9 Oct 2000, 15:32 UTC
Re: SDGE represenatation of future market conditions
- From
- James D Steffes james.steffes@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 9 Oct 2000 08:32:00 -0700 (PDT)
Chris & Jeff -- Given your pending discussions, thought you should see this information. Not quite sure what SDG&E is up to here, but wanted you to be aware. Jeff, don't know what Mona is thinking about doing, but you may want to talk with her about responses. Jim
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by James D Steffes/NA/Enron on 10/09/2000 03:29 PM ----- Mona L Petrochko@EES 10/09/2000 02:59 PM To: Gary Mirich/HOU/EES@EES cc: Douglas Condon/SFO/EES@EES, Martin Wenzel/SFO/HOU/EES@EES, West GA, Harry Kingerski@EES, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Joe Hartsoe@Enron Subject: Re: SDGE represenatation of future market conditions Gary, Thanks for passing this information along. This is a pretty well-documented discussion, which is always helpful when we contact the utility about such conduct. Obviously, this is very concerning about SDG&E counter-marketing, while promoting choice. In addition some of their assumptions seem to require tremendous leaps of faith. I haven't seen an application to aggregate yet, but I would assume there would be heavy protests to such a proposal. (SDG&E solicited my feedback on such a position, and I told them we weren't interested.) I'm not sure what type of ruling they are expecting from FERC, lower price caps or a return to cost-based rates (pretty extreme). Decision, per Sue Mara, is not expected until December. SDG&E does have bilateral contracting authority and at least thus far has not exercised it. Customers have already experienced what "leaving it to SDG&E" will get them. Once bitten, twice shy. Enron Energy Services From: Gary Mirich 10/09/2000 12:03 PM Phone No: 602-840-3800 To: Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES@EES cc: Douglas Condon/SFO/EES@EES, Martin Wenzel/SFO/HOU/EES Subject: SDGE represenatation of future market conditions Mona, I thought you should have the following information due to your ongoing work with SDGE to facilitate open market choice by their regulated customers. As you know I've been working with SAIC to close business for the last 60 days. We had offered them a 26 month price on 50% of their load for approximately 7.5 cents/kWh. They compared our offer(s) to others that were significantly higher. As part of their decision-making process, and in an attempt to confirm that SDGE wasn't preparing to release any kind of drastic rate reduction/relief in the immediate future, SAIC's treasurer called SDGE's CEO for a meeting with an SDGE exec. On 9/27, SAIC's treasurer Dan Baldwin met with SDGE's SVP of Fuels and Power Ops, Gary Cotton. Another SAIC exec, Rene Terrazas, VP Real Estate, was also in that meeting. He is my source for the following comments from SDGE: 1). SDGE expects to be given authority very soon to aggregate customers, much like direct access providers, in order to provide better-than-market pricing. 2). SDGE expects FERC to "come out with something" that will reduce the prices that retail standard offer customers are paying. No detail from SDGE on what form FERC's action would take or when. 3). SDGE's recent bilateral contracting authority should result in lower prices for SAIC. 4). SDGE suggested that very few customers have switched to DA because their is too much uncertainty about the future. He said that SAIC is part of 97% of SDGE's customers that have not switched to date. 5). This SDGE exec said he thought that prices would soon return to a more reasonable level, and that SAIC should be expecting direct access prices around 5 cents/kWh. Even though SAIC currently suffers from analysis-paralysis, SDGE's comments about the state of the market are very concerning. First, pawning off SAIC to an exec in fuels and ops for advise about the retail open market hardly seems appropriate. Second, SDGE's suggestion to SAIC that they are somehow in good company by waiting is directly in contrast to what SDGE's regulatory affairs people are attempting to promote with the supplier selection initiative. Third, for SDGE to even hint that there are regulatory (FERC, CPUC, or otherwise) "fixes" soon to be announced that will relieve SAIC's pricing dilema is at the very least irresponsible. In Rene's opinion the SDGE exec was using the same old "fear, uncertainty, and doubt" lines that utility execs typically employed prior to direct access in their efforts to retain customers! Finally, and most concerning to me, is that SDGE has an executive willing to make a guess about the price SAIC should be expecting to receive in this market. Many market sources (eg: Bloomberg) besides Enron wouldn't predict a price as low as 5 cents. Nevermind that Mr. Cotton is likely unqualified to make such a claim, but even if he was, I think he is way off base for even entertaining the question. In light of our efforts to work with SDGE to facilitate customer transition to DA, I think these comments indicate that their executive team is not truly on board with the work of SDGE's regulatory affairs. EES is in a "stand down" right now with SAIC, who decided after their meeting with SDGE that Enron's offer may not be as competitive as previously believed. Their treasurer has decided to wait and see - perhaps a month or more. Irrespective of my ability to close this deal today or in the future, I wanted you to be aware of the SDGE's comments and how they've impacted one SDGE customer's decision to "leave the utility". Perhaps we should suggest that customer inquiries like those of SAIC go through regulatory affairs instead of execs who have twisted and/or minimal information and a willingness to guess about the future. Your comments welcome. thanks much Gary.