3 Jul 2001, 17:50 UTC
RE: Status report on document identification at Enron Corp. offic es i n San Francisco
- From
- Molland, Michael E." @ENRON mmolland@brobeck.com
- Date
- Tue, 3 Jul 2001 10:50:03 -0700 (PDT)
Bob: I missed you by phone this morning, and will call again when you return this afternoon.We have stopped plans to copy the EES contracts with customers for power, pending further discussions with you. Here are the considerations that seem relevant: . Both the AG and Dunn subpoenas request these contracts and supporting documents. They are probably the only significant amount of EES documents in California that are responsive to the Dunn subpoena. . They are currently kept in several places in the San Ramon office, Costa Mesa and Long Beach. If we plan to gather them for a production in or around Sacramento soon we should consider making copies of the Southern California contracts so they are available for review and production in Northern California. The extent of the Southern California contract documents is about four or five boxes. San Ramon probably has about ten. We could more easily hold off on the copying in San Ramon since it is close both to our offices and Sacramento. . It is unlikely we can shift copying costs for these documents to Dunn's committee or the AG. We could produce them in a central location, but I doubt we can force them to go to several locations in the state to review documents that fall in this category.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From: Robert.C.Williams@enron.com [mailto:Robert.C.Williams@enron.com]
Sent: Tuesday, July 03, 2001 7:13 AM
To: MMolland@brobeck.com; Richard.B.Sanders@enron.com;
sbishop@gibbs-bruns.com; mlk@pkns.com; mtuohey@velaw.com;
GFergus@brobeck.com
Cc: ADSmith@brobeck.com; PMeringolo@brobeck.com
Subject: RE: Status report on document identification at Enron Corp.
offices i n San Francisco
Michael, before we go to the expense of copying the EES contracts, I want
to see if Mike Kirby can convince the Committee that those contracts have
no relevance to its investigation, which in fact they don't. Also, why
should Enron bear the costs of this massive document production. The
federal courts (at least in Houston) require the party seeking discovery to
pay the cost. If we conclude that we have to pay for this, maybe we should
make the contracts available in a room for their review. Please call me.
Thanks.
-----Original Message-----
From: "Molland, Michael E." <MMolland@brobeck.com>@ENRON
[mailto:IMCEANOTES-+22Molland+2C+20Michael+20E+2E+22+20+3CMMolland+40brobeck
+2Ecom+3E+40ENRON@ENRON.com]
Sent: Tuesday, July 03, 2001 12:44 AM
To: Williams, Robert C.; Sanders, Richard B.;
'sbishop@gibbs-bruns.com'; 'mlk@pkns.com';
'mtuohey@velaw.com'; Fergus, Gary S.
Cc: Smith, Amanda D.; Meringolo, Peter
Subject: Status report on document identification at Enron Corp.
offices i n San Francisco
Amanda Smith, Peter Meringolo, and I met with officers and
administrators at the San Francisco offices of Enron Corp. this morning
and
identified documents responsive to the Dunn committee subpoena. Amanda
and
Peter then collected and reviewed potentially responsive documents in
the
afternoon. They will continue to do so, with the assistance of two
paralegals, tomorrow. Assuming we do not produce documents relating to
the
development and siting of generation facilities ( which comprise the
lion's
chair of the documents in San Francisco) we estimate there are about ten
boxes of responsive hard copy documents in the office. However, we have
not
yet reviewed any electronic documents. The following summarizes these
discussions and the status of document identification:
Most of the documents in the SF office correspond to one of the
three major functions of the office. The predominant operation is the
development of power generation facilities in the Western United States
under the supervision of Dave Parquet. Second, the office markets
wholesale
power to municipal utilities and other customers under the direction of
Mike
McDonald. Both these operations are done by Enron North American and
both
Parquay and McDonald are vice presidents of Enron North America.
McDonald
works closely with EPMI in Portland. The final significant function of
the
office consists of legislative and regulatory affairs, which is part of
Enron Corp and managed by Sue Mara.
We reviewed many of the documents within the custody of persons
working under the management of Parquet and Mara. McDonald is on
vacation
until June 11 and has not returned phone calls to his home message
machine.
Given his close relationship to EPMI in Portland we need to reach him
soon
to interview him on the subject. He is said to have potentially
sensitive
pricing and financial information relating to wholesale power on his
hard
drive. The following summarizes our review of the documents in the
Parquet
and Mara supervised operations.
Mara: Many documents may be privileged. Non-privileged documents do
not appear especially sensitive- examples are reports of trade
association
meetings and PUC and other regulatory proceedings.
Parquet: Parquet was on the board of ISO. He has about two boxes of
responsive ISO information. Most appear non sensitive, but may require
notice to ISO prior to production.. There is also some bid information
regarding an Enron offer to buy a PG and E generating facility later
purchased by Mirant. These documents are also non-sensitive. Parquet has
financial documents, including the allocation of profit and loss to
certain
Enron subsidiaries.
However, there are tens (50 to 100) of boxes of documents relating
to power plants Enron has or is planning to develop in the Western
United
States. Generally, these type of documents do not appear called for in
the
subpoena. However, embedded within these development plans are documents
that are responsive to other categories of the subpoena and sensitive-
such
as pricing curves, information about future contracts, and forecasts of
supply and demand for power. Parquay says these are competitively
sensitive
documents. It would take several days to review these documents.
Further,
many contain third party information subject to confidentiality
agreements
with such third parties. If we produce them we would need to notify
these
third parties soon. I suggest we not produce these documents but do so
openly by disclosing to Drivon that we are treating documents relating
to
siting of power plants not operated by Enron as non-responsive.
McDonald: This operating unit has few hard copy documents. Most
sensitive information is said to be on McDonald's hard drive, including
financial information that reportedly shows how much money Enron made in
California in the past year or two by selling wholesale power. Someone
needs
to reach McDonald so we can ask him about it.
Document retention: The office manager says that a backup tape is
made of the server and the "H" drives on each computer every day. 20
days of
backup tapes are kept before they are overwritten. The backup tape from
every fourth Friday of each month is kept permanently. They believe
e-mail
is so preserved on this back up tapes, but say that only people in "
Houston" know for sure. We should find out. We asked the office manager
to
retain copies of all backup tapes going forward.
EES: The EES personnel in San Francisco have few responsive
documents. The Dunn subpoena asks for all of Enron's contracts for
retail
sale of power, which are also requested by the AG from EES. These
probably
total 20 or so boxes. We will ask the EES offices in San Ramon and Costa
Mesa offices, which house these contracts, to copy them and send them to
us
for our review. We will hold them until we make a decision whether to
produce them, either to the AG or Dunn.
PUC production: Enron previously produced about a half box of
documents to the PUC. Most are responsive and should be also produced to
Dunn.
I expect we will have completed at least a cursory review of the
responsive hard copy documents in San Francisco that do not pertain to
plant
construction and operation by tomorrow afternoon. We then need to review
the
documents on the hard drives of Parquay and McDonald, hopefully by
Thursday
afternoon. We will collect examples of the most sensitive documents we
find
tomorrow and send them Tuesday evening to Bob Williams for review .
=======================================================
This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and
may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized
review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not
the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and
destroy all copies of the original message.
To reply to our email administrator directly, send an email to
postmaster@brobeck.com
BROBECK PHLEGER & HARRISON LLP
http://www.brobeck.com
=======================================================
This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message.
To reply to our email administrator directly, send an email to postmaster@brobeck.com
BROBECK PHLEGER & HARRISON LLP
http://www.brobeck.com