5 Jul 2001, 16:31 UTC
CMTA Legislative Weekly - 07/05/01
- From
- Loretta Macktal lmacktal@cmta.net
- Date
- Thu, 5 Jul 2001 09:31:00 -0700 (PDT)
Legislative Weekly July 5, 2001 Issue 27, Volume 3 A weekly publication from the California Manufacturers & Technology Association detailing legislative and regulatory developments in Sacramento A DEDICATED REVENUE STREAM Department of Water Resources Wants Money to Flow Their Way Six months ago Department of Water Resources took over power purchasing responsibility from the nearly insolvent investor-owned utilities. The general fund was first tapped, then a short-term loan allowed the purchasing to continue.? Now the state needs to issue $13.4 billion in bonds authorized in SBX1 31 (Burton D-San Francisco), to be paid back by utility ratepayers for more than a decade. On July 12 the CPUC must decide how much of utility rates should be siphoned off to pay off the bonds and the ongoing costs of power being purchased on the spot market and under short and long term power contracts signed by DWR. This &dedicated revenue stream8 (DRS) will be based on the latest analysis by utility and administration financial experts. The big question is whether current rates are high enough to cover all utility generation costs (nuclear, qualifying facilities, hydro, etc.), DWR power costs, and all the other elements of rates (public purpose charges, transmission and distribution, etc.).? Many assumptions about the spot market, the effects of the FERC price mitigation order and the level of customer demand enter into the calculation of the DRS.? Wholesale spot prices have recently dropped, but there still could be a shortfall that would need to be made up in higher rates or with more borrowing to push off repayment to the future. In related news, last week the CPUC nearly ordered the suspension of direct access in order to ensure that customers would not be able to leave utility service and thus escape the payment of bond and DWR power costs.? Customer groups were able to persuade regulators to put off the decision pending legislation that could clarify a direct access customer's obligation to pay a fair share of these costs.? To that end, ABX2 10 (Hertzberg D-Van Nuys) is being amended to make the bonds secured by the DRS rather than DWR contracts, thus creating more regulatory flexibility regarding the terms of direct access, and SBX2 27 (Bowen D-Marina del Rey) and ABX2 42 (Kelley R-Idyllwild) are the competing vehicles for how exit fees should be calculated. ? LOCKYER CONVENES NEW GRAND JURY ON ALLEGED PRICE GOUGING California Attorney General Bill Lockyer appointed 19 new members to a Sacramento County Grand Jury this week to consider the growing volume of evidence from both sides on the continuing investigations of alleged price gouging by power generators. The Grand Jury to be convened later this week will be issuing subpoenas for testimony and documents and is expected to be impaneled for several months. In a related development, Lt. Governor Cruz Bustamante and Assemblywoman Barbara Matthews reportedly will introduce two new &whistleblowers8 at the state capitol on Thursday from a San Diego power plant. Recent testimony from three employees before a legislative committee investigating charges of wrongdoing on the part of a San Diego power plant claimed their employer, Duke Energy, manipulated the supply of electricity from the plant to increase the company's profits. In response, generators have produced documents showing they were simply following the direction from the State Independent System Operator to modify their electricity output. ? WINDFALL PROFITS TAX LEGISLATION TO BE CONSIDERED SBX2 1 (Soto D-Pomona) would impose a &windfall profits8 tax on electrical power generators and is scheduled for hearing on Monday, July 9th in the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee. CMTA opposes the bill. SBX2 1 pertains to all types of electricity generation including co-generation produced and sold by manufacturers and generation by other qualified facilities such as bio-mass and solar plants.? It causes the &excess profit8 to be confiscated by the state from a middleman in the supply chain: a 100% tax.? This revenue is then distributed to individual taxpayers but not to business taxpayers (who paid the middleman the excess in the first place). The bill is a state-imposed price cap.? Excess profit is defined as anything exceeding a cost-based rate established by the PUC on a plant-by-plant basis.?? If enacted, SBX2 1 would have almost no effect on merchant generators, as most of them have entered into contracts with the state that pass on the cost of any increased taxes to the state.? Furthermore, this legislation would violate federal law which preempts state law in this area.? In accordance with the 1979 federal law, the PUC has set the price at which co-generators and other QFs can sell their energy.? It is the cost that the utility would have charged had it performed the sale. This formula was devised to encourage manufacturers to build on-site generation and sell excess power for public use.? This formula did not guarantee a profit for such generators but gave them an incentive to build generation facilities and operate efficiently.? Changing the formula would result in manufacturers refusing to build more generation facilities and increased litigation costs until the courts wipe away SBX2 1 (Soto). ? LIABILITY FOR ELECTRICAL NON-GENERATION CMTA strongly opposed ABX2 51 (Reyes D-Fresno) which would make any retail or wholesale operator of an electric generation facility strictly liable for any damages proximately caused by that generator's reduction or discontinuance of service for economic reasons. Neither negligence nor intent must be proven in order to establish strict liability.? Under this legislation, a generator could be held strictly liable for damages that resulted if electricity supplies were curtailed when the generator was temporarily shut down to perform routine maintenance, unscheduled maintenance or due to other external business factors (i.e. the high cost of fuel).? ABX2 51 also would make it difficult for a generator to permanently close a facility, even if the facility was not operating profitably. Generators are only one component of many that work together to provide reliable electricity supplies throughout the State.? However, ABX2 51 would result in generators shouldering the responsibility for all damages, liability and responsibility for electricity shortages. Amendments were taken to remove co-generation from