15 Dec 2000, 09:10 UTC
A DRAFT OF A BRIEF ON CALIFORNIA'S WOES for ENRON'S REGULATORY AND
- From
- Margaret Carson margaret.carson@enron.com
- Bcc
- Joan Stransky
- Date
- Fri, 15 Dec 2000 01:10:00 -0800 (PST)
WHY CALIFORNIA SHOULD HAVE LISTENED TO ENRON NOT HERE....NO WAY The root cause of California's high electricity costs today stem from a severe lack of new power plants. Why? Not enough capacity was added since 1996 due to tough siting problems in this ecology prone state. Even Enron gave up in Pittsburg, in North California when it took too long to site a clean 500 MW gas combined cycle plant on an empty site that is right next door to an existing plant! In fact in all the state only 700 MW of new capacity were added since 1996 compared to its growth of 11000 MW since then. This growth ate up all the surplus capacity that existed in 1996. No wonder they are power short. It is a tough dilemma since this state's hi tech businesses and commercial businesses and homeowners have fast growing demand for more and more reliable power. THE 10 PERCENT CUTS BOTH WAYS The CPUC compounded the state's problems when they put their electric deregulation plan in place in 1997-98 by mandating a high 10 percent rate cut to residential and commercial consumers--which Enron loudly protested at the time--. This rate cu, just as Enron predicted discouraged alternative power sellers from selling into California because it was a hard price to beat and it blurred consumers understanding of what is actually happening to their cost of power. It would have worked if PG&E and SoCalEd had cut their costs --as they should have -- by 10 percent to accommodate the rate cuts, but of course they didn't. Surprise surprise. BI LATERAL CONTRACTS TO THE RESCUE Further problems arose because of the CPUCs requirement for wholesale buyers and sellers to use the PX (power exchange) auction system -- instead of bilateral contracting which Enron Government Affairs strongly advocated at the time -- . The PX uses an auction to set a single highest price that clears the market in one time period for all power, rather than the variety of prices that can be agreed to by dozens of counterparties under a free market using bilateral contracting. Now that the PX is often unworkable bilateral contracting is begging to be allowed. But it may be too little too late. TO MAKE THINGS WORSE Because the CPUC has been shocked by the high prices being reached in the PX , it now has been setting tight $150 - $250 MW price caps which obviates its own auction process and discourages sellers of power away from selling power into California. But it also worsen the economics for any potential power plant developers who might be out there considering building a plant in C alifornia. Many US power markets have no price caps at all or caps of $1000 MW (or high enough so they are seldom triggered.) Not California. CALIFORNIA'S WOES AREN'T EASY TO FIX What does this all mean? If California had listened to Enron it would have avoided the severe problems it has today--- lack of new plants, lack of market oriented power prices, rate caps that discourage sellers and developers alike and irate customers. It would have had no automatic rate cut and consumers would know when their costs were going up or down. The State would use bilateral contracting to get its supplies so if Duke or Enron or Exelon or Dynegy or whoever had contracts with counterparties the prices would be variously set and if more power demand was evident, developers would have a clear economic basis on which to contract for their new plants. There would be no need for price caps. NOT IN MY BACKYARD OR YOURS EITHER!! On the power plant siting problem, this is a tough one. California is a beautiful state and prides itself on its green conscience. Even a few high tech companies that need 99.9999 percent reliable power desparately are still unwilling to build a small clean gas combined cycle plant inside their own fence. So we do not know how California can resolve siting problems as it is a quirk of the state that says give me lots more cheap, environmentally clean power but don't build any plants here in my state to do it.