2 Jul 2001, 15:16 UTC
FERC OASIS Business Practice Ruling
- From
- Charles Yeung charles.yeung@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 2 Jul 2001 08:16:00 -0700 (PDT)
Another victory at FERC! Although Enron did not file a protest in this docket, nor was a signatory to the joint Coral/Dynegy protest, I worked with Dynegy on forming the arguments against the proposed change to OASIS (first to confirm after scheduling deadline) at NERC. Dynegy and Enron and a few others voted against the NERC request but lost the vote thus leading to the NERC filing. In my opinion, such a practice would advantage incumbent utilities and their affiliate marketers who tend to buy pre-confirmed Firm service. One of the main arguments I made at NERC and a chief reason why FERC denied the request is cited in the order: "Dynegy/Coral argues that the proposed standard addresses the problem of unused transmission capacity caused by some customers not confirming accepted transmission requests, but does not address the underlying problem caused by the practice of some transmission providers of delaying their acceptance of requests for daily, firm transmission service, even when customers submit their requests early. " FERC further acknowleded: "If transmission providers would all respond to requests for daily,firm transmission service on a timely basis, then customers would have adequate time to confirm before reservations are scheduled, and the MIC's proposed business practice might not be needed." This is the correct message for FERC to send back to NERC - to put the burden on the transmission providers to expedite requests - not penalize the customers for getting OASIS requests in early.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Charles Yeung/HOU/ECT on 07/02/2001 02:59
PM ---------------------------
"Grabiak, Terri J." <TGrabia@alleghenypower.com>@nerc.com on 07/02/2001
01:39:42 PM
Sent by: owner-mips@nerc.com
To: "'mips@nerc.com'" <mips@nerc.com>
cc:
Subject: Business Practice Ruling
For those of you that haven't seen this. FERC denied our request.
T
95 FERC 4 61,492
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Before Commissioners: Curt H'bert, Jr., Chairman;
William L. Massey, Linda Breathitt,
Pat Wood, III and Nora Mead Brownell.
Open Access Same-time Information
System (OASIS) and Standards of Docket No. RM95-9-013
Conduct
ORDER DENYING REQUEST FOR EXPERIMENTAL BUSINESS PRACTICE STANDARD
(Issued June 29, 2001)
We will deny the request from the Market Interface Committee
of the North American Electric Reliability Council (MIC) for
expedited approval of its proposed experiment on the treatment of
unconfirmed requests for daily, firm transmission service, for
the reasons stated below.
BACKGROUND
On May 29, 2001, the MIC filed a request to modify the
Commission's OASIS Business Practice Standards adopted in Order
1
No. 638, to add a new business practice standard dealing with
accepted daily, firm point-to-point transmission service that has
not been confirmed and to modify a related footnote to Table 4-2
on Reservation Timing Limits. The MIC requests that the
Commission implement this proposal on a mandatory, experimental
basis for six months beginning no later than June 30, 2001. The
MIC further states that, within four months of the effective
date, it will provide the Commission with an assessment of the
1
Open Access Same-Time Information System and Standards of
Conduct, Order No. 638, FERC Stats. & Regs., Regulations
Preambles 1996-2000 4 31,092 (2000).
Docket No. RM95-9-013 -2-
experiment and whether it should be revised, discontinued, or
made permanent.
On June 5, 2001, the Commission issued a notice of filing
and request for comments regarding the MIC filing. The notice
gave a brief description of the MIC proposal and invited comments
2
on or before June 11, 2001. Comments were invited on the MIC
proposal generally and specifically on whether Commission action
is needed by June 30, 2001, as requested by the MIC.
On June 11, 2001, Dynegy Power Marketing, Inc. and Coral
Power, LLC (collectively "Dynegy/Coral") jointly filed a protest
opposing the MIC request.
Dynegy/Coral argue that the MIC proposal should not be granted on
an expedited basis and that it should be rejected outright.
Dynegy/Coral's protest was the sole comment filed in response to
the June 5, 2001 notice and request for comments.
