16 Feb 2001, 00:49 UTC
WPTF Friday Chapter and Verse Burrito
- From
- Gary Ackerman foothill@lmi.net
- Date
- Thu, 15 Feb 2001 16:49:00 -0800 (PST)
THE FRIDAY BURRITO
Depression is merely anger without enthusiasm
Slowly we sink into the abyss of the dreaded B word.? The State Legislature
and our illustrious Governor, Emperor of the Dark Side, are showing a trait
that heretofore I never noticed.? They are impotent in tackling complex
issues that involve big bucks.? They are simply unable to manage the task.? I
used to hold these institutions in relatively high regard.? Forget the
bellyaching in which all taxpayers and voters engage.? I mean, there was an
element of something bigger than the PUC, the ISO, and the utilities when
reference was made to the boys and girls working in the State Capital.? I am
no longer impressed.
I suppose there are things the Gov and the Legislature do well.? Let me
think.? Well, law enforcement, environment, transportation, water,
agriculture, education, parks and recreation, and health.? I suppose they do
all right managing those things.? But as for electricity, it seems this topic
is like a hungry monster that chews up politicians and spits them out after
sucking the political marrow from their bones.? The mix of money and
electrons is too rich for their appetites.
Yet, hope springs eternal. Today the Governor will announce his package for
curing California's energy crisis.? There is one part of his plan that is
good news.? He will announce a new component of electric rates that will
increase revenue to cover the under-collected wholesale power costs of PG&E
and SCE.? The smelly parts include purchase of the transmission grid by the
State, thereby transferring revenue collection for the grid to the California
Department of Water Resources.? We discuss the whole package below.? However,
it is mind boggling to me how deep the State is willing to sink to avoid a
straight up rate increase.? I understand, based on recent e-mails you folks
have sent to me, that DWR will re-organize and take on a new name: California
Utility Buyers Agency (CUBA).? The head of CUBA will be S. Fidel Freeman, a
well-known advocate of public systems. Helping Fidel fiddle at the helm will
be Che Budraja, a jungle revolutionary who steals from the rich, and invests
the money in T-bills.? We look for great things from CUBA, not the least of
which will be cigars that have printed on the label, "The Attorney General
Has Determined that Retail Competition May Be Hazardous to Our Health".
As the state struggles to punch its way out of the mess, I have discovered a
solution to our energy woes whilst in the comfort of my own home. My proposal
is that we ship all our teenage children to Montana for the summer.? This
will conserve thousands of megawatts of in-state electric generating
capacity, bring down the price of alcohol, and make our roads safe.? The
other day, I entered the bedroom of my 13-year old boy, and noticed that
everything electrical was humming.? His computer was the main focus of his
attention at that moment, but at the same time his TV was on, the
electric-guitar amplifier was on standby ready, all the lights were on, and a
CD player was filling the air with the sounds of screeching voices.? One
megawatt may light 1,000 homes, so they say, but it only energizes 14
teenagers.? Send our teenagers to Montana (I have a name for this program (
Energy Conserpation: We Don't Give a ____ about Saving Energy) and put them
on the right side of the Western grid.? Plenty of coal power out there, and
the program will lessen the need for burning natural gas to produce
electricity.? When Montana gets tired of our 6 million California teenagers
because they emptied the state of Snicker Bars, Pepsi, and cellophane wrapped
junk food, we'll send them by bus to Mexico.? Our Governor and even President
Bush believe that all the power we be needin' is south of the border.?
Anyway, the dollar is strong relative to the peso, and we can feed our
beloved children snacks from Source Taco Bell with enough gorditas and
chalupas until the cows come home; which is soon.? When school re-starts in
the Fall, the summer rolling blackout threat ("The ISO is in Day 206 of a
Stage 3 Alert") will be over, and we can welcome home our new heroes.? It's a
plan.
ISO Governing Board Chairman Ghengis Kahn is reported to be constantly
reminding the ISO staff at Governing Board meetings that reality is an
important element of their new strategy.? I wonder how he would know.? And
PUC President Loretta "Let's Do" Lynch, the Darth Vader(ess) to Davis'
Dark-Side Emperor, is reported to be "loving her job" at the PUC.? I'm not
making this up.? She actually told the San Francisco Chronicle how much she
loves getting things back to the way they were before 1996.? I hear that when
she is done with electricity reform, she will be assigned to work on Civil
Rights.? Return that system back to circa 1950.
The way I see it, the State will enter into relatively costly long-term
contracts.? The effect will nail consumers to default utility service by
suspending direct access, and in just a few years we will be back to where we
were in 1994: high cost electricity against which businesses want an out
because spot wholesale prices will be below the long-term price benchmark.??
But this time we can take advantage of our 18/90 hindsight to craft a better
solution. I have a suggestion.? Let's gather together in advance
representatives of all segments of our business, and develop a memorandum of
understanding.? The MOU will spell out a new competitive market that allows
utilities, by then financially upright, to collect their "new" stranded
costs.? Consumers will be given the Province of British Columbia, soon to be
purchased by? Governor Davis as a peace offering to Harvey Rosenfield. All
the nuclear plants will be purchased by the state and operational control
will be turned over to the consumer advocates.? Everyone will be happy.? All
we need is a Republican Governor for California in 2004 we can rely upon to
enact the necessary legislation.
I am delighted to be back in Burrito-ville.? Phoenix was nice, the crowd was
great, our speakers were terrific, but I need my weekly slab of salty meat
and salsa.
Things in the People's Republic of California
?@@@ Dr. Davis' Miracle Cure
?@@@ Phoenix Principles are on the Table
?@@@ Is there a Credit Committee in your future?
?@@@ APX Announces Special Workshop on Feb 21
Things National
?@@@ FERC Kicks ISO Tariff Amendment 36 in the Chops
?@@@ Ohio Ushers in Retail Competition
Odds & Ends (_!_)
===================
Things in the People's Republic of California
?@@@ Dr. Davis' Miracle Cure
As I write this week's Burrito, the Governor and his aides are trying to
convince the Democratic Caucus in the state legislature that his plan has
legs.? If it had legs, then I wish it would run away.? Here are the major
points of Dr. Davis' plan as I heard it yesterday afternoon:
* Authorize DWR to acquire the high voltage transmission grid and/or other
assets,? enter into related agreements with utilities and contract for
operation of transmission with utilities
* Direct the PUC to amend and transfer the appropriate portion of retail
rates applicable to transmission from utilities to DWR
* Authorize revenue bond financing for acquisition and required improvements
of the transmission grid
The state's purchase of the transmission system is conditional upon PG&E's
and SCE's parent companies returning their Year 2000 tax refunds back to the
affected utility (about $1.5 billion); extending cost-based rates on native
generation for 5 additional years, banning the sale of generating assets; and
dismissing the pending rate litigation against the state in federal District
Court.
If the utilities are willing to accept the deal, then the state will direct
the PUC to establish a Dedicated Rate Component (DRC) to allow recovery of
portions of the utilities' unrecovered costs pursuant to negotiations with
the administration.? The state will authorize the utilities to sell revenue
bonds secured by the DRC.
Shoot me for saying this, but bankruptcy is beginning to look like an
attractive alternative.? Sure, we might not get all the money owed to the
power marketers and generators, but there is no guarantee of getting all the
money in the Gov's plan.? There are loopholes big enough through which you
can drive a 18-wheeler.? Further, shouldn't we do something to help the state
from swallowing itself?? The right thing to do is say, "Mr. Governor, thank
you so much.? You have tried mighty hard to wipe your hands clean of this
mess, but your plan just isn't enough.? We'll take our chances." I can't
believe the Wall Street investors and bondholders will encourage the
utilities to accept the offer, although they might.? The plan has too many
bureaucratic traps.? Too much that can go wrong, and incur potentially long
delays.? It smells bad.
What do you folks think?
Things in the People's Republic of California
?@@@ Phoenix Principles are on the Table
While the Governor is busy peddling his plan, last week in Phoenix, our group
also got involved with long-term and short-run solutions to California's
electricity market.? About 40 WPTF members had a discussion with a wide range
of ideas and options.? WPTF Chair, Rob Lamkin, and I facilitated the
discussion, and took notes of people's comments.? Over the weekend, Phil
Muller helped me draft the short-term principles in a summary document that
is three pages.? The meaning of "short-term" is recommendations that can be
implemented in time for Summer of 2001.
We are still working on the details, and as many of you know, we will
teleconference next week to discuss the recommendations, and hear your
comments. However, below is a thumbnail synopsis of the seven short-term
recommendations that we are currently considering:
* Electric price must be an incentive for energy conservation (Pleas for
voluntary conservation are not taken seriously unless accompanied by
meaningful price signals.)
* Rely on positive incentives to achieve demand reductions (Positive
incentives align the interests of consumers with the need to reduce
consumption and give consumers the ability to choose for themselves how to
participate.)
* Market participants in the Western states should agree to a self-imposed
"damage control" circuit-breaker mechanism for wholesale prices (Market
participants should individually establish for a limited time a voluntary
circuit-breaker wholesale price above which their company will not charge any
load serving entity.)
* Suppliers must be paid (Suppliers, who are still owed for deliveries made
last October, can not continue to sell power to California if they are not
confident that they will be paid.)
* Temporarily ease air-quality requirements to allow older power plants to
operate more hours during the year.