the bill.? However, CMTA will continue to oppose the measure on the principal that imposing strict liability on generators will only discourage generators from siting new facilities and selling their electricity within the State. The measure passed from the Assembly Judiciary Committee on July 2 and next will be heard in the Assembly Energy Costs and Availability Committee. ? STREAMLINING THE PIPELINE PERMITTING PROCESS The CMTA is supporting ABX2 47 (Diaz D-San Jose) which would increase the financial threshold necessary to obtain a Public Utilities Commission (PUC) Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN) from $50 million to $100 million.? Increasing this threshold will allow for expedited construction of new natural gas pipelines and will help to shore up the infrastructure needed to increase the State's natural gas capacity. The measure also streamlines the permitting process for new pipeline construction, requiring the PUC to act on a permit request within 12 months of receiving a completed application.? Failure to act on the permit would result in the automatic issuance of a CPCN. Natural gas is a necessary component of many CMTA members, industrial and manufacturing operations.? Given the State's heavy reliance on imported natural gas, CMTA supports expediting the construction of new pipelines to ensure that a sufficient supply of this critical fuel is available for use. ? REPORTING TO THE EOB MAY OPEN RECORDS FOR PUBLIC REVIEW A measure that allows the Energy Oversight Board (EOB) to inspect and make public all of a facility's records, data, accounts, books or documents related to reliability, availability, and the cost of electric service was heard in the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee on June 27. CMTA testified in opposition to ABX2 28 (Migden D-San Francisco) which substantially expands the authority of the Independent System Operator (ISO) to adopt operating and availability standards for electricity generation and transmission. ABX2 28 also would allow the ISO to regulate a facility's co-generation scheduling and maintenance practices, which would have the practical effect of giving the ISO regulatory authority over a business, primary industrial operations. Since many of the co-generation facilities do not keep separate records for the electricity component of their facilities, this requirement could open up much of the facility's private operational records for their competitors, and public review. Committee members expressed concern regarding the effect of expanding the authority of the Energy Oversight Board, how the measure affects the handling of documents subject to the Public Records Act, and clarification regarding the purpose for which documents would be used. The measure was subject to testimony and discussion, however a vote was not taken. The measure will again be heard on July 10. ? NEW FISHING LIMITS FOR REGIONAL WATER BOARDS In late May, Assemblymember Fran Pavley,s (D-Agoura Hills) AB 1664, which makes various changes to state and regional water board penalty authority, was amended on the Assembly Floor to remove language that would have created major new penalty exposures for manufacturers.? Shortly thereafter, questions surfaced concerning a subtle change to a section of the water code that grants authority to the regional boards to issue orders for investigation of waste discharges.? The concern pertains to the ability of the regional boards to issue investigation orders to parties &suspected of having discharged8 waste at some point in the past.? Orders issued under these circumstances typically involve contentious property access issues and costly monitoring requirements.? This section of the code is already used liberally by the regional boards and the change in AB 1664 arguably invites more orders that lack a clear nexus between the discharger,s past activities and the suspected discharge. AB 1664 was amended earlier this week in Senate Environmental Quality Committee to address this issue.? The bill's sponsor, the State Water Resources Control Board, and Assemblymember Pavley agreed to take language requiring that any new investigation order be accompanied by a written statement identifying the evidence upon which the order is based.? This clarification applies to all circumstances under which investigation orders are issued and should help to ensure that regional boards do not abuse this authority. ? CAL-OSH STANDARDS BOARD TO CONSIDER ERGONOMIC RULE On the agenda for the July 19, 2001 meeting in San Diego, the California Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board (Standards Board) will consider a petition from organized labor to adopt the recently overturned federal Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) ergonomic rule as a state rule for California.? If adopted, it would replace California's repetitive motion standard (Title 8, CCR 5110). Employers opposed the federal rule because most employers believed it was based on dubious science that could not accurately identify the cause of repetitive motion injuries attributable to work.? The federal rule contained restrictions that would prohibit doctors from providing information on non-occupational causation of injury that would interfere with an employer's ability to determine the compensability of a claim under California workers, compensation law &arising out of and in the course of employment8.? Other onerous provisions include:? Requiring employers to pay work restrictions benefits that require a 90% or 100% replacement rate of an injured worker's gross pay; and the continuation of employer provided fringe benefits for up to 3 months in the case of a musculoskeletal disorder related to work.? The federal rule would have carved out a completely different standard for musculoskeletal disorders (injuries due to repetitive motion) with remedies substantially more costly than other injuries under the workers, compensation system. CMTA is requesting that members send letters to the Standards Board or attend the meeting to urge board members to reject the petition.? Write to:? John MacLeod, Executive Officer, Cal-OSH Standards Board, 2520 Venture Oaks Way, Suite 350, Sacramento, CA 95833.? If you plan to attend the meeting, the address is 1350 Front Street, State Building Auditorium, San Diego, California.? Please call Willie Washington at (916) 441 5420 if you have questions. ? ? www.cmta.net California Manufacturers & Technology Association 980 9th Street, Suite 2200 Sacramento, CA? 95814 (916) 441-5420 phone (916) 447-9401 fax ?