28 Jun 2001, 18:48 UTC
RE: Discussion of document retention policy for EES
- From
- Robert C. Williams c..williams@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 28 Jun 2001 11:48:39 -0700 (PDT)
Proposed alternative email to those employees identified as involved in California:
Re: Data Retention
"Due to the various regulatory proceedings ongoing in California, please do not delete any email or electronic data that relate to the California market. Deletion of such data could subject both you and the Company to allegations of deliberate destruction of evidence, contempt of court, and civil and criminal penalties. To preserve such data please create a folder entitled "California Data" and move all emails and other data to that folder. Thank you for your cooperation."
Comments?
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: "Molland, Michael E." <MMolland@brobeck.com>@ENRON [mailto:IMCEANOTES-+22Molland+2C+20Michael+20E+2E+22+20+3CMMolland+40brobeck+2Ecom+3E+40ENRON@ENRON.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 27, 2001 8:02 PM To: Williams, Robert C. Cc: Sanders, Richard B.; 'mlk@pkns.com'; 'sbishop@gibbs-bruns.com'; 'mtuohey@velaw.com'; Fergus, Gary S. Subject: Discussion of document retention policy for EES Bob Williams, Andrew Edison, Michael Molland, Amanda Smith, and two IT professionals working with EES, Jon Eastlund and Pete van de Gohn, today discussed a going forward document retention policy for EES as a result of the California AG's subpoena. This is a summary of our discussion. * Agreement with AG with respect to EPMI-Portland: I (per my conversation with Gary Fergus) confirmed that the document retention policy that was negotiated in December, 2000 with the AG with respect to EPMI in Portland is as follows: All employees are instructed not to delete any e-mail for 24 hours. Each 24 hours a backup "snapshot" of the entire e-mail server in Portland is taken. After 24 hours, employees may delete e-mail. This policy has been in place since mid-December and back-up tapes should exist for e-mail for each day from mid-December through the present. * Description of E-mail server organization within EES: All EES employees are on one of two e-mail systems: (1) the exchange server/Legacy system or (2) Lotus Notes. The exchange/Legacy system is run off of three servers located in San Ramon, California, Costa Mesa, California, and Phoenix, Arizona. The Lotus Notes server is in Houston. The majority of EES personnel in California probably are on the exchange/Legacy server, but there is no way of knowing who is which server without individually checking. EES personnel who were originally hired in California probably use the Legacy system. Generally, the only in-California personnel who use the Lotus Notes system are those who were originally hired by EES to work outside of California. Virtually all EES employees outside California use the Lotus Notes system. * Current e-mail retention of Legacy system: The customary practice is to keep daily back up tapes, which are over written weekly, as well as one weekly snapshot of the system, which is overwritten after 30 days. As of last week, the exchange/Legacy server is being preserved as follows: the daily and weekly tapes are no longer being overwritten and are being preserved by Jon Eastlund. (Jon is checking with his subordinate in Costa Mesa to confirm that this is also being done in Costa Mesa). Jon reports that the earliest weekly back up tape which is still preserved dates from May 25th. He is keeping that tape in San Ramon until it can be picked up by Brobeck. * Retention of e-mail of Lotus Notes System: The Lotus Notes server is backed up every day, but the back tapes are erased after seven days and this policy is continuing. As of several weeks ago (when B. Williams first sent out notification to Pete Van de Gohn and the IT staff in Houston) the Lotus Notes server is being preserved as follows: the auto purge and the delete functions on the computers of certain key personnel have been disabled for certain EES personnel(e.g. Sunde and Benevides). In addition, more recently, the auto purge function was disabled on the computers of additional personnel (the Golden Bear team) who use the system. As of today, Pete will disable the delete function for those additional personnel as well. * Going forward, we discussed several different policies that EES might institute. First, we discussed the idea of instituting a policy like that in place at EPMI in Portland (i.e. preserving the daily back up tapes that are already being made- but overwritten after a week or so-in the ordinary course of business). This policy will create a significant amount of information that will be difficult and expensive to search if it is requested. However, it is apparently consistent with the policy in place at EPMI- Portland and is possible to do on both e-mail systems. Second, as an alternative to preserving backup tapes we discussed disabling the delete function on the computers of key personnel. This is now being done for the Lotus Notes system. However we understand that the exchange/Legacy system may not have an auto purge function. Jon will check whether the delete disabling function can be accomplished on the exchange/Legacy system and report back. This second alternative preserves e-mail that will be relatively easy to search for production. However, it may be difficult to implement for California personal on the legacy e-mail system. Third, we discussed instructing key EES personnel at issue to move all potentially responsive e-mails into folders on the system which may they be protected, reproduced and reviewed.This would be the least burdensome potentially leaves us open to the "fox is guarding the henhouse" argument by the AG. * Data Servers:We discussed data servers briefly. All personnel are on different servers for their word documents and spread sheets. This system has no autopurge function. However, the only way that a document can be deleted is if a user actually deliberately deletes it from the system. Accordingly, there seems less need to initiate further backup of this server. * Finally, we agreed EES lawyers should send e-mails to all key EES personnel confirming our earlier instruction to them that they not delete e-mail documents or messages. A draft e-mail on this subject follows: This e-mail confirms that EES has instituted an interim document retention policy as a result of the investigation commenced by the California Attorney General. Until further notice, please do not delete any non-personal e-mail from your inbox or any documents from the data servers. In lieu of deleting any of your e-mail please transfer it to a folder in your e-mail system for storage. If you need instructions on how to do this please call ---------. ======================================================= This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. To reply to our email administrator directly, send an email to postmaster@brobeck.com BROBECK PHLEGER & HARRISON LLP http://www.brobeck.com