26 Oct 2001, 21:32 UTC
OSBA Report Online HTML Version Volume 74 Issue 44
- From
- osbareport@ohiobar.org osbareport@ohiobar.org
- Date
- Fri, 26 Oct 2001 14:32:07 -0700 (PDT)
Goto Online Report Homepage></a> </td> </tr> <!--========================================= END TR SECTION 1 =============================--> <!--========================================= BEGIN TR SECTION 2 =============================--> <tr> <td width=Curving GraphicHand on Mouse GraphicOctober 29, 2001Vol. 74 # 44 Click to view Legis-Letter Click to view Classifieds Click to view Breaking News CLE Courses Unsubscribe [IMAGE] [IMAGE] Click to Visit Click to Visit Click to Visit Click to Visit Click to Visit Click to Visit Click to Visit Supreme Court Judges-Discipline-Impartiality-Impropriety-Public Reprimand After judge spoke with newly arrested person and drove her home from police station without discussing her case, he was the judge in her case and accepted her plea agreement. Judge is publicly reprimanded for failing to promote public confidence in judiciary, failing to recuse himself and creating an impression of impropriety. Disciplinary Counsel v. Medley 93 Ohio St.3d 474 Torts-Dram Shop Act-Wrongful Death-Underage Buyer-Knowingly In Dram Shop Act action for wrongful death arising out of vehicular accident allegedly caused by sale of beer to minor without proof of age, trial court's grant of summary judgment for defendants was erroneous. ORC ?4399.18(A)(3) imposes liability on a liquor licensee for negligent off-premises actions of intoxicated person if a preponderance of the evidence shows licensee or its employee knowingly sold intoxicating beverage to underage person, a violation of criminal prohibition in ORC ?4301.69. Read in pari materia with ORC ?4301.69, the word "knowingly," as applied in ORC ?4399.18(A)(3), to the sale of an intoxicating beverage to an underage person, encompasses the standard "know or have reason to know" and a licensee may not avoid liability by simply failing to ask buyer for identification or proof of legal age or failing to establish other safeguards. Lesnau v. Andate Enterprises, Inc. 93 Ohio St.3d 467 Court of Appeals Opinions Civil Rights-Firearms-Brady Act-Background Check Fees Nonprofit firearm association, licensed firearms dealer, and Ohio residents and handgun purchasers brought 42 USC ?1983 action against Ohio Attorney General (OAG) for refund of fees paid for firearms purchasers' background checks under the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act, 18 USC ?921, et seq., and a subsequent agreement between OAG and U.S. attorney general, on the basis that the fee was unauthorized and unconstitutional. Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment to OAG. As to the 42 USC ?1983 claims, that plaintiffs could bring and were not barred by the applicable statute of limitations, ORC ?2305.10(A), plaintiffs' rights were not infringed by the OAG, nor were plaintiffs-purchasers affected by conduct taken under color of state law. OAG and state agency responsible for collecting the Brady fee acted within their statutory powers. Second Amendment to U.S. Constitution, effective only against the federal government, is not incorporated into the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and does not restrict the power of states to regulate the right to keep and bear arms for purposes of a claim under 42 USC ?1983. ORC Chapter 2723 permits an adequate means to contest a tax or assessment and was available to challenge the legality of Brady fee before or after its imposition, such that the fee's imposition did not violate procedural due process. Also discussed: where OAG is sued in official capacity, 42 USC ?1983 may not be the basis for such a suit; dealers as private entities did not function as state actors; OAG entitled to qualified immunity; plaintiffs failed to timely bring their personal-capacity action against OAG for collection of Brady fees under the sole remedy, ORC ?2723.01. Peoples Rights Org. v. Montgomery (12th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 443 Criminal Law-Expungement-Retroactivity Trial court did not err in denying expungement of first-degree misdemeanor domestic violence conviction where motion was filed before effective date of new ORC ?2953.36(C) prohibiting expungement, and denial was entered after effective date. Expungement is a privilege conferred at discretion of trial court, not a right, and rule prohibiting retroactive application of law against a vested right, Ohio Const., Art. II, ?28, was not violated. Euclid v. Sattler (8th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 538 Criminal Law-Juveniles-Delinquency-Murder-Purpose-Involuntary Manslaughter Trial court erred in adjudicating 13-year-old defendant delinquent for murder with gun specification and carrying