2 Oct 2000, 08:37 UTC
THE WINNERS IN CALIFORNIA
- From
- Mary Hain mary.hain@enron.com
- To
- Richard B Sanders, Christian Yoder, Richard Shapiro, James D Steffes, steve.c.hall@enron.com, Tim Belden, Robert Badeer, Jeff Richter, Tim Heizenrader, Chris Stokley, Murray P O'Neil
- Date
- Mon, 2 Oct 2000 01:37:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Mary Hain/HOU/ECT on 10/02/2000 08:43 AM --------------------------- Enron Capital & Trade Resources Corp. From: "Ronald Carroll" <rcarroll@bracepatt.com> 10/02/2000 06:48 AM To: <jhartso@enron.com>, <mary.hain@enron.com>, <smara@enron.com>, <snovose@enron.com> cc: Subject: THE WINNERS IN CALIFORNIA DJ POWER POINTS: Winners In $4 Billion Calif Sweepstakes > By Mark Golden > A Dow Jones Newswires Column > > NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--Now that PG&E Corp (PCG), Edison International > (EIX) > and > Sempra Energy (SRE) have announced that about $4 billion in power costs > flew > out > their windows this summer, Wall Street might be curious to know on which > corporate doorsteps the windfall landed. > A few of the beneficiaries have indicated publicly how well they did > this > summer. We've supplemented those announcements with data on market share, > conversations with western U.S. electricity traders, second quarter > earnings > reports and publicly available information from the California Independent > System Operator - operator of the state's high-voltage transmission grid > and > real-time power market - to create this Top 10 list of winners in the > Summer > of > Luck. > > No. 10: Duke Energy Corp (DUK), Calpine Corp (CPN) and AES Corp (AES). > These > companies, with significant merchant power plants in California, didn't > make > as > much money as they could have because they sold their power before prices > started rising. > AES, for starters, has sold the vast majority of the capacity of its > California natural-gas fired generators under a long-term, fixed-price > contract > to make power for another company - a company much higher on this list - > which > supplies the natural gas and owns the electricity. > Duke, with 2,680 megawatts of generators in California, lost out on > significant potential income, because it sold most of its power months > before > prices started to rise. > > No. 9: Electricity trading companies. These companies, like Utilicorp > United's > (UCU) Aquila, Citizens Power (now owned by Edison International) and > Belgian > company Tractebel's (B.TRB) U.S. unit, mostly traded in and out of > positions > - > and they made good profits doing so. This group also includes the > unregulated > trading units of Sempra and PG&E. > > No. 8: Western utilities with power to spare, namely Arizona Public > Service > Co., the Public Service Co. of New Mexico (PNM) and IdaCorp Inc.'s (IDA) > Idaho > Power. > PNM said on Sept. 14 that it made $193 million in wholesale marketing > during > July and August, a 90% increase over the same two months last year. > Arizona > Public Service, which is a subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corp (PNW), > had > considerably more power to sell than PNM, market sources said. > > No. 7: TransAlta (T.TA) and PPL Global (PPL). Western electricity prices > have > been high outside California as well. TransAlta and PPL reached deals to > buy > two > major coal-fired power plants in the Northwest last year and took > ownership > before this summer. Unlike gas, coal is still cheap. > > No. 6: Enron Corp (ENE), El Paso Energy (EPG) and the energy trading > unit > of > Morgan Stanley-Dean Witter (MWD). Unlike the in-and-out traders, these > companies > bet on rising prices and came into the summer holding large supplies in > the > West, electricity traders said. > "Enron just bought and bought and bought before the summer, and never > seemed > to sell," said one trader. > El Paso also owns 896 MW of generation in California. > > No. 5: The U.S. Federal Government and the State of Arizona. Federal > utility > Bonneville Power Administration and Arizona public utility Salt River > Project > rode to California's rescue on the hottest days this summer, providing > hundreds > of megawatts of supply at top dollar. > > No. 4: California's independent generators. The merchant power companies > in > California that did the best this summer are Reliant Energy Inc. (REI), > with > about 4,063 MW of California capacity; Southern Co. (SO), with about 3,000 > MW; > NRG Energy (NRG), with 1,500 MW; and Dynegy Inc. (DYN), with 1,250 MW. > Unlike Duke, AES and Calpine, these companies held on to most of their > power > and sold it in the day-ahead and real-time markets, where prices turned > out > to > be best. > Reliant has already indicated that third quarter earnings available for > equity > will top last year's figure by about $110 million. > All of these companies, however, saw their windfall trimmed by > diversification. Each owns gas-fired and some oil-fired merchant power > plants in > the eastern U.S., where high fuel prices and low electricity prices have > damped > profits. > "We've had a good summer, but we have a pretty balanced portfolio across > the > country," Stephen Bergstrom, president and chief executive of Dynegy, said > in an > interview. "As good as the summer has been in the West, it's been as bad > in > the > eastern half of the country." > > No. 3: Los Angeles Dept. of Water & Power (and its bondholders). LADWP > has > about 7,000 MW of generation, or about 2,000 MW more than it needs for its > customers. As LADWP general manager S. David Freeman said a few weeks ago, > "A > blind pig could make money with that setup." > > No. 2: The heavily taxed citizens of British Columbia, Canada. Their > provincially owned utility, BC Hydro, has been very busy this summer > turning > (free!) water into electricity worth hundreds of millions of dollars more > than > expected and flooding the province's general funds. With hydroelectric dam > reservoirs the size of New England and transmission lines that can carry > 3,000 > MW of southbound power, BC Hydro has single-handedly kept socialism > solvent > for > another year in British Columbia. > > And the Grand Prize winner in the California Utilities Sweepstakes: > Williams > Companies (WMB), the company AES's generators are working for. Williams > controls > almost 4,000 MW of gas-fired generation in the San Diego area, a little > more > than 10% of what California's utilities need on average during daylight > hours in > the summer. > What's more, those plants are under contract as "resource must run" with > the > ISO. Their power can't be sold in the forward market. Williams had to take > daily > and real-time market prices by default, which is exactly what you would > have > done to maximize profits. > And Williams isn't hurt by the factors that have diluted other > companies' > California gains. It isn't very exposed in the East; and as a big producer > of > natural gas, it's benefiting from high gas prices nationwide. > Just to give an idea of how well the company likely has done this > summer, > consider that Williams' second quarter profit from its energy services > segment > rose to $412 million this year from $106 million in the second quarter of > 1999. > That in a quarter with one and a half months of soaring prices. In the > third > quarter, there were three. > -By Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604; > mark.golden@dowjones.com > > (END) Dow Jones Newswires 29-09-00 > 1800GMT(AP-DJ-09-29-00 1800GMT) >