* Retain consumer choice options in selection of electricity suppliers (A
preferred alternative to the state becoming the only creditworthy party is
for consumers themselves to take on the credit responsibility by purchasing
directly from a third party supplier.)
* Suppliers' bid data should be released on a time-delayed basis to an
authorized monitor. (In order to satisfy the needs of both the public, and
the desires of the sellers, a repository of suppliers' bid data should be
kept by an authorized market monitor that is independent of both buyer and
seller influence.)
There are major policy changes for WPTF in a few of the bullet items, above.?
Therefore, the WPTF Board will need to hear from you either via e-mail or at
next week's teleconference.? We are anticipating that a Board vote will take
place next Thursday, at the earliest.
Things in the People's Republic of California
?@@@ Is there a Credit Committee in your future?
Get organized now, and avoid the rush.? It may come to pass that we will
learn a whole new facet of business.? That is, the rules and procedures of
bankruptcy.? I was introduced to Mr. Jonathon Rosenthal of Saybrook Capital
earlier this week.? Saybrook is an investment-banking firm in LA that
specializes in purchasing defaulted bonds from issuers going through
difficult workouts and bankruptcies.? They represented many creditors in the
Orange County bailout in 1994.? Remember that one?? Well, currently Saybrook
is representing MBIA, the largest bond insurance company in the world, and a
major creditor against the utilities if the utilities do not pay their
bondholders.? MBIA is interested in discussing with other potential creditors
the role of an informal credit committee prior to a petition for bankruptcy.
WPTF is playing a role by introducing Saybrook and MBIA to our membership.?
Towards that end, a teleconference call has been scheduled next Tuesday for
WPTF members, and Saybrook Capital.? Because it is a member's only call, and
limited to potential creditors, interested parties must contact me for the
call-in number, and time.? If you want to learn more about Saybrook Capital,
their website address is www.saybrook.net.
Things in the People's Republic of California
?@@@ APX Announces Special Workshop on Feb 21
The PX markets are gone, and the ISO transmission market is a mess.? There
are no adjustment bids to provide economic signals regarding SCs willingness
to alter their schedules at various congested intertie points.? John Stremel
of APX made a presentation in Phoenix, last week, at the WPTF general meeting
on a proposal that APX may undertake to fill the adjustment-bid gap.? The
folks at APX wanted me to alert you regarding the special meeting on February
21, and encourage you to attend the workshop at their offices in Santa Clara,
California.
Without a congestion market, all SCs stand to loose millions of dollars by
having schedules cut by the CAISO because there are no other short term
alternatives to congestion management.? The investment APX will require from
participants to develop an interim solution will be minor compared to the
financial impact without it.
APX is asking you to attend this meeting and to confirm your desire to help
fund a solution to be provided by APX.? Ultimately they will seek financial
commitments prior to developing a solution, but they believe it is feasible
to have a system in place well before the summer season.? Due to its interim
nature, APX will seek a flat fixed fee such that its planned abandonment will
not negatively impact APX with the more permanent change to congestion
management that will eventually be implemented by the CAISO.
Contact Michael L. Heinrich at APX for more information, 408-517-2159.? His
e-mail address is mheinrich@apx.com.
Things National
?@@@ FERC Kicks ISO Tariff Amendment 36 in the Chops
On Wednesday, FERC issued an order that you can download at
http://www3.ferc.fed.us/bulkpower/bulkpower.htm .? The order is in response
to several petitions, not the least of which is the ISO's proposed Tariff
Amendment 36.? The Amendment requested a relaxation of the credit requirement
of PG&E and SCE so that the ISO could continue ordering real-time generation
to meet the load of the two major load-serving entities.? FERC stated that
the credit requirement may be relaxed for the utilities' scheduling of their
own generation to meet their own load.? However, for all "net short"
purchases, the ISO can not relax the credit limit.? The FERC wisely counseled
the ISO to have a third party credit-worthy buyer sleeve the net short
schedules, such as DWR.? A credit worthy backer, said FERC, would encourage
more supply into the real-time market (e.g., supplemental energy) and reduce
the need for out of market calls.
It would be tempting to conclude that generators with ISO PGA's, given the
FERC Order, do not have to respond to ISO calls if a credit worthy buyer is
not available to back the ISO payments.? But I don't think that is what FERC
was saying.? FERC was careful to avoid stepping on the toes of the US
District Court that is addressing that very petition made by the ISO, and
under which a temporary restraining order is in effect mandating that all
generators with ISO PGA's comply with ISO orders.? That case continues today
in federal court in Sacramento.? However, the FERC Order did do two things.?
One, if removed the risk that generators had the burden to sell to the ISO
even if the buyers were not credit worthy.? Two, it affirmed that
"reasonable" price is in FERC's authority, not the power buyer, i.e., DWR.?
