7 Feb 2000, 09:34 UTC
Re: NSPS Calculation for Saturn 1200 -Reply
- From
- Rick Loveless rick.loveless@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 7 Feb 2000 01:34:00 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Rick Loveless/ET&S/Enron on 02/07/2000
09:23 AM ---------------------------
Kenneth Young
02/04/2000 04:06 PM
To: Rick Loveless/ET&S/Enron@Enron
cc:
Subject: Re: NSPS Calculation for Saturn 1200 -Reply
Rick,
Attached is communications I have had with Solar on the Saturn turbine fuel
consumption. The fuel rate Ms Leslie Whitherspoon cites in her example below
is the lowest I have seen from Solar for a Saturn turbine. I do not know for
a fact whether her example is applicable to our operation.
I am making you aware that any of the calculations using Solar's data has
exceeded the 10.7 gigajoule/hr limit as specified in 40 CFR 60.330 clause of
the BNA's Subpart GG - Standards of Performance for Stationary Gas Turbines.
I was incorrect to say exceeding this fuel consumption would trigger PSD; per
our conversation it only triggers a NSPS permit which occordingly is
triggered anyway with the replacement of a Saturn turbine. Attached is the
spreadsheet I forwarded to Ms Whitherspoon.
Ken Young
---------------------- Forwarded by Kenneth Young/ET&S/Enron on 02/04/2000
03:45 PM ---------------------------
Leslie H Witherspoon <Witherspoon_Leslie_H@solarturbines.com> on 02/01/2000
09:49:00 AM
To: Kenneth Young/ET&S/Enron@Enron
cc:
Subject: Re: NSPS Calculation for Saturn 1200 -Reply
In the NSPS formula the "STD" value is % by volume....
Therefore, you take your result, 0.015 % ppmv, and move the
decimal two places to the left to represent ppmv. Result 0.00015
or 150 ppm.
Yes, the Saturn has a heat input high enough to trigger the NSPS
regulation. This regulation however, has nothing to do with
triggering PSD. I don't understand the connection you are
making between NSPS, Subpart GG and PSD. Most states,
including Kansas, have the delegated authority for NSPS.
All that is required by the standard is a performance test within
180 days of start-up and a record of the sulfur and nitrogen
content of the fuel. In some cases, less testing is required.
Please let me know if this doesn't answer your questions. I feel
that there may be some disconnect on what your strategy and
how I'm assisting.
Leslie
619.544.2434
On Wednesday, I can be reached at 619.590.0552 all day.
>>> Kenneth_Young@enron.com 02/01/00 04:21pm >>>
Leslie,
Please review your calculations. I do not think (14.4 / 14.4 x
0.015)
equals 150ppm.
This issue is not the tolerable limits of emission of the Solar
Saturn. I feel
this issue relates to a fuel flow limit which governs whether a
Saturn falls
under the 10.7 gigajoule limit prescibe by 40 CFR 60.330 clause
of the BNA's
Subpart GG - Standards of Performance for Stationary Gas
Turbines. I have
included a spreadsheet to illustrate my point. From your data a
Solar Saturn
consumes fuel at the rate of 10,864 BTU/HP.hr; my calculations
show that this
rate consumes fuel a rate about .5 gigajoule above BNAs limit,
which may force
us to apply for a PSD permit.
Please take time to review the spreadsheet and my comments,
and if you see
anything that needs correction, please advise.
(See attached file: Solar Saturn limits.xls)
Thanks
Ken Young
Leslie H Witherspoon
<Witherspoon_Leslie_H@solarturbines.com> on 01/26/2000
02:28:00 AM
To: Kenneth Young/ET&S/Enron@Enron
cc: Leslie H Witherspoon
<Witherspoon_Leslie_H@solarturbines.com> (IPM Return
requested) (Receipt notification requested)
Subject: NSPS Calculation for Saturn 1200
Heat Rate at ISO conditions: 10,864 Btu/Hp-hr
10,864 Btu/Hp-hr x 1055 J/Btu / 745.7 w/Hp / 1000 J/KJ =
15.37 KJ/w-hr
Max denominator is 14.4 per the regulation
14.4 / 14.4 x 0.015 = 150 ppm
The regulatory limit is 150 ppm. We warranty the Saturn 1500 at
110 ppm. I would suppose that the 1200 had a similar warranty.
Please let me know if you need anything else.
Leslie Witherspoon
Solar Turbines
619.544.2434