24 May 2001, 08:12 UTC
RE: Experience In commissioning GE 7FA's & Slow/Insufficient TDI
- From
- Kay Mann kay.mann@enron.com
- To
- John G Rigby
- Date
- Thu, 24 May 2001 01:12:00 -0700 (PDT)
As far as I know the commissioning period we have in the current LM contracts still works for the LMs. I haven't heard any differently. You just plug those things in, right Scott? From the owner/power seller standpoint, the predictability is more important than the time period (within reason, of course). No matte what we have on LDs with GE, the penalty for not moving megawatts will be more. As for standard of conduct, do we have language in the warranty section about how the service techs have to work? Maybe something similiar would be work? The discussion shows that it is a good idea to get them committed to performing the TD of I at the time we sign up to buy the turbines. ckm
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
John G Rigby@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 05/24/2001 07:54 AM To: Bill Williams/ENRON@enronXgate@ENRON cc: Scott Dieball/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Kay Mann/Corp/Enron@Enron Subject: RE: Experience In commissioning GE 7FA's & Slow/Insufficient TDI Good point on the LM's- I will make that point, at this time I think the baseline is 7FAs- and the time should be shortened for LM's. Unfortunately I do not think that EECC has corporate history on the 7FA's commissioning time- I think NEPCO does. As to the EPC contractor wanting a similar cure time, in effect the commissioning period will have to be built into his Guaranteed Completion Date. This does not mean that GE gets all this time to commission, it de facto can be shorter or longer, what it does do is sets the mark in the sand for one of the criteria that must be met before GE is exposed to Takeover LD's because the GE equipment will not meet Specific Performance Guarantees or operate reliabily thus causing the EPC Contractor to be late. (slightly run on sentence-whew) As such it is not a GE slowness LD. As to there not being enough TDI of people or their being inept thus causing a delay. A valid concern-and perhaps we can pin GE for. I am struggling with what to use as a quantitative standard against which we could assess Take Over LDs. It is almost like good/bad art, you know it when you see it. Scott and I can try making late, insufficient or inept TDI services as (iii) in Section 10.3.2 (3rd reason for trigging Take Over LD's)- but without some standard it will be tought to reach an agreement with GE and tougher to enforce. I welcome your creative thoughts. I would expect GE to rail against this. Scott and Kay- Thoughts? Bill Williams/ENRON@enronXgate 05/23/2001 06:13 PM To: John G Rigby/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Subject: RE: Experience In commissioning GE 7FA's One thing for me - this contract will not just be for 7FA's. The LMs have much shorter fire and ready to go times (days to weeks at most), and to allow a generic move to 45 days could put aeroderivative gas turbine projects in jeopardy with regards to schedule. I must confess I do not have the 7FA experience. EE&CC should be able to back these numbers up. I suspect this may be a TDI issue as well. GE may be having fewer qualified Technical consultants to cover the onslaught of construction - contributing to the request to extend to 45 days. Note, if we go to 45 days for the Seller, the EPC contractor will want the same time period to remedy. -----Original Message----- From: Rigby, John Sent: Wednesday, May 23, 2001 3:29 PM To: Williams, Bill; larson Gene@ENRON; haas Dan@ENRON Subject: Experience In commissioning GE 7FA's One of the provisions in the "Standard GE- World Hunger" deals with GE's exposure to Take Over Liquidated Damages. The provisions reads as set oiut below.: (it is not final, we are struggling over (e) and (g). GE wants to change 30 days in (d) to 45 days - they say that their average time to go from first roll to complete Unit commissioning is 53 days- They will send some info on this to Bill W and me. Do any of you have recent experience in the first roll to completion of commissioning 7FAs either in simple cycle or combined cycle that I can use to confirm or refute tha 45 days is reasonable? 10.3.2 Takeover Liquidated Damages . Purchaser may assess and Seller agrees to pay liquidated damages (the &Takeover Liquidated Damages8) as set forth in Exhibit B-6, Section B.6.3, for each day that the Facility fails to achieve Takeover by the Time for Completion as a result of any or all of the following: (a) a the Unit is unable to be commissioned and/or operated reliably (such inability being within Seller,s sole responsibility as defined herein), but only after the expiration of the Commissioning Period; or (b) a the Unit demonstrating performance below the Specific Performance Levels, Assessment of such Takeover Liquidated Damages is subject to the following: (c) Purchaser elects at its sole discretion not to place a the Unit in Commercial Operation; (d) Purchaser allows [thirty (30) days] from first fired roll of the Units Unit to complete Unit commissioning check outs, any needed replacement, adjustments or corrections to make the Units Unit ready for testing (the &Commissioning Period8); (e) [Purchaser makes reasonable efforts to provide the necessary time and operating loads for Seller and Purchaser to commission and check out the Units Unit. Seller,s time and load requirement shall not be to the exclusion of the needs of other Facility equipment being commissioned. Purchaser shall coordinate the most advantageous utilization of time and assets whenever conflicting requirements exist and such situations shall not be deemed delay by Purchaser]; (f) Subject to (g) below, Purchaser may not assess Takeover Liquidated Damages prior to the expiry of the Commissioning Period; (g) [In the event Seller fails to use its best efforts to minimize time to make corrections, adjustments or repairs to the deficiently performing Unit during the Commissioning Period, Purchaser shall have the right to void the Commissioning Period and assess Takeover Liquidated Damages without regard for the period afforded by the Commissioning Period]; (h) Purchaser provides prompt oral notice of delays affecting commissioning; (i) Purchaser provides Seller its commissioning schedule no less than forty five (45) days prior to commencement of commissioning on the first Unit and provides periodic updates thereto; (j) In the event Purchaser is not subject to similar delay liquidated damages with Owner, then Seller will not be subject to Takeover Liquidated Damages; and (k) In the event that Purchaser is subject to similar delay liquidated damages with Owner, then Seller shall pay Takeover Liquidated Damages in accordance with this Section 10.3.2. In the event that the Purchaser is Owner, subsections (j) and (k) of this Section 10.3.2 shall not be applicable. However, to the extent that the Purchaser is an entity subject to delay liquidated damages associated with the Facility, subsections (j) and (k) of this Section 10.3.2 shall be applicable.