Although not stated directly, DWR had been chanting in word and deed that it
wouldn't pay prices that in their sole discretion were unreasonable.? That is
the type of uncertainty that can stop a market stone cold.
Maybe in next week's Burrito we will have a matrix of legal suits filed on
behalf of or against our members, and the state.? It would make things so
much easier to understand.? You can't tell the players without a program.
Things National
?@@@ Ohio Ushers in Retail Competition
Green Mountain's Rick Counihan is excited about a news release regarding a
community aggregation deal that his company is entering in Ohio, even as
California is moving
to end such possibilities.
Green Mountain Energy Company was selected to serve over 400,000 Ohio
electricity customers in the country,s largest-ever energy aggregation
contract.? The selection was made by the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council
(NOPEC), a governmental, public electricity buying group formed to serve
nearly 100 communities in the area surrounding Cleveland.
Under the letter of understanding, NOPEC and Green Mountain Energy Company
will enter into a six-year supply contract.? With the addition of these new
Ohio customers, Green Mountain Energy Company,s total customer base will
surpass 500,000 across deregulated markets in California, Pennsylvania, New
Jersey and Connecticut.? The Company received regulatory approval in January
to enter the Texas market later this year.
Under the terms of the letter of understanding, the NOPEC and Green Mountain
Energy Company supply contract will provide for the Company to begin serving
customers in September, 2001.
Odds & Ends (_!_)
Today my wife and I played hooky.? It was a belated Valentine's Day
celebration.? We took to the beautiful Napa Valley and enjoyed a three-hour
lunch on the Napa Valley Wine Train.? I highly recommend the journey.? The
food is superb, the train is a classic, and watching the valley of wineries
unfold to the rocking motion of the train is incredibly relaxing.? Nothing in
the world, not even our state energy crisis meant a thing during today's
adventure.
The train speaks to another era - a world that we might vaguely remember from
our childhood.? Nothing like it exists in our daily lives today.? Iron,
steel, brass, and wood paneling are everywhere.? The girth of the train cars
and engines are unlike the plastic moldings that coat our automobiles,
computers, and modern day tools.? Dining in a dome car with heavy sterling
silverware, starched white linen, attentive waiters and waitresses, and
classic cuisine lifts you from the humdrum of fast food to another time and
place.? In short, it was a thankful break from a stress-filled reality that
is taking all of us down.? Don't forget to let go every now and then. Okay?
Jobs, jobs, jobs.? It seems that many of you folks are changing jobs, and
others of you are eagerly trying to find people.? The demise of the PX
certainly provides the rest of us with some very qualified candidates.? I
encourage those of you trying to hire employees to post in the Burrito the
positions you are trying to fill.? Also, those of you looking for new
opportunities should drop me a Burrito line, and tell me what you are looking
for.? We might as well make the search as easy as possible.
Speaking of new jobs, Marcie Milner, formerly of Enron's Phoenix office
recently switched to Coral Energy, and relocated to Coral's La Jolla,
California office.? Best of luck to you, Marcie.? Marcie's new phone number
is 858-320-1506.
This week's humor injection is from Randy Young at Pinnacle West in Phoenix.?
Randy, we didn't see you on the golf course last week when we were in
Phoenix, but we'll accept your contribution any way.
=========================
Divine Advice
A businessman was in a great deal of trouble. His business was failing, he
had put everything he had into the business, he owed everybody - it was so
bad he was even contemplating suicide. As a last resort he went to a priest
and poured out his story of tears and woe.
When he had finished, the priest said, "Here's what I want you to do: Put a
beach chair and your Bible in your car and drive down to the beach. Take the
beach chair and the Bible to the water's edge, sit down in the beach chair,
and put the Bible in your lap.
Open the Bible; the wind will riffle the pages, but finally the open Bible
will come to rest on a page. Look down at the page and read the first thing
you see. That will be your answer, that will tell you what to do."
A year later the businessman went back to the priest and brought his wife and
children with him. The man was in a new custom-tailored suit, his wife in a
mink coat, the children shining. The businessman pulled an envelope stuffed
with money out of his pocket, gave it to the priest as a donation in thanks
for his advice. The priest recognized the benefactor, and was curious.
"You did as I suggested?" he asked.
"Absolutely," replied the businessman.
"You went to the beach?"
"Absolutely."
"You sat in a beach chair with the Bible in your? lap?"
"Absolutely."
"You let the pages riffle until they stopped?"
"Absolutely."
"And what were the first words you saw?"
"Chapter 11."
==========================
The way things are going with high wholesale prices, and the utilities'
accumulated debt, the utilities are so broke they may need to file Chapter
10.5.
Have a great (holiday) weekend.? I'll be in Las Vegas for my son's ice hockey
tournament.? Never a dull moment.
gba
?