a concealed weapon, arising out of 10-year-old neighbor's being shot while defendant was engaging in horseplay with father's gun. Adjudication was not supported by sufficient evidence of purposefulness where there was a lack of animus or motive, gun was in awkward position when it discharged, safety had been on earlier in day when defendant pulled trigger without effect, and defendant was surprised and dismayed when gun discharged into victim. Defendant's carrying gun for avowed purpose of scaring neighbor girls constitutes aggravated menacing under ORC ?2903.21, which supports finding of delinquency involuntary manslaughter, and case is directly remanded for entry of judgment and sentencing on this lesser included offense. Also discussed: despite low IQ, defendant understood nature of charges against him and ably assisted counsel who was not ineffective in failing to request a competence hearing. In re York (8th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 524 Employer and Employee-Termination-Arbitration-Appeal After township terminated firefighters and refused to arbitrate grievances, it sought declaratory judgment that appeal from termination under ORC ?505.38 was sole remedy under collective bargaining agreement (CBA). Trial court denied injunctive relief and granted judgment on pleadings, holding that, under CBA, arbitrator had jurisdiction to determine arbitrability. Trial court did not err because where CBA expressly reserves power to arbitrator to determine arbitrability, trial court should not make an independent determination. It is also for arbitrator to determine whether grievances assert rights under the CBA that may be maintained independent of a court action or whether the grievances amount to an appeal of termination under ORC ?505.38, which would preclude arbitration. Union Twp., Clermont Cty. v. Union Twp. Professional Firefighters' Local 3412 (12th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 542 Housing-Mandatory Inspections-Search Warrant-Probable Cause-Ripeness After landlord was convicted of two misdemeanor city housing code violations and administratively ordered, pursuant to ordinance, to have semiannual searches of all properties, including even those not involved in the violations, trial court did not abuse its discretion in affirming decision upholding constitutionality. Where city ordinance does not mandate that inspections be performed without a warrant, but either with owner's consent or with a warrant, it is constitutional. Where city performed the inspections but has not had the occasion to obtain a search warrant, landlord's contention that conviction of a housing code violation is insufficient probable cause to issue a warrant for another property is not ripe for adjudication. Russel v. Akron Dept. of Public Health, Hous. Appeals Dept. (9th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 430 Landlord and Tenant-Courts-Municipal-Jurisdiction-Counterclaim Amount-Appeal In a forcible entry and detainer action in municipal court for possession and damages with tenant counterclaiming for breach of quiet enjoyment, harassment, abuse of process and injunctive relief, magistrate denied tenant's motion to certify case to common pleas court due to counterclaim in excess of jurisdictional amount. Trial proceeded solely on landlord's claim for possession with the magistrate granting judgment for possession to the landlord, which the municipal court adopted. Where municipal court's ruling on tenant's motion to certify was pending, any claim of error in that ruling must await final judgment, and municipal court had jurisdiction to enter judgment for possession, ORC ?1901.18(A)(8). ORC ?1901.22 and Civ. R. 13(J) are not self-executing, and municipal court is not required to certify cases based solely on the monetary amount demanded in a counterclaim. Also discussed: reconsideration of court of appeals previous dismissal granted after trial court signed journal entry approving magistrate's decision granting writ of restitution to landlord, App. R. 26. Colombo Ent., Inc. v. Fegan (8th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 551 Political Subdivisions-Tort Liability-Housing-Immunity-Party In owner's action for damages against county building and zoning department (BZD) and its administrator arising out of denial of building permit to complete residential construction and township's demolition of structure, trial court did not err in granting summary judgment to BZD on basis, inter alia, of immunity and failure to sue township. BZD is an instrumentality that carries out county functions that entitles it to political subdivision tort liability immunity under ORC Chapter 2744, where it was engaged in a governmental function, ORC ?2744.01(C)(2)(p), and there is no applicable exception to immunity. Where