18 Jun 2001, 17:33 UTC
FW: FW: Davis Eases Power Plant Pollution Rules
- From
- Alan Comnes alan.comnes@enron.com
- To
- Tom Alonso, Ray Alvarez, Robert Badeer, Tim Belden, Christopher F Calger, Jeff Dasovich, michael.driscoll@enron.com, Mark Fischer, Chris H Foster, Mark Guzman, Steve C Hall, Tim Heizenrader
- Date
- Mon, 18 Jun 2001 10:33:00 -0700 (PDT)
Here is information on the ability of CA generators to run in excess of their orginal offset NOx quantities. Alan Comnes
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From: Schoen, Mary
Sent: Monday, June 18, 2001 3:23 PM
To: Comnes, Alan
Cc: Guerrero, Janel
Subject: Re: FW: Davis Eases Power Plant Pollution Rules
The following is more explanation about the recent Executive Order (EO)
signed by the Governor of California on June 11, 2001. In order to avoid
future blackouts, Governor Gray Davis is waiving limits on hours of operation
and the associated emissions for natural gas-fired peaker units if they
adhere to certain conditions. He is requesting local air districts to allow
natural gas-fired peaker power plants to operate in excess of their hourly,
daily, quarterly and/or annual emission limitations if they do the following:
1. Agree to sell power to the California Department of Water Resources or to
a utility located in California
2. To serve an operating utility,s own load
3. Agree to sell to another California-based utility
The gas-fired peaker units must also pay a mitigation fee to the local air
districts of $7.50 per pound of oxides of nitrogen (NOx) and $1.10 per pound
of carbon monoxide (CO) emitted. (The Governor set this number - it is,
however, the same amount the South Coast AQMD is charging for NOx offsets in
the modifications it made to the RECLAIM program.) These mitigation fees will
be used to clean up or retire other sources of pollution in the same air
basin. The Governor is ordering the California Air Resources Board to work
with the Environmental Protection Agency to ensure that power plants willing
to operate under this order obtain the necessary approvals.
As you know, there are many peaking plants that are close to exhausting their
allowable operating hours. Once these facilities exhaust the amount of
allowable hours they would have to either shut down the units or negotiate an
agreement with the local air agency to continue to operate. With the
exception of Mirant Potrero in San Francisco and Reliant Energy Mandalay in
Ventura County, no facilities have negotiated such agreements. The EO issued
by the Governor gives the peaker facilities a blanket approval to operate
beyond the restrictions. The Governor believes that waiving of the
requirements will also minimize reliance on backup diesel-fired generators,
which have even higher emissions than the natural gas peakers. In my
previous discussions with the US EPA Region 9, they did say they were willing
to work with the state to provide variances to power plants' operating
limits. However, in the two instances mentioned above, the EPA required the
plants to agree to install pollution control equipment at a specific future
date. This aspect of the agreement was critical to EPA, because the
increased emissions from the peakers with increased hours are now significant
enough (major source status) to trigger New Source Review which requires
installation of Best Available Control Technology (BACT). The EO by the
Governor makes no mention of future controls.
According to municipal utilities and other generators, the Governor's action
could provide up to 1,200 Megawatts of additional power this summer by
expanding the number of hours of operation at natural gas-fired plants. The
EO will expire on October 31, 2001, unless revoked, modified or extended by
further executive order. The air director of the Ventura air board has
already sent comments opposing this order due to its negative air impacts.
Environmentalists will also no doubt object. The EPA has not yet responded.
Despite the potential negative environmental effects, the political pressure
will be strong to let these plants operate. I will keep my ears open for
additional developments on this matter, please let me know if you have any
questions.
From: Alan Comnes/ENRON@enronXgate on 06/12/2001 11:57 AM
To: Mary Schoen/NA/Enron@Enron
cc:
Subject: FW: Davis Eases Power Plant Pollution Rules
Mary,
Any insight into this latest change would be appreciated by the traders. Is
this order any different than the SCAQMD $7.50/ton program already
implemented? Will EPA allow that state to do this?
Thanks,
Alan Comnes
-----Original Message-----
From: Comnes, Alan
Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2001 9:55 AM
To: Alonso, Tom; Alvarez, Ray; Badeer, Robert; Belden, Tim; Calger,
Christopher F.; Dasovich, Jeff; Driscoll, Michael M.; Fischer, Mark; Foster,
Chris H.; Guzman, Mark; Hall, Steve C.; Heizenrader, Timothy; Kaufman, Paul;
Mainzer, Elliot; Mallory, Chris; Mara, Susan; Motley, Matt; Perrino, Dave;
Platter, Phillip; Richter, Jeff; Scholtes, Diana; Swain, Steve; Swerzbin,
Mike; Williams III, Bill; Wolfe, Greg
Subject: Davis Eases Power Plant Pollution Rules
Tuesday, June 12, 2001
Davis Eases Power Plant Pollution Rules
Electricity: Order will allow more production from heavily polluting
'peaker' facilities.
