25 Sep 2000, 15:34 UTC
Electric Restructuring: E Source Teleconference Examines Ways to Solve California Power ...
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Mon, 25 Sep 2000 08:34:00 -0700 (PDT)
E Source Teleconference Examines Ways to Solve California Power Crisis 09/25/2000 PR Newswire (Copyright (c) 2000, PR Newswire) BOULDER, Colo., Sept. 25 /PRNewswire/ -- In a teleconference held Friday afternoon, September 22, 2000, by E Source(TM), industry analysts proposed several solutions to remedy the imperfections in California's electric market and discussed ways that those lessons could be applied in other states that are considering restructuring their electric markets. No single "silver bullet" solution emerged from the panelists. Rather, they said that solving the California power situation would require a combination of supply, demand, pricing, and regulatory solutions. "It is important that we mend, not end, electric restructuring," said Ralph Cavanagh, co-director of the energy program at the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC). "Restructuring is a process, not an event," added Becky Kilbourne, director of market development for the California Power Exchange (CalPX). Bill LeBlanc, vice president of retail consulting at E Source, made this point: "It is very difficult to have an open market and a regulated market at the same time. And now, as additional regulations are being added to California's still-opening electric market, new and unpredictable market distortions are likely. Price volatility -- both upward and downward -- characterizes open markets. In a world of price volatility, customers need to have access to a rich portfolio of creative pricing options. Those who want price stability can pay a premium for it. Those willing to play in the dynamic, real-time pricing market will need load management capabilities that allow them to shed load quickly when prices spike." Specific solutions discussed by the panelists included: Supply Solutions Chris Seiple, director of supply-side consulting for RDI(TM), opined that this summer's price spikes were principally the result of insufficient power plant construction in California as its electric demand grew during the 1990s. "The electricity market requires quick responses to changes in conditions and therefore it is a policy imperative that permitting of power plants be achieved more swiftly in California," said Seiple. He noted that electric demand in the western United States has grown by 14 percent during the second half of the 1990s, but generating capacity has grown by only 2 percent. Roughly 3,600 megawatts (MW) of new generation is currently under construction and is scheduled to come online next year. An additional 800 MW of capacity now under construction is slated to come online in 2002, while another 6,000 MW of capacity is in the advanced development stage, with varying in-service dates. A further 20,000 MW of capacity is in early-development stage, he added. However, Seiple cautioned that delays in construction, a possible shortfall of turbines, and the power-development process itself could cause a recurrence of this summer's price spikes by 2002. Not all supply solutions should be fossil-based, said NRDC's Cavanagh, who pointed out that the state of California is adding additional cost-effective renewables that will come online in the near future. These new resources will add to the thousands of megawatts of non-fossil generation capacity that have been installed over the past 20 years. Distributed Solutions In addition to wider use of renewable generation, several panelists agreed that increased deployment of cost-effective energy efficiency measures would serve to dampen future electric price spikes. Consumers also need to be reminded on a regular basis about the importance of wise energy use. "What California and the West need most urgently now is more of what has worked best to relieve strained power grids in recent years: investments in energy efficiency and renewable energy resources, which together have delivered more than 15,000 megawatts to California alone over the past two decades," Cavanagh added. "We need more distributed energy resources and energy efficiency measures to cut future price spikes," said Michael Shames, executive director of the Utility Consumers' Action Network (UCAN). He added that many large commercial customers in California are now considering self-generating their electricity, because they cannot tolerate sharp price swings and they are dissatisfied with the risk-management options they have today. Regulatory and Legal Solutions Kilbourne of the CalPX advocated limited wholesale price caps and an improved interface between wholesale and retail electric markets. She also echoed other panelists when she noted that regulatory disincentives in California caused many energy service providers (ESPs) to exit that market, leaving customers with little or no alternative when prices began rising. Having a larger number of ESPs and a broader range of retail offerings in the market could help avert future price spikes, she said. Ron Davis, director of the E Source Strategic Distribution Management Series, remarked: "The still-regulated distribution companies in California are being held responsible for protecting their retail consumers against the high prices in the state's wholesale power market. But by design, they lack the tools and incentives necessary to keep the power prices they pass on to consumers low and stable. And now, SDG&E is subject to another rate cap. Extending SDG&E's performance-based ratemaking (PBR) to the commodity side of the business, much like was done to allow natural gas services to share in the savings from securing lower cost supplies, is a better solution to help insulate customers from price volatility in the future." Looking Forward UCAN's Shames concluded that "San Diego's experience is a sobering and instructive harbinger of deregulatory turmoil that will hit other regions throughout the country." E Source believes that price volatility will be part of life in retail electric and gas markets that are going through restructuring. Retailers and consumers alike need to protect themselves with hedging investments, load management capabilities, energy efficiency upgrades, and other measures. E Source believes that regulators, lawmakers, ESPs, consumers, commercial customers, and other participants in the restructuring of retail electric and gas markets should closely follow and implement the lessons from the still- evolving California market. E Source and RDI are trademarks of Financial Times Energy, Inc., which is headquartered in Boulder, Colorado. FT Energy is a leading provider of objective information and analysis on restructuring electric and gas markets, wholesale power trends, fuel prices and projections, and other vital knowledge about the electric and gas businesses. If you would like to speak with any of the people quoted in this release, please contact Jim Keener at 720-548-5624. /CONTACT: Jim Keener of E Source, 720-548-5624, jkeener@ftenergy.com/ 14:00 EDT Folder Name: Electric Restructuring Relevance Score on Scale of 100: 79 ______________________________________________________________________ To review or revise your folder, visit Dow Jones CustomClips or contact Dow Jones Customer Service by e-mail at custom.news@bis.dowjones.com or by phone at 800-369-7466. (Outside the U.S. and Canada, call 609-452-1511 or contact your local sales representative.) ______________________________________________________________________ Copyright (c) 2000 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved