25 May 2000, 09:16 UTC
Re: Choice of Law for Master Firm Gas Purchase/Sale Agreement with BC Gas Utility Ltd.
- From
- Mark Taylor mark.taylor@enron.com
- To
- Mark Powell
- Date
- Thu, 25 May 2000 02:16:00 -0700 (PDT)
Mark -
You might consider treating the choice of law and submission to jurisdiction
as two separate issues. For example, if BC law is not objectionable, we
could choose that law to apply but not consent to the jurisdiction of any
particular court. The most likely outcome (at least in many US states) would
be that we would end up in a BC court if we had to sue them but unless we
have significant contacts with BC (e.g. an office there) they would have to
sue us in Alberta.
Mark Taylor
Mark Powell\CAL\ECT
Sent by: Mark Powell
05/24/2000 07:27 PM
To: Alan Aronowitz/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark E Haedicke/HOU/ECT@ECT, Jeffrey T
Hodge/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT
cc: Grant Oh/CAL/ECT@ECT
Subject: Choice of Law for Master Firm Gas Purchase/Sale Agreement with BC
Gas Utility Ltd.
To: The Legal Trading Committee
Enron Canada Corp. ("Enron Canada") is in the process of negotiating a Master
Firm Gas Purchase/Sale Agreement (the "Master") with BC Gas Utility Ltd. ("BC
Gas"). In this regard, we have recently received a request from BC Gas to
amend the "applicable law" of the Master from Alberta to British Columbia
such that subsection 17.12 of the Master would read as follows:
"This Agreement shall be governed by and construed, enforced, and performed
in accordance with the laws of the Province of British Columbia, without
regard to principles of conflicts of law, and each Party hereby submits to
the non-exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of British Columbia."
BC Gas has also asked that the applicable law for the guarantee of Enron
Corp. be governed by the laws of British Columbia.
While I am fairly sure that we will be able to persuade BC Gas to accept the
State of Texas as the appropriate law for the Enron Corp. guarantee, it seems
unlikely (because the counterparty is a British Columbia utility that
operates primarily in British Columbia) that BC Gas will accept any
jurisdiction other than British Columbia with respect to the Master.
Although I have not been called to the bar in British Columbia and there may
be some quirks and minor differences between the jurisdictions, it is my
understanding that the commercial law of British Columbia is generally not
much different from that of Alberta. Nevertheless, I am seeking your
comments and consent to such an amendment to the Master.
Should you have any questions or require additional information, please give
me a call at (403) 974-6708. Thank you for your assistance with this matter.
Yours truly,
Mark Powell