By DAN MORAIN, Times Staff Writer
SACRAMENTO--Gov. Gray Davis agreed Monday to lift air emission limits on
heavily polluting power plants and allow them to run at capacity this summer
as long as the electricity they produce is sold in the state.
State officials said the plants must be pressed into use to avoid
blackouts.
Davis' executive order lets the generators build the cost of air
pollution fines into the price the state pays for electricity produced by
natural gas-fired power plants, said Catherine Witherspoon of the California
Air Resources Board.
Municipal utility districts--including the Los Angeles Department of
Water and Power--and independent power companies could supply as much as
1,200 megawatts from so-called peaker plants, facilities that generally are
permitted to operate for only a few hundred hours a year because they pollute
so heavily. That is enough power for more than 1 million homes.
Other gas-fired power plants that have been shut down because of air
pollution restrictions also could be started up as a result of the order.
In a news conference Monday, state officials said the order will have
the effect of lowering air pollution by limiting the use of far dirtier
diesel generators, which industry could use if power supplies are threatened.
"If we don't get every last megawatt we can [from natural gas-fired
plants]," said Witherspoon of the air board, "we will see people turning to
diesel more frequently."
Added Kellan Fluckiger, a top energy advisor to Davis: "If you don't run
these, you're either going to have outages or you're going to run something
dirtier."
Fluckiger said the order expands "the number of hours these things can
run and the amount of energy they can produce."
New natural gas-fired power plants emit about half a pound per
megawatt-hour of operation of ozone-producing pollutants. The plants affected
by the order emit between two and five pounds of oxides of nitrogen per
megawatt-hour.
If the plants are pressed into operation for 200,000 megawatt-hours this
summer, there will be between 400,000 and 1 million additional pounds of
oxides of nitrogen emitted into the air.
The state probably will end up paying the fees associated with the extra
pollution through higher electricity prices. The fees amount to $7.50 per
pound of oxides of nitrogen--or $7.5 million if the plants operate for
200,000 hours--and $1.10 per pound of carbon monoxide emissions. The money
would be used to reduce air pollution from other sources.
"Under this order, dirty power plants can run as long as they want and
pollute as much as they want so long as they pay into a fund," said Gail
Ruderman Feuer, senior attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council.
"Our concern is that there's no guarantee that the fund will result in
emission reductions any time soon."
A Ventura County air pollution control official said that running one
peaking power plant operated by Reliant Energy for one hour is the equivalent
of adding 20,000 new cars to Ventura County highways for an hour. Reliant
Energy could not be reached for comment Monday night.
"To the extent that they run when not needed for an emergency, it's
going to put more air pollution into Ventura County skies and it's going to
make our air dirtier," said Dick Baldwin, air pollution control officer for
Ventura County.
Los Angeles DWP Director David Wiggs hailed the order, saying it was
needed so the city can sell the state as much as 1,000 megawatts of power
this summer.
"This was the issue we had to have solved or we could not offer any of
our excess capacity to the state," Wiggs said.
He added, however, that the city and state have not yet agreed on a
price for the power. Wiggs said the city is "negotiating to get our cost as
low as we can legally charge" so that customers of the city utility district
are not subsidizing consumers in the rest of the state. Municipal utility
districts elsewhere in the state also are expected to benefit from the order.
Though the order was aimed at spurring municipal utilities to sell power
to the state, it also applies to independent power producers such as Reliant
Energy of Houston and Duke of North Carolina--both of which have called on
Davis to ease air pollution restrictions on their old natural gas-fired
facilities.
"This puts more money in the Texans' pockets and more air pollution in
Ventura County residents' lungs," said Baldwin of Ventura County.
Doug Allard, a Santa Barbara County air pollution control officer, also
said it seems as if the governor is giving private power generators much of
what they had sought.
"We have serious concerns about the order," said Feuer of the Natural
Resources Defense Council. "It's taking the discretion away from local air
districts to regulate power plants in their region."
* * *
Times staff writer Nancy Vogel contributed to this story.
RELATED STORY
Utility: Edison plans to raise $1 billion in debt restructuring. C1
Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times