DISCUSSION
We will deny the MIC s request for expedited approval of its
proposed experiment on the treatment of unconfirmed requests for
daily, firm transmission service for three reasons. First,
although the MIC requests expedited approval of its proposed
experiment, the MIC s proposal presents no reason why expedited
treatment is needed. Moreover, although our June 5, 2001 notice
specifically invited comment on this issue, no comments were
filed in support of expedited treatment or giving reasons why
2
This shortened comment period was used to accommodate the
MIC's request for action on or before June 30, 2001.
Docket No. RM95-9-013 -3-
prompt action is needed. In fact, Dynegy/Coral s protest, the
sole comment filed, argued against expedited approval of the
proposed experiment both because it opposed approval of the
experiment outright, and because Dynegy/Coral argues that
implementation during the summer peak period would cause problems
for customers denied service under the MIC s proposal. Given the
absence of a showing of need for expedited treatment, we will
reject MIC s request for expedited approval of its proposed
experiment.
The MIC proposal would allow transmission providers, at
reservation request deadlines, to retract their prior acceptance
of unconfirmed customer requests for daily, firm transmission
service and substitute pending pre-confirmed requests for such
service, in order of queue time, up to the amount of daily, firm
available transmission capability remaining. The proposal
includes phrases such as, "the transmission provider has the
right to move to a retracted status" and "after which time that
request may be retracted." These phrases do not provide a
standard for the transmission provider to use in deciding whether
to retract customers' unconfirmed accepted requests for daily,
firm point-to-point transmission service. Careful monitoring
would be necessary to insure that the proposal is not implemented
in a discriminatory manner. A customer whose request for
transmission service had been accepted would have no way to
predict whether a transmission provider might choose to retract
Docket No. RM95-9-013 -4-
its acceptance, which would make it difficult for the customer to
make alternative arrangements.
Dynegy/Coral argues that the proposed standard addresses the
problem of unused transmission capacity caused by some customers
not confirming accepted transmission requests, but does not
address the underlying problem caused by the practice of some
transmission providers of delaying their acceptance of requests
for daily, firm transmission service, even when customers submit
their requests early. Dynegy/Coral contends this practice puts
customers in a bind that forces them to make alternative
arrangements as a protective mechanism. Dynegy/Coral argues that
customers should not be punished for taking such precautions,
even if they result in some unused transmission capacity.
Dynegy/Coral argues that a better solution to avoid unused
capacity would be for transmission providers to more uniformly
respond to requests for daily, firm transmission service on a
timely basis, rather than by taking the unwarranted step of
giving greater priority to pre-confirmed service requests.
Further, Dynegy/Coral argues that the MIC proposal would force
customers to purchase transmission services they will be unable
to use.
We agree with Dynegy/Coral that the MIC proposal does not
address whether the time period for transmission providers to
evaluate requests for daily, firm transmission service needs to
be clarified or shortened and that this is a relevant issue. If
transmission providers would all respond to requests for daily,
Docket No. RM95-9-013 -5-
firm transmission service on a timely basis, then customers would
have adequate time to confirm before reservations are scheduled,
and the MIC's proposed business practice might not be needed. We
request that the MIC reconsider its motion in light of the
concerns raised by Dynegy/Coral. After considering these issues,
the MIC may, at its option, make a revised request for an
experimental business practice standard.
The Commission orders:
The request by MIC for expedited approval of a proposed
experiment on the
treatment of unconfirmed requests for daily, firm transmission
service is hereby denied
without prejudice, as discussed in the body of this order.
By the Commission.
( S E A L )
David P. Boergers,
Secretary.
Terri J. Grabiak
General Manager, Transmission Marketing
Allegheny Power
800 Cabin Hill Drive, Room B101
Greensburg, PA 15601
(724) 838-6748
(724) 838-6156 - fax
mailto:tgrabia@alleghenypower.com <mailto:tgrabia@alleghenypower.com>