28 Feb 2002, 14:25 UTC
FW: NBPL BTU issue
- From
- Don Hawkins don.hawkins@enron.com
- To
- Randy Rice
- Date
- Thu, 28 Feb 2002 06:25:28 -0800 (PST)
Randy, I think this addresses some of the concerns you had yesterday with BTU. Don
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Thompson, Charlie Sent: Thursday, February 28, 2002 6:29 AM To: Hawkins, Don Subject: FW: NBPL BTU issue Don........FYI. -----Original Message----- From: Harrill, Billi Sent: Wednesday, February 27, 2002 5:16 PM To: Miller, Randy; Steve Klimesh/ET&S/Enron@ENRON Cc: Rice, Randy; Thompson, Charlie; Freeman, John; Cowart, Willie; Johnson, Lynn; Puetz, Fred; Swerczek, Mike; Coburn, Scott Subject: RE: NBPL BTU issue The information for Ventura gets transferred from the NBPL SCADA/EFM system directly to PGAS through a file extract and transfer that I do every month. Fred Puetz, Lynn Johnson and Mike Swerczek are the programmers on our side that developed this. Jeff May is the programmer on NNG's side that receives the data. We have had numerous problems over the past several months where PGAS does not reflect the same information we are sending. But Mike Swerczek has confirmed for me that we are sending the correct information -- something seems to be happening in the upload to PGAS. This whole process worked fine before PGAS -- we've been doing this for several years. -----Original Message----- From: Miller, Randy Sent: Wednesday, February 27, 2002 5:08 PM To: Steve Klimesh/ET&S/Enron@ENRON Cc: Rice, Randy; Thompson, Charlie; Freeman, John; Harrill, Billi; Cowart, Willie Subject: NBPL BTU issue Steve, I wasn't sure who all I was suppose to copy on this so if I missed someone please forward this on to them. First I looked over every daily BTU average from the NBPL Ventura GC from Sept through to date and there are no two days in a row where the BTU value were the same although there we several days where if you rounded the BTU to 1 decimal place they would be the same. I also verified back to September the Ventura GC BTU with the NBPL Glen Ullin GC BTU and our monthly averages for these two GCs have tracked between with 0.1 and 0.4 BTU of each other. So I am confidant with the NBPL BTU numbers. Second after I received the Daily Volume Statement I checked the BTU factors for the days in question against the Ventura BTU average for that day. What I found was that when the statement would show a series of days that the BTU was the same the first day was correct but the rest of the days were not. Although when I took the volume in MCF times the BTU factor listed in the report for the days in question I did not get the same value listed as the MMBTU value. I then took the MCF times the SCADA BTU average and it then calculates correctly for the MMBTU listed. I spoke with John Freeman and we verified the information in the NBPL SCADA and it is correct and matches up with the Daily Volume statement for MCF and MMBTU but the BTU factor did not match up for the days in question. So I believe the volumes and energy values to be correct it is just the BTU factor listed on the Daily report that is incorrect on some days. I have listed below some of information out of our SCADA system for a few of the days in question. Do you know how the volume and BTU values get from NBPL to NNG for this statement? The problem may be in the transfer of that data. Meter Id: 920401 Station Name: Ventura Ultrasonic NBPL POI: 7 Meter Run: Sum of 1 meter run(s) Atmos Pressure: 14.045 Pressure Base: 14.73 Hist MMCF DryBTU Energy Date @14.73 @ 60 MDTH ------ ------ ---- ------- 11225 1106.90 1008 1115.35 11226 1130.88 1007 1138.96 11227 911.95 1006 917.77 11228 871.40 1007 877.14 11229 874.29 1007 880.25 11230 899.08 1007 905.58 11231 908.20 1009 916.07 20201 881.81 1009 890.00 20202 667.24 1008 672.37 Actual BTU daily average values 02/02 1007.6903 ? ? 02/01 1009.2866 ? ? 01/31 1009.2733 ? ? 01/30 1008.8920 ? ? 01/29 1006.3815 ? ? 01/28 1006.2870 ? ? 01/27 1006.2625 ? ? 01/26 1007.5184 ? ? 01/25 1007.6829 ?