the New York ISO control area. The petition was prompted by Niagara Mohawk's commencement of billing in late 1999 and early 2000 for station power under its retail tariff for the three NRG facilities, NRG questioned the bills since divested generation assets are not subject to retail tariff rates under Commission precedent. While Niagara Mohawk admitted that its retained generation facilities are still allowed to treat station power as negative generation to be netted against output, it responded to NRG's questions by sending disconnection notices to the NRG facilities. Historically, the NRG petition stressed, vertically integrated facilities (including Niagara Mohawk) have treated -- and still treat -- station power as net/negative generation. Franchise utilities have not charged themselves for station power service under their retail tariffs nor have they used such tariffs to charge other utilities with generation facilities in their retail service territory. "Even today, these same utilities continue to treat station power as net/negative generation for their own and other favored generation facilities," said the filing. "At the same time, these utilities are trying to unilaterally impose retail tariffs and rates on station power service for their divested generation. But these divested generation assets are the exact same facilities for which the utilities have historically treated station power as net/negative generation." As evidenced by the historical practice of netting station power, the NRG entities first cited a 1972 start-up agreement between Central Hudson, Consolidated Edison of New York and Niagara Mohawk (joint owners of the Roseton generating facility in Central Hudson's exclusive retail service area) providing that start-up power (a component of station power) obtained from Central Hudson should be netted against output before net generation was allocated among them. Second, the New York Power Pool Agreement (approved by FERC in 1991) similarly allowed the netting of station power for members with generation facilities in the exclusive retail service territories of other members. Third, transition energy sales agreements between Con Edison and NRG (concerning NRG's recent purchase of two divested generation facilities from Con Edison) explicitly authorized the treatment of station power as net/negative generation. These assignments were accepted by the Commission as part of the process to obtain approval for the divestiture of jurisdictional assets. In the PJM market, the petition noted (1) a recent filing by PJM Interconnection L.L.C. (ER00-3513) revising its open-access transmission tariff (OATT) and Operating Agreement to make clear that the historical practice of netting station power service against gross generation should continue even after the utilities divested most of their generation; and (2) recent interconnection agreements filed by Conectiv, in conjunction with a request seeking FERC approval to divest jurisdictional assets to affiliates of NRG, expressly treating station power as negative generation. Finally, the NRG petition observed, the Commission has approved market rules of the New England ISO recognizing that market participants have the option of netting station power. Thus, the NRG entities concluded, the Commission-approved arrangements and historical practices in New York, PJM and New England all show that station power has been and continues to be treated as net/negative generation. "These arrangements also demonstrate that utilities such as Niagara Mohawk and Con Edison -- the same utilities that are now trying to impose retail tariffs on their divested generation --benefitted from prior netting arrangements right up until the time these assets were divested. These same utilities are currently allowing their own retained and other favored generation to net at the same time they are trying to force the divested generation to pay for such station power under retail tariffs." Moreover, the petition added, the historical practice of netting is consistent with the Commission's repeated statement that "load is not served at a generating unit" through transmission or interconnection assets. The petition requested that FERC confirm its prior rulings and declare that NRG's generation facilities have the right and option to treat station power as negative generation to be netted against gross generation. This declaration would recognize that the historical practice of netting station power is still the most efficient means of ensuring that all generators have equal access to essential station power in a market-based system. In other words, "nothing in a competitive market suddenly transforms station power into a retail event." By declaring that station power as negative generation is a scheduled service available under the Commission's pro forma tariff, the petition contended, the Commission will further the public's interest in a competitive energy market and, simultaneously, "preempt the type of discriminatory and anti-competitive conduct that necessitated this petition in the first place," namely, efforts by utilities such as Niagara Mohawk to impose retail tariff rates on station power service to divested assets while still allowing their own retained generation facilities (and other favored facilities) to net station power. Including station power service in pro forma tariffs would not only provide generators with a service necessary to operation of their interconnected facility but would also ensure availability of the service to all generators on fair and nondiscriminatory terms, the petition added. Furthermore, the NRG entities said the Commission has and should exercise jurisdiction over station power issues. Since generating facilities cannot be operated without station power, the petition explained, the provision of station power "affects or relates to" the generator's ability to produce and sell electric power in wholesale markets. Thus, the provision of station power is "an integral and essential part" of the interconnection and operation of that generator. "The Commission's jurisdiction therefore easily extends to the provision of station power and supports the issuance of a declaratory order ensuring that station power is made available to all generators on efficient, nondiscriminatory terms as part of a pro forma tariff." Based on the above discussion, the petition requested FERC to issue an order declaring that Niagara Mohawk cannot impose its unbundled retail tariff on NRG's generation facilities. However, the petition made clear, the requested declaration -- like the OATT revisions proposed recently by PJM -- would not prohibit any generator form voluntarily agreeing to take station power under a retail tariff. "It is the option to take station power as a scheduled service under the pro form tariff that is important. By mandating this choice, the Commission will ensure that utilities cannot take advantage of a generator's need for station power." The Commission should further declare, given its exclusive jurisdiction over the wholesale energy market, that Niagara Mohawk cannot use state law self-help remedies such as disconnection or termination of station power to force payment from a wholesale generator. Any attempt to rely on state law procedures is clearly preempted by the Commission's exclusive jurisdiction, NRG said. Finally, since both NRG and the public will suffer irreparable harm if Niagara Mohawk is allowed to terminate station power service and shut down the generation facilities in question, the Commission should issue an interim order prohibiting Niagara Mohawk from terminating station power service until these proceedings have been completed.