29 Nov 2000, 10:58 UTC
Proposed Decision
- From
- Jeffery Fawcett jeffery.fawcett@enron.com
- Bcc
- Susan M Scott
- Date
- Wed, 29 Nov 2000 02:58:00 -0800 (PST)
The GD article today regarding the proposed decision is a pretty good Readers Digest version of the order. Susan and I spoke with Jeff Dasovich and Mark Baldwin yesterday, and the consensus of those conversations was that Transwestern should remain involved in this proceeding only for purposes of implementation/documentation. Jeff offered that he might send a letter to Governor Gray's office expressing both dismay and indignation that the CPUC didn't complete their task and warning of the adverse outcome to California ratepayers if these more modest reforms are approved. He may ask the other Comprehensive Settlement parties to join in signing the letter. Susan, Mark and I spoke about this idea later, and we've got some reservations about TW's role in admonishing the CPUC. We should probably wait to see this letter first before committing to anything. Bilas draft cautious toward SoCal competition Mindful of the current chaos over energy markets in the state, California Public Utilities Commissioner Richard Bilas has recommended the adoption of a much more moderate approach to promoting competition on Southern California Gas, (SoCal) system. In his draft decision, Bilas advised the commission to reject the unbundling of intrastate transmission and instead approve the first settlement filed in the case, the less far-reaching Interim Settlement (IS), submitted in December 1999. SoCal, San Diego Gas and Electric and other parties filed two more settlements after the IS, reaching a comprehensive agreement in April this year. But since then, gas and power prices skyrocketed in the state, prompting a consumer backlash and giving competition a bad name. The draft language notes that the first interim settlement was supported by more customer groups than the later agreements. Recent events &lead us to conclude that the centerpiece of this investigation, the unbundling of intrastate transmission and the implementation of a system of firm, tradable intrastate transmission rights, should be delayed,8 according to the draft order. &This unbundling is the basis of the [comprehensive settlement] and we cannot approve it. We do not, however, wish to commit to paralysis until 2006, as the [post-interim settlement] would have us do. Accordingly, we believe Californians are better served at this juncture by the adoption, with modifications, of the IS.8 The biggest change to the IS in the draft is the rejection of an automatic capacity expansion by SoCal at Wheeler Ridge, Calif., with rolled-in rates if certain criteria are met. El Paso Energy had objected to the provision in the IS that would have allowed SoCal to automatically expand capacity at Wheeler Ridge by 100 million cfd if a certain number of curtailments oc-curred. El Paso objected to forcing all shippers to pay for the expansion at Wheeler when only certain customers would benefit. The draft says SoCal can file a separate application for the Wheeler Ridge expansion, but approval would be conditioned on a traditional hearing process. The draft decision would also: End SoCal,s current &windowing8 process, which limits shippers, ability to change nominations for deliveries between receipt points on the system. It is replaced with an announced daily calculation of capacity available at each receipt point; Establish Hector Road as a formal receipt point for nominations; Institute an operational flow order (OFO) procedure. Provides a forum for more changes in OFO procedures if excessive OFOs are made; Set up &pools8 of gas on the SoCal transmission system that are intended to increase the liquidity of gas trading; Make changes to balancing rules, while retaining the current 10% monthly imbalance tolerance; Make SoCal,s own gas acquisition unit subject to the same balancing rules and penalties as all other shippers; Allow some limited imbalances trading, as well as the right to assign and reassign unbundled storage contract in a secondary market, with a SoCal electronic bulletin board set up for it; Unbundle from core transportation rates the storage capacity cost exceeding that required for core minimum reliability; and Provide for rate recovery of up to $3.5 million in implementation costs. In addition, the draft would unbundle core interstate transportation from rates, eliminate core contribution to noncore interstate transition cost surcharges, eliminate the core subscription option as well as the caps for core aggregation programs. The threshold for participating in core aggregation is reduced, and billing options are offered to core aggregators. Bilas, draft also warned that the commission may come back in two years to open another investigation into gas competition, taking into account any changes in market conditions. Bilas gave a little more insight into his decision in the text of the draft. &The cost of gas as a commodity has vastly increased at the border, showing a differential between the basin and border prices that is more than the cost of transport and related services; we question whether there will be an opportunity for discounting by marketers if more competition is allowed,8 Bilas wrote in the draft decision. &With half the state already committed to a restructured competitive natural gas industry, it suddenly seems as if the benefits of such re- structuring to enhance competition are speculative, particularly at this time. With one leg in the water, the current has switched direction and it will be difficult, if not foolhardy, to reach our goals by forging ahead. &We choose to take a cautious approach again,8 the draft continues. &Rather than proceeding to unbundle transmission in Southern California now, we approve, with modifications, the settle- ment suggesting smaller steps towards a competitive market. Additionally, we unbundle core interstate transmission and once again urge the Legislature to pass consumer protection legisla- tion aimed at unregulated marketers while we facilitate growth in core aggregation programs.8 The CPUC would not rule out the unbundling of intrastate transmission and other restruc- turing in the future &but believe that at this point in time the certain benefits do not outweigh the costs to most ratepayers.8 All drafts must be filed 30 days before the meetings at which they will be discussed. The draft decision is currently on the agenda for the CPUC,s Dec. 21 meeting.