township initiated administrative action to demolish structure, it was proper party-defendant, not BZD, which merely granted administrative demolition order after township order was final. Brewer v. Butler Cty. Bldg. & Zoning Dept. (12th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 567 Practice and Procedure-Class Action-Certification Borrowers brought action against lender arising out of alleged fraudulent misrepresentation of true cost of postponing one monthly payment by neglecting to disclose that extension fee was in addition to the compound interest payable over loan term. Trial court did not err in certifying class after oral argument based on grounds set forth in motion for certification and plaintiffs' supplemental memorandum rebutting lender's allegations of class's deficiency. Also discussed: trial court was not required to make separate findings for each element of class certification, along with supporting reasons. Begala v. PNC Bank, Ohio, N.A. (1st Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 556 Products Liability-Defect-Proximate Cause Plaintiff-minor's hand was partially amputated by meat grinder used in father's business, and jury returned verdict for manufacturer on products liability claim and for maintenance company on negligence claim. Competent, credible evidence supported jury verdict that grinder was not defective under consumer expectation or risk/benefit tests where expert testified that product's safety devices and warnings sufficiently warned consumer of the danger; that the product was not more dangerous than an ordinary consumer would expect; and that product conformed to all applicable engineering and manufacturing standards and was safe as designed. Verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where jury could have found that sole proximate cause of injury was plaintiffs' failure to unplug grinder before reassembling it and improper removal of hopper top, contrary to manufacturer's warnings. Bleh v. Biro Mfg. Co. (1st Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 434 Torts-Attorneys-Legal Malpractice-Release-Consideration-Formation In action against attorneys who admitted malpractice in failing to timely file personal injury claim arising out of auto accident, trial court erred in granting summary judgment to attorneys based on release that recited as sole consideration only the sum paid by tortfeasor's insurer in settlement of client's emotional distress claim. There was also genuine fact issue of meeting of parties' minds on settlement and whether attorneys' waiver of fees and payment of client's medical expenses was fair consideration. Barnes v. Ricotta (8th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 560 Misc Court No Cases this week. [IMAGE] rounding corner graphic Opinion summaries prepared by Anadem, Inc., Columbus, Ohio. [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] Ohio unreported appellate opinions Ohio Attorney General opinions U.S. Supreme Court opinions U.S. 6th Circuit opinions Ohio ethics opinions Ohio Revised Code Click here to visit Casemaker! [IMAGE] Docket Announcements Rules Announcements Calendar Click here to read more! [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] New OSBA awards to honor contributions in legal education Recognizing a high level of interaction between the academic community and the practicing bar, the Ohio State Bar Association Legal Education Committee has established two new legal education awards. Click to read more! Address issues in your practice area: Join your OSBA section board of governors Anyone interested in serving on the board of one of the OSBA's sections? Read further to find out more about this great opportunity. Click to read more! Civil rights attorney Morris Dees to speak in Columbus Famed civil rights attorney will be keynote speaker at the Ohio Center for Law-Related Education's Annual Law and Citizenship Conference. Click to read more! More Association News... [IMAGE] [IMAGE] OSBA Logo - Justice is Hard Work Editor: Kathleen Maloney Technology Director: Fred Engel IT Engineer: Shane Zatezalo Membership, Public and Media Relations, & Publications Committee: William J. Davis, East Liverpool, chair Colleen E. Cook, Marietta Louis A. DiFabio, Geneva Michael H. Mearan, Portsmouth Kraig E. Noble, St. Marys Heather G. Sowald, Columbus [IMAGE] [IMAGE] To unsubscribe from this newsletter click here . To subscribe to the text-only version click here . For the online issue archives click here . To utilize the links to the caselaw in the OSBA Report Online you will need a version 5.x or higher web browser. [IMAGE] [IMAGE] Copyright ? 1997-2001 Ohio State Bar Association. All rights reserved. To submit comments or suggestions, send to OSBAreport@ohiobar